A Thought on Income Inequality

Income inequality has become a popular Progressive trope with which to demonize Republicans, Conservatives, and the United States generally over our alleged insensitivity to the plight of our poor.  Notwithstanding the immorality of capping whatever it is we use for income in order to take from the better off and give those takings to the poorer off, there are practical failures in this meme, as well.

One source of information that clarifies this matter comes from Stanford University’s Hoover Institution in the form of a paper by Kip Hagopian and Lee Ohanian, titled The Mismeasure of Inequality.  Following are some highlights from that paper; RTWT.

…the Census Bureau, which uses what it calls “money income” in its measurement of income inequality.  Money income, which is the definition of income typically used in public references to inequality, consists of cash income only, does not subtract taxes, and excludes the value of noncash transfer payments (such as nutritional assistance, Medicare, Medicaid, and public housing), as well as many other components of income.  In addition to transfer payments, which are a substantial portion of income at the low end of the income scale, some of the other missing components of income are: employer-provided fringe benefits (primarily retirement benefits and health insurance, which can amount to as much as 30 percent of income), capital gains, imputed rent from owner-occupied housing, and increases in the value of home equity

And

Based on this more relevant definition [which included all those exclusions], income inequality declined 1.8 percent during the sixteen-year period between 1993 and 2009….

But even using the Gini coefficient, a popular “measure” of income inequality—which uses only money income as its measure—income inequality in the US only grew by 10% over the last nearly 30 years.

But it also turns out that income isn’t the only way to measure what’s intended with “money income” or “total income,” nor is it necessarily even the best measure.

…almost singular focus on income as a measure of economic well-being, when there is a clear consensus among economists that the best measure of living standards over the long term is not income, but consumption.  Focusing on consumption rather than income provides a very different picture of inequality.  … [A]ccording to the BLS [Bureau of Labor Statistics], during the fifteen-year period between 1986 and 2001, consumption inequality went down slightly; from a Gini of .283 to a Gini of .280.

Consumer Expenditure Surveys say much the same thing: consumption is relatively equal across incomes.  Even at that,

[C]urrent methodologies measure only market consumption rather than total consumption, which is the sum of both market (purchased) and nonmarket (home-produced) goods.  This is important because lower-income households consume a disproportionate amount of goods produced in the home (what economists call “home production”), including home-cooked meals, household-provided child care, and household home improvements and maintenance. Economists have estimated that home production is around one-third of GDP, yet this form of consumption is not counted in the total when measuring consumption inequality.

And none of this addresses the dynamic nature of income and consumption, what’s called economic mobility, or the ability of folks to move (or down) the economic ladder.  Here, we are wanting: upward economic mobility requires, among other things, job availability and, for homeowning job hunters, the ability to sell their homes pursuant to a job-related relocation.

Property Rights, Local Version

Winona, MN, has decided it has the right to determine what a man can do with his private property and do so without such trivial acts as seizing it under eminent domain and paying “just compensation” for it.  The 5th Amendment doesn’t apply to this town’s City Council, it seems.

Winona’s “government” has decided that only 30% of the homeowners on any city block will be allowed to rent their homes, and the city will decide which 30% will receive this boon.

Aside from the legal question of this property taking, there are practical effects.  Winona is a university town, and many of its city blocks are within student-commute of the university.  Renting a house by groups of students, or renting a room or two in a house by a student (letting a room counts the whole house against the 30% limit), was a way for a student to find cheap housing.  No more.

Renting a house, or a room or two, was a way for a homeowner to pick up some additional income, an especially valuable thing in this economy of ours.  No more.

Renting a house when it was for sale, but not selling, was a way for a homeowner to pick up some extra income and perhaps relocate to a new job and be able to afford housing in the new location.  No more.

The Winona City Council members have decided they will make these decisions—mere homeowners are unequal to the task—and they will limit to whom they grant their blessing.

It’s a twofer: arrogant and unconstitutional.

Toward An Affordable Health Insurance Industry

John Cochran, University of Chicago Booth School of Business Professor of Finance, among other positions, is on the right track, but he’s wide of the mark in some critical respects.

The unraveling of the Affordable Care Act presents a historic opportunity for change.  Its proponents call it “settled law,” but as Prohibition taught us, not even a constitutional amendment is settled law—if it is dysfunctional enough, and if Americans can see a clear alternative.

And

Only deregulation can unleash competition.  And only disruptive competition, where new businesses drive out old ones, will bring efficiency, lower costs, and innovation.

That’s plainly true, and he goes on to tout further—correctly IMNSHO—the advantages of a free market in the delivery of health insurance and the delivery of health care services.  However, he has some misconceptions in the extent to which those two industries should be allowed to go in a free market.

Health insurance should be…lifelong and guaranteed-renewable, meaning you have the right to continue with no unexpected increase in premiums if you get sick.

This isn’t insurance: it eliminates the concept of premiums being based on the risk being transferred.  Or, it is insurance, and the risk being transferred and the fee charged for accepting that transfer (the premium) will be elevated to account for the higher risk involved in that mandated longer-term risk acceptance as well as the changed risk factor represented by having gotten sick.  And sick again with the same thing.  And again.

Insurance should protect wealth against large, unforeseen, necessary expenses, rather than be a wildly inefficient payment plan for routine expenses.

This is blatantly normative and not at all related to the competition of free markets.  There will, indeed, be customers who want policies that cover “routine expenses;” it’s not Cochran’s—or government’s—place to proscribe these because they disagree that such policies have utility.

Rather than a mandate for employer-based groups, we should transition to fully individual-based health insurance.

Again, no.  This is another interference with a competitive free market.  It’s certainly true that the (tax-policy encouraged) “mandate” for employer-based groups is a distortion of the market.  However, rather than simply distorting the market in a different direction, let that market—the individuals who aggregate into that market—decide whether group plans are viable.

Aside from that, there is the matter of preexisting conditions.  The only risk that can be transferred here is the timing of the next flare up of the condition.  Forcing folks with these conditions onto the individual market will simply artificially elevate the premiums they’ll have to pay for the transfer of that risk.  Group plans would allow the risk acceptors, those insurance companies, to spread the timing across a risk pool larger than one, which would allow them to charge a lower premium—with a truly free, competitive market forcing them to compete for the business, and so exerting further downward pressure on the premiums charged.

Current group plans can convert to individual plans, at once or as people leave.  Since all members in a group convert, there is no adverse selection of sicker people.

This isn’t a free market—it’s a mandate to move away from a policy structure that many will want to retain, even if the coverages available within a particular group might change under free market imperative.  The free market also will handle the question of adverse selection just fine—that pricing matter.

Distressing to Whom?

Scientists have zapped an electrical current to people’s brains to erase distressing memories, part of an ambitious quest to better treat ailments such as mental trauma, psychiatric disorders and drug addiction.

In an experiment, patients were first shown a troubling story, in words and pictures.  A week later they were reminded about it and given electroconvulsive therapy, formerly known as electroshock.  That completely wiped out their recall of the distressing narrative.

“It’s a pretty strong effect.  We observed it in every subject,” said Marijn Kroes, neuroscientist at Radboud University Nijmegen in the Netherlands and lead author of the study, published Sunday in the journal Nature Neuroscience.

And

The hope is that one day it may be possible to selectively eliminate a person’s unwanted memories or associations linked to smoking, drug-taking or emotional trauma.

This is an extremely promising tool for helping folks overcome serious troubles.  Like many powerful tools, though, it can be very dangerous.

“Distressing memories.”  Distressing for whom?  The individual? Or Government?  Rudimentary efforts have already been tried: the Soviet Union’s Gulag.  It’s been warned of for a long time: Clockwork Orange.

Now that this sort of thing is coming to fruition, the tool wants, badly, close monitoring and control, and not only by our government.

A Thought on Immigration and Amnesty

The immigration debate in Washington boils down to a debate over how to handle the country’s 11 million or so illegal residents.  A Washington Post editorial over the weekend suggested a compromise: let them stay but don’t give them citizenship.

No.  Either we believe in redemption and rehabilitation, or we don’t.  We do believe in it, at least tacitly, for other criminal behavior—capital murder and sex offenses nearly the only things that are excepted.  And sex offenses get heinous acts.  Nearly all other offenses against us or our society have endpoints to the penalty exacted, and then the offender pretty much is allowed to go on his way with a clean slate.

A man enters our country illegally, though, and after that single and singular crime, he makes himself a productive member of his community.  On what basis do we insist that this crime is so heinous that he must pay for it for the rest of his life—the he must be denied any opportunity to earn citizenship in our country?  On what basis do we say his illegal entry—his sole crime (and it is a crime, no doubt)—is of a piece with capital murder or molesting a child?

Pay a price for having entered illegally?  Pay a price for having violated a traffic law?  Certainly.  And that means there’s no amnesty, either for the illegal entry or the traffic violation.  But there’s also more to this than just the utilitarianism of punishment for a crime and calling it square.  There’s the morality of it—redemption and rehabilitation.  We give that much to our felons, why not also to a man whose only crime is that he came illegally into our country to make a better life for himself and his family?  No.  Allowing a path along which to earn citizenship, a path that includes a price for illegal entry, isn’t amnesty.

The man who comes here and makes his way, who becomes a contributing member of our society—that’s the kind of man we want to immigrate.  That’s the kind of initiative, of drive, of work ethic, of desire to make a better life that brings creativity to our economy and to our nation.