Obamatalk on the Global Stage

Iran has perpetrated a deliberate, calculated act of war against the United States with the just publicized plot to murder the Saudi Ambassador to the United States, and subsequent action to blow up the Saudi Arabian and Israeli embassies, all on American soil (an attack magnified in its perfidy by being attacks on diplomats, who everywhere but in barbarism are proof against assault, as diplomats are the only way nations have to speak with each other aside from open war).

I wrote here about the laughing stock our President has made of himself on the world stage.  This is the latest example of the dangers to which Obama’s—what: foolishness? repugnant timidity?—have exposed our country.  Other examples include the Christmas bomber (AKA underwear bomber), whose attempt at terrorism only failed due to his own incompetence; the New York subway bombing attempt, which was foiled by skilled FBI agents; the New York Times Square parked car bombing attempt, which was foiled only by a couple of alert street vendors; the list goes on.  All of these have occurred in the last three years.  All of these garnered an Obama response of threats, finger-shaking, and efforts to “isolate” of Iran.

And this week, in the aftermath of a highly laudable and successful attack on the terrorist Anwar al-Awlaki, he’s actually apologizing, in all seriousness, to the family of another terrorist who was killed along with al-Awlaki for our misdeed in having killed that additional terrorist—a…man who, by his own words, is “proud to be a traitor to America.”

In the seven years between 9/11 and the beginning of the Obama administration, there were no further attempts against our country that weren’t preempted, or blocked, far from our borders.  One difference between then and now is that the prior administration took positive action against the terrorists associated with the destruction of the World Trade Center, the attack on the Pentagon, and the apparent attack on the White House, and against terrorism generally.

What is Obama’s response to Iran’s act of war?  Here it is, in his own words, as provided by Powerline:

So with respect to how we respond, our first step is to make sure that we prosecute those individuals that have been named in the indictment. And I will leave to the Attorney General the task of describing how that will proceed.

The second thing that we’re going to continue to do is to apply the toughest sanctions and continue to mobilize the international community to make sure that Iran is further and further isolated and that it pays a price for this kind of behavior.

and

…what you can expect is that we will continue to apply the sorts of pressure that will have a direct impact on the Iranian government until it makes a better choice….

His rationale for thinking this might actually be effective?  Again, his own words:

…we’ve been able to unify the international community in naming Iran’s misbehavior and saying that it’s got to stop and there are going to be consequences to its actions.

But, what consequences, for example; and, when, exactly?  This is just Obamatalk—empty threats and firm finger-shaking, with no intention of actually doing anything.

To be meaningful, consequences have to be capable of altering the target’s behavior in a direction favorable to us, not merely make us feel good.  Obama’s words have no deterrent capacity whatsoever; the terrorists and their sponsors know that all we’ll do in response—all the United States, the most powerful nation on Earth, on paper—has the courage to do, is bark and growl like an old dog.

Idle chit-chat, empty threats only alter the target’s behavior in this way: they fill the target with contempt for us, and they encourage the target to continue and to escalate.  Any street hood from Chicago knows this.  Surely, a community organizer from Chicago knows this, too.

Fair Share and Economic Mobility

Much has been made, in the last few years, of an apparent increasing concentration of wealth in the hands of a few, while the poor get poorer.  One result of this has been a demand that the rich should pay more taxes; they should pay “their fair share.”  Another result has been a general objection to the increasing wealth of those who are already wealthy; there should be a general redistribution of their wealth to the poor.

In addition to attempting to define what “their fair share” should be, it’s also useful to explore whether the wealth disparity in the US is really all that bad.

Let’s look first at the question of “fair share.”  I’ve written elsewhere that in 1999, the top 10% of Americans, by income, paid 66% of the total income taxes collected by the Federal government, while the bottom 50% paid 4% of the total; in 2008—after the Bush tax cuts that so favored the rich—the top 10% of Americans’ share had increased to 70% of the total income taxes, while the bottom 50%’s share had decreased to 3% of that total.  With the richest Americans’ share of the tax burden increasing, already, what is their “fair share?”

Further, when we look at actual income vs. taxes, we see this in 2008—again, after those Bush tax cuts “for the rich;” the disparity is even more startling.  The top 1% by income, who earned 20% of the total income in the US, paid nearly 40% of the total taxes paid by Americans.  That bottom 50%, who paid those 3%, actually earned nearly 13% of the nation’s total income.  Again, what is the “fair share” of the rich?  I suggest it’s already been met, and more.

Still, were the concentration of wealth and the associated wealth disparity static, there might be a valid beef, if only from the practical standpoint that such stationarity would contribute to stagnation in our economy, at the cost of continued improvement in well-being for us all.  But when we look at income mobility, we see no such stationarity.

When we look at minimum wage earners, for instance, we find that adults who earned at minimum wage levels over the period 1998 through 2006 did so only relatively briefly.  Then, rather than losing their income altogether, they moved on to better paying jobs.

We can look at this another way, too.  According to the Treasury Department’s “Income Mobility in the US from 1996 to 2005” report, the children of today’s poverty-level family are part of the next generation’s middle class families.  Today’s poor young man is tomorrow’s middle-aged middle class man.  Indeed, “80 percent of taxpayers had incomes in quintiles as high or higher in 2005 than they did in 1996, and 45 percent of taxpayers not in the highest income quintile moved up at least one quintile.” Further, the median incomes of those in the lower quintiles increased more than did the median incomes of the higher quintiles.  Not only are today’s poor a different group of people than yesterday’s, today’s poor are better off in absolute terms than were yesterday’s poor.

The movement runs both ways, as it must: relative movements are a zero-sum game.  Not only is yesterday’s poor man not today’s poor man, because yesterday’s poor man has gotten better off, relatively as well as absolutely, yesterday’s rich man is not today’s rich man: he’s lost ground relatively as well as absolutely.  “Among those with the very highest incomes in 1996—the top 1/100th of 1%—only 25% remained in this group in 2005….  [T]he real median income of these taxpayers declined over this period.”  It’s broader than that, too: 30% of those in the top quintile in income in 1996 had fallen to the next lower quintile by 2005, and nearly 3% had fallen all the way to the bottom quintile.

It seems that demands for the rich to pay “their fair share” are redundant; they already are.  It’s that bottom 50% that seems to be underpaying their “fair share.”  Further, demands for the class warfare of wealth redistribution would seem to be aimed at a moving target.  Our free market economy already is redistributing wealth, as Americans earn their way out of poverty, or lower middle class, or middle class, and enter those better off groups.  Demands to take wealth away from the rich are demands to take property away from those who’ve only just earned it with a lifetime of hard work and sweat.  And they are demands to deny that property to the children of these only newly successful.

The Progressive and the Law

The law be damned.  Constitution-schmonstitution.

We can’t have our way through democratic procedure, so we’ll just blow up democracy and rule by fiat.  Because We Know Better.

That’s Rep Jesse Jackson, Jr’s (Dem, IL) attitude, as reported in The Daily Caller yesterday.  He was holding forth on the virtues of Obama’s Stimulus Lite, that $500 billion “jobs” bill that failed a cloture vote in the Senate a couple of days ago.  But let’s let the good Representative speak for himself, with my commentary interspersed.

I hope the president continues to exercise extraordinary constitutional means, based on the history of Congresses that have been in rebellion in the past.  He’s looking administratively for ways to advance the causes of the American people, because this Congress is completely dysfunctional.

I’m not aware of any Congresses that have been in rebellion in the past.  I must have slept through that part of my junior high Civics.  But what about that alleged dysfunction?  The “dysfunction” stems from Congressmen actually have the gall to honor their commitment to their constituents to work to hold down government spending (this “jobs” bill wanted to spend $175 billion we don’t have and to continue to pay people for not working, rather than stimulating job growth) and to hold down taxes (the bill wants to “pay for” those $175 billion by adding a surtax of 5.6% on “millionaires,” the Progressives’ more new taxes mantra).  And this elides objections to the Progressives’  class war, which they’re using as justification for the taxes.

President Obama tends to idealize—and rightfully so—Abraham Lincoln, who looked at states in rebellion and he made a judgment that the government of the United States, while the states are in rebellion, still had an obligation to function….  On several occasions now, we’ve seen…the Congress is in rebellion, determined…to wreck or ruin at all costs.

The Progressive is accusing the Congress, for doing its duty with its power of the purse, of committing Treason (the Constitution’s definition (Art III, Sect 3)) by being in open rebellion against the President of the United States—how, exactly?  The Congress isn’t rolling over and giving the President everything he’s demanding is the treasonous, rebellious behavior.

Listen to the video, too; it’s highly instructive.  We have, for instance, this from Rep Jackson:

The President had an opportunity to exercise Section 4 of the 14th Amendment; he chose not to.

This is what the 14th Amendment actually says:

The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned. But neither the United States nor any State shall assume or pay any debt or obligation incurred in aid of insurrection or rebellion against the United States, or any claim for the loss or emancipation of any slave; but all such debts, obligations and claims shall be held illegal and void.

Notice that there is nothing authorizing the President to create new or to increase existing debt by Executive fiat.

Rep Jackson’s entire performance is a breathtaking, Ezra Klein-esque ignorance of the Constitution (which is understandable; it is, after all, so old).

On the other hand, Rep Jackson insists that the Congress “is in rebellion;” how can any debt that it creates or increases be valid at all?  Hmm….

The Campaign and My Choice

With this post, I conclude my short series consisting of my analyses of the Republican candidates for the nomination for President.  To recap, I limited my discussions to three candidates: Mitt Romney, Herman Cain, and Rick Perry.  The structure of this series consisted of a collection of posts concerning what I didn’t like about the candidates and then a series of what I did like about them.  This is my endorsement of a single candidate.

None of the candidates have adequately addressed the matter of illegal immigration and of illegal aliens.  Some have taken a hard line toward sealing and controlling our borders, and this is entirely appropriate.  However, controlled borders are only half the problem.  The vast majority of the illegal aliens are present in the United States because they want a chance to participate in the American dream, to avail themselves of the benefits of America’s exceptional culture.  They would be highly productive and valuable citizens were they given the chance.  Yet we throw up roadblocks after barriers after obstacles to impede them.  It can take a couple of months to get a non-immigrant visa; B-1 visas can take a month, H-1B visas as long as six months, and the H-1Bs have very low annual quotas. It shouldn’t be that hard to enter the United States legally.  There should be border crossing stations every mile along our border (which, just incidentally, would put the human traffickers—the mules, and worse—immediately out of business).  Visa approval should occur in days, not months (in today’s computerized world, it shouldn’t take months to run a background check), and there should be no quotas.  With none of the candidates addressing this aspect of illegal immigration, their handling of immigration generally is, in this context, I think a wash.

Perry: Perry’s attack ad campaign is tactically foolish and so calls in to question his judgment.  The Republican candidates should be running against Obama and touting their own superior qualities for that task; they should not be attacking each other and giving the Progressives ammunition for the Presidential campaign.

When asked, in Tuesday’s Dartmouth University debate, to be specific about his economic plan, Perry repeatedly said he’d unroll his plan “over the next three days.”  When Romney asked him directly, he responded that Romney had been developing his plan over the last five years, whereas Perry had been developing his only over the last 6 weeks.  This was pretty weak and smacked of excuse-making, especially since Perry has been governor of the second largest state for the last 11 years (and he’s not yet passed up a chance to remind us all of that), and so he has considerable experience at developing economic plans.

Finally, Perry doesn’t communicate well in a fluid environment.  A man who can’t think on his feet isn’t Presidential material.  A Texan who can’t is disappointing.

Romney: Romney’s responses concerning Romneycare and Obamacare in the Dartmouth debate increased my confidence both in his willingness and his ability to repeal Obamacare were he to be elected President, and it showed an ability to respond to Democrats’ attempts at assimilation of Romneycare into Obamacare.

He also has a 160 page Economic Plan, with 59 policy proposals in it.  However, it isn’t that hard to fix our economy and government’s interference with it by limiting spending to less than revenues.  This isn’t rocket science.  This is a Technocrat is overcomplexifying things.

His evasive generalities in response to other economic questions, though (Cain: “can you name some points in your 59-point complex economic plan?”  Romney: <mumble>), indicate to me that he still hasn’t very many specifics fully developed.  And he doesn’t seem willing to get specific; would he take a stand on specifics in dealing with Congress?  Yeah, yeah, I said he’d take a stand here, but his Dartmouth performance makes me wonder about his constancy.  His campaign has been one of avoiding mistakes rather than of advancing concrete ideas.

Finally, at a campaign stop the day before the Dartmouth debate, The Daily Caller asked Romney whether current AG Eric Holder should resign over his performance with DoJ’s Fast and Furious.  Romney’s answer was lengthy and evasive—it took him 35 seconds to say he wasn’t going to say.  When the question was repeated later to Romney’s aide, Eric Ferhnstrom, the aide said Romney “prefers [press] availabilities like this, where his thinking is more organized, as opposed…answering questions on the fly. He doesn’t think that’s conducive to a good conversation.”  See my remarks above about thinking on one’s feet.

Romney is no Eric Cantor, or Paul Ryan.  Or Newt Gingrich.

Cain: Cain’s up from the ranks experience in small businesses and large are a serious plus: in a free market, the entrepreneurs, small businesses, and large businesses are in a positive feedback loop, and that’s a strong economy with a plethora of opportunity.  Cain understands the limits to government effectiveness in that environment, and he understands the necessary fixes, simple fixes.

I like his view of making every section of government justify its budget in detail.  That’s not zero-based budgeting, but it’s close enough, and it’ll work well if not done too often.  He’ll never pull it off, but the threat of it will have its own benefit.

In the Dartmouth debate, he faced serious criticism for the first time: now he’s one of the front-runners, and so a target.  His ability to keep his humor, while providing specifics (he was subject to an “insider” cheap shot when he refused to violate a confidence concerning a couple of possible nominees for his administration) rather than evasion or generalities was refreshing.  And he was able to defend those specifics.  On the other hand, he wasn’t often seriously challenged: “turn 9-9-9 upside down; the Devil is in the details?”  How cute.

His consumption tax is a serious problem, but that can be worked.  Overall, his tax proposal represents a lower set of rates for individuals and businesses, and that’s all to the good: the more of our money left in our hands, under our judgment, the better off our country will be.

In the end, my preference is Herman Cain.  He has the best ideas, and he does, if not the best job, at least a very solid job of presenting and selling them.  And, crassly, it’ll be difficult for the Progressives to keep playing their race card on anyone who disagrees with Obama.  Although we might hear mutterings of Uncle Tom, or Oreo.

The Campaign and Herman Cain, II

With this post, I continue a short series consisting of my analyses of the Republican candidates for the nomination for President.  To recap, I’m limiting my discussions to three candidates: Mitt Romney, Herman Cain, and Rick Perry.  The structure of this series consists of a collection of posts concerning what I don’t like about the candidates and then a series of what I do like about them.  I’ll conclude with my endorsement of a single candidate.  At this point I’m in the series of what I like, and here I’ll talk about what I like about Herman Cain.

Business Experience: Mr Cain’s experience runs the gamut: he came up from the ranks, running individual restaurants, then a chain of restaurants, then a restaurant association, and finally a large corporation.  Cain also is fully capable of turning around failing businesses, and doing that without government handouts.  He rescued both Pillsbury’s chain of Burger Kings in the Philadelphia area and a failing Godfather’s Pizza corporation, returning them both to profitability.

His experience in business, also, is concrete: he didn’t come in at the top and learn business only from senior management’s perspective; he learned it from the small business perspective, also, with that individual restaurant experience.  Cain began with an actual working man’s experience.

Economy: On the whole, he’s got it right on taxes and on spending.  His 9-9-9 program has that serious flaw of a consumption tax, but the program reduces tax rates for both corporations and individuals.  Further, it greatly broadens the tax base so everyone does, indeed, “pay their fair share.”

He’s not afraid to cut, either: his opening move is an across the board cut which will reduce spending substantially, and with everyone’s ox being gored by the cuts, it’ll be difficult for anyone to resist without their being exposed as plainly addicted to spending for its own sake.  This is front and center on his campaign Web site:

Every federal agency, every government program and expenditure must be reviewed and revised with a keen eye and a red pen. Leaders should be willing to shrink budgets by target percentages….

On the matter of the nation’s debt, Cain is equally clear:

While both parties can claim some political victory in this compromise [to raise the debt ceiling in exchange for some trivial spending cuts], the American people got short-changed. The debt ceiling will be raised, opening the door for further debt ceiling and tax increases with no sign of treatment for the addiction to spending in Washington.

Communication: He’s plain-spoken with a sense of humor.  He’s fully capable of explaining his positions with brevity and clarity, as he’s shown repeatedly in the formats of the early primary debates.

Character:  Here is Cain in his own words:

One of the most important lessons Dad taught us was not to feel like victims. He never felt like a victim; he never talked like a victim.  And both of our parents taught us not to think that the government owed us something. They didn’t teach us to be mad at this country.

This, of course, is anathema to the incumbent Progressive government, which believes that government is the answer to every problem, and that America isn’t so hot, anyway.