The Campaign and Mitt Romney, II

With this post, I continue a short series consisting of my analyses of the Republican candidates for the nomination for President.  To recap, I’m limiting my discussions to three candidates: Mitt Romney, Herman Cain, and Rick Perry.  The structure of this series consists of a collection of posts concerning what I don’t like about the candidates and then a series of what I do like about them.  I’ll conclude with my endorsement of a single candidate.  At this point I’m in the series of what I like, and here I’ll talk about what I like about Governor Mitt Romney.

Experience: Governor Romney is one of the few candidates in this field who has actual business experience.  He’s run businesses, and he’s met payroll.  With Bain Capital, Romney expanded the company’s size and finances with successful leveraged buyouts, turning around those companies and making them successful (their impending financial failure making them ripe targets for such acquisitions), and then selling them on the open market.  On criticism that such buyouts and resales often cost jobs, he has responded, correctly, that the surviving companies were sounder and were successful—without Bain’s corrections, the companies would have failed entirely, and all of the employees would have lost their jobs.   His experience is broad, too: he’s successfully run nonprofits.  He became CEO of the Salt Lake Organizing Committee in the wake of corruption allegations in the Salt Lake Olympic Committee and of a financial shortfall for those winter games that threatened their removal to another venue.  He turned around the situation and made the 2002 Winter Games a financial and competition success.

Nor is Romney a bailout artist.  After his success at Bain Capital, he was recruited (back) to Bain & Company, where he had started his business career (and which had helped get Bain Capital started), with the purpose of rescuing that now failing company.  He restructured the company and its cost structure and returned it to profitability within a year—without need of bailout funding from any source.

Education:  Governor Romney has stressed that the Federal government legitimately can play only a limited role in the education of our children, not the massively intrusive role of the current (and recent) administrations.

Romney also supports school choice and, within the current tax system (as opposed to a flat tax, or the tax system proposed by Herman Cain), a tax credit for the expenses incurred by those who prefer home schooling to the current failures of our public school systems.  Also, as Governor of Massachusetts, he has vetoed legislation that would have hindered the growth of charter schools.

Finally, Romney favors immersion in English for our immigrants, rather than committing scarce funding and resources to bi-lingual education.

Flip-Flops: For all his reputation as a flipper, he doesn’t seem to be afraid to take a stand.  The Left likes to conflate his evolution of policy with flip-flop, and sometimes they’re right.  But sometimes they’re wrong.  His positions on abortion and on Romneycare are examples.  He’s made no bones about the evolution of his views on abortion: as a private citizen, he could view the matter from the outside and take an abortion-tolerant position; however, once he became governor and had to face this matter of life directly, his position evolved.  On the matter of Romneycare, he makes no bones of his belief that this program was—and is—right for Massachusetts, but that it’s not right for every state, nor is it right for the federal government to impose it.   A flipper changes positions with the political winds; that’s a different behavior than a position legitimately evolving—and not changing back.  Romney’s position on these matters—whether we agree or disagree with him—is quite clear and steady.

Finally, here’s Romney’s take on taking a stand in the context of vetoes, including those he knows he can’t sustain, courtesy of The New York Times:

[P]eople used to say to me…“Governor, you’ve had a lot of vetoes and a lot of them get overridden. Most of them get overridden. That weakens your power.” I said, “Baloney. I want people to know what I stand for. And I’m going to veto items even if that 85% [Democratic] legislature goes out and spends it, I’m going to veto it to make sure people know what is right and what is wrong for the leadership in our state.”

Communication: Romney is an effective communicator who can clearly present his positions, and he can debate well.  As I’ve written elsewhere in this series, the best ideas in the world have no value if they can’t be offered in a coherent manner.

Why Should Teachers Have Tenure?

Caution: long post….

Tenure for teachers (for the purposes of exposition, I include teachers in the K-12 grades and professors in colleges and universities under the rubric “teacher”) is job security to the point of having the job for life.  But does tenure serve any useful purpose?  That is, given this security, do we get better quality teaching?

The purpose of the job of teaching is to teach—that is, to produce quality students, students able to move to the next level of learning, and ultimately to leave school and embark on their own lives as self-sufficient, capable, productive adults.  Before receiving tenure, teachers must serve a probationary period that can extend, depending on the particular institution, from one or two years of teaching to as many as seven years before they can be considered for tenure.  Does tenure further this purpose?

The advantages claimed for tenure are these: academic freedom, safety against arbitrary dismissal, preservation of experience and skills accrued over a career of teaching.  We’ll address each in the following paragraphs.

Tenure fosters development of original thinking because the teachers have the safety of their job within which to exercise a large measure of autonomy in exploring new ideas, developing new concepts.

To gain tenure, though, the probationary teacher must conform to the established thinking and performance bounds of the tenured faculty and of the administrators who, together, determine the teacher’s continued employability, even before they consider the teacher’s suitability for tenure.  Further, with this safety of tenure, where is the incentive to innovate, to think things anew, to explore, to run risks with different ideas?  While some few will do these things without incentives, most teachers find it easier simply to stay with the familiar—at the expense of innovation.  With nothing to lose in their safety, tenured teachers see nothing to gain by deviating from the familiar, the safe.

Tenure also makes it easier for tenured teachers, where they have input (which primarily, but not exclusively, occurs in the colleges and universities), to support tenure for colleagues who might challenge these senior teachers, were the latter not safely tenured.  But what does this “advantage” of tenure say about the tenured faculty, really?  Quite plainly, it demonstrates that the tenured are chary of challenge, they are leery of the competition from colleagues who, operating on an equal (untenured) footing, innovate themselves, develop and try new ideas themselves, and so on.  By succeeding at these, those competitive juniors represent the real threat to the tenured faculty: the juniors are doing a better job, and are more creative.

Tenure provides safety against arbitrary dismissal.  One hundred years ago, when the concept of teacher tenure was being developed, teachers often were dismissed because of their politics, because of their race, because the woman teacher stayed out too late at night, because she got pregnant.  These were valid beefs then, and a system of protection against such claptrap was needed.

Today, we have a suite of labor law that achieves this.  Discrimination on the basis of race, gender, politics, and so on is illegal, and there are several metrics in place in case law, and in the laws themselves, that effectively identify such discrimination.  Arbitrary dismissal of teachers is no longer a threat, and it has not been for more than 30 years.

As long ago as the 1890s, major donors could successfully remove some professors or block the hiring of others, and this was viewed as a negative—one of those arbitrary dismissals or hirings.  But why should a major donor not be allowed to specify how his donation must be used?  When we “donate” our money to a businessman in order to receive his product, are we not allowed to demand that the product live up to its promise?  When an investor “donates” his investment to a business, should not that investor be allowed to specify how his investment should best be used?  When we donate our money to a charity, are we not allowed to specify its use?  So it is with donations to educational institutions.  The donors have every right to demand that the institution’s product—its students—be well enough taught to live up to the institutions’ promise of their product.  The investor in an educational institution should be able to specify how his investment is to be used for the greatest efficiency in producing qualified students.  Such specifications clearly include the personnel as well as the physical plant employed.

Tenure preserves for the classroom the experience and skills accumulated over the course of a life of teaching.  But tenured teachers choose the classes with the advanced students, the school districts’ better schools and facilities.  All of this experience and this vaunted skill set thereby becomes unavailable to the disadvantaged students, who are taught by the (no doubt, hardworking and well intentioned) less experienced and the inexperienced new hires.  What is the advantage of tenure for these students who most need that experience and skill?

Following are some additional disadvantages to tenuring teachers.

With tenure, it’s extremely difficult to fire inadequate teachers.  New York City’s only recently suspended “rubber rooms” are a blatant illustration of this shortcoming.  In these rubber rooms, failed teachers—teachers acknowledged to be failures by their schools and their union alike—sit around unproductively and at full pay, often for years, while their cases wend their way through “due process” before they can be removed from the district’s payroll.  A lot of press has been expended on the unions’ role in this travesty, and to be sure, the union plays a part.  But it’s tenure, not union rules, that are most in the way of correcting this.

Indeed, tenure makes seniority the main factor in dismissal decisions, instead of teacher performance and quality.  Tenure requirements create a “last-hired, first-fired” policy; merit receives little to no consideration.  Even in those contracts under development which include students’ test scores as a factor in evaluating individual teacher performance, this actual classroom output remains a minor factor; longevity and teacher education (as opposed to student education) still are the dominant considerations.  This was made plain by the New Jersey teacher’s complaint to Governor Christie a couple of years ago: “You’re not compensating me for my education (her plaint occurs beginning about 0:40 of the clip).  She’s right, but she fails to understand the problem.  She’s being paid for the product she delivers, educated students, not how much self-improvement she undergoes.  Tenure, thus, is little more than an excuse by teachers to be paid for their input, not for their output.

Finally, tenure at colleges and universities tends to depend on research grants and publications and not on actual teaching, much less quality teaching.  Indeed, one of the perks of tenure in the hallowed halls is a lighter teaching load.  In K-12, tenure isn’t even pretended to be earned; it’s granted as a matter of routine. Teachers only need to teach for a short period of time to receive tenure.

Right to work states have higher employment rates than states with “safe,” union jobs.  This is no knock on unions in this context, but it illustrates an important point.  Having a job in an environment where an employer is free to fire employees who are not producing is no threat to a quality employee.  It is no threat to a quality non-tenured teacher’s employability, either.  On the contrary, that teacher’s merit as a teacher, how well that teacher is preparing his students for the next stage of their lives, determines that teacher’s employability, and just as no worker in a right to work state need fear for his job so long as he’s actually doing it, no teacher need fear for his job, so long as he’s teaching effectively.  Tenure provides no more job security than that of actually performing well.  In the end, tenure isn’t needed generally in right to work states, and tenure isn’t needed anywhere in the teaching industry.

The Campaign and Herman Cain

With this post, I continue a short series consisting of my analyses of the Republican candidates for the nomination for President.  To recap, I’m limiting my discussions to three candidates: Mitt Romney, Herman Cain, and Rick Perry.  The structure of this series consists of a collection of posts concerning what I don’t like about the candidates and then a series of what I do like about them.  I’ll conclude with my endorsement of a single candidate.  In this post, I’ll talk about what I don’t like about Herman Cain.

Tax Policy: He’s pushing a consumption tax, and this is a mistake.  Coupled with the overall rate reductions that are part of his 9-9-9 plan, that might not seem like a big deal, but the fact is a consumption tax is very regressive.  There are necessities that we all must buy whether we work or not, and a consumption tax would hit those who are not working especially hard.  He defends the tax on the non-working by insisting that his tax policy, coupled with his other plans for improving our economy, will put people back to work.  I believe his suite of policies will, in their aggregate, do this, but “putting people back to work” only works to an extent.

Full employment in the US has been, in recent history, in the neighborhood of 4%-4.5% unemployment, not 0% unemployment.  What of those remaining 4%-4.5%?  They will have no employment-based income with which to pay the taxes on their consumption (of course this elides the lack of funds with which to consume at all, but that’s a different thread).  Further, the unemployment rates only concern those who are out of work, but want work.  What of those who are out of work because they’re retired?  In the context of a consumption tax, these folks are no different from those 4%-4.5% unemployed.

This also misses the total cost of this kind of tax.  When coupled with the already in place consumption taxes that many states use as major components of their own funding, total consumption taxes can reach beyond 20%.

The empirical history of consumption taxes is unpromising, also.  The various national consumption taxes started low in Europe, too, but it’s too easy to raise such a tax without the taxpayer entirely noticing (“a penny for poverty,” or “a penny for universal health care,” or pick a cause)—and the average European consumption tax now is in the neighborhood of 20%.

Experience: He has no political experience.  This often is touted as a positive, and in many respects, it is.  Here’s the downside.  In order to get legislation through the United States Congress (or any state legislature, come to that), it’s necessary to work with a collection of politicians each of whom has the interest of his own constituency, or even his own interest, at heart and often at the expense of the country (or state).  Working through the purely political imperatives of a collection of politicians is not a straightforward task, no matter the depth of good will being brought to the table, by Mr Cain or by any of those politicians.   The Congress is not a private enterprise’s executive office, where if push comes to shove, the boss can simply pull rank and issue the relevant binding instruction.

Finally, the nation seems to have had a bellyful, in President Obama, of Presidents with no prior serious political experience.  It may be that Mr Cain’s actual working man’s business experience will count for a lot on the national stage, but this still will be a tough row to hoe.

Government and the People

Our social compact, as in the nature of such compacts, is an agreement entered into, voluntarily, by each of us with all of the rest of us.  It is an agreement between and among us; it involves no one else and no thing else.

A result of this compact of ours is a government which we have created to serve our needs (chief among these being the protection of our Creator-endowed natural rights in this secular world and the protection of each of us and all of us from each other—not from ourselves—and from others who are outside of our compact).  This is an important point, which many miss: our compact is not at all an agreement between us and our government.

Our government is nothing more, or less, than our creation, and as such, it is subordinate to us in every respect.  In order to enable our government to prosecute those protections, to do the job for which we created it, we do, indeed, transfer from us to it a measure of authorities and powers so that it has necessary tools.  However, these powers and authorities, originating in us, can be withdrawn by us at any time.  Thus, the relationship we have with our government is not at all one of equals, nor is it in any way a democratic relationship.  Our government is bound to do our bidding, not the other way around.

One of the things we acknowledged about ourselves in this relationship, those 230 or so years ago when we agreed to our social compact, was a duty inherent in us to replace our government when it became so oppressive, so counter to our purposes, as to no longer have our consent to govern.  This acknowledgment is sufficiently important that our Declaration of Independence says it twice:

That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.

and again:

But when a long train of abuses and usurpations, pursuing invariably the same Object evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government, and to provide new Guards for their future security.

When our Founders wrote these passages, they were working in a world devoid of democracy, a world containing no government that operated with the consent of the governed (however much a people may have loved its monarch).  Thus, they were envisioning the only means of abolishment as being the course on which they had embarked: violent revolution.  But the government they invented (and which followed on the example of various ancient Greek ideas, among others) made routine another means of abolishment and institution of new: periodic and frequent elections, through which we might recast our government peacefully and, simultaneously, renew our consent.  Of course this new invention did not eliminate recourse to violent overthrow, but it made resort to that, necessarily rare (“mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable than to right themselves by abolishing”) option, extremely unlikely.

But there is another side to this asymmetric relationship between us and our government.  Of necessity, our government is subordinate to us—and so it is not independent of us.  We cannot just wind it up, set it loose, and walk away.  Nor can we divorce ourselves from the individual responsibilities and obligations that are part of that endowment in us mentioned earlier.  As our government is bound to obey our instruction, so are we bound to provide that instruction, as often as necessary.  We have a duty to ourselves, to each other, and to our subordinate government, to stay actively engaged in the politics of our time, and specifically in the activities of our government.

We must maintain active oversight of our government, working to keep it on the straight and narrow, its behavior satisfactory to our ends and not to its own.   Over the flow of history, conditions will evolve, and it may be necessary for us, as the polity of our compact, to alter our government’s path to a new course better suited to the new conditions.  We cannot do this, we cannot maintain course or alter it, if we do not remain actively engaged: positively schooled in the politics and economics and activities of our time, and positively interacting with our government to ensure it is serving our needs alone.

Pericles once said, “Just because you do not take an interest in politics doesn’t mean politics won’t take an interest in you.”  Or as Plato put it more bluntly, “Those who think they are too smart for politics are doomed to be governed by those who are dumber.”

The Campaign and Mitt Romney

With this post, I’ll begin a short series of posts consisting of my analyses of the Republican candidates for the nomination for President.  Keep in mind that you’re getting these analyses for free; it’s entirely possible that you’ll getting your money’s worth.  The structure of this series will consist of, first, a collection of posts concerning what I don’t like about the candidates, then I’ll have a series of what I do like about them.  I’ll conclude with my endorsement of a single candidate.  To be sure, my endorsement will have enormous value for the lucky pick; he’ll be able to take it to a famous coffee chain with a few bucks and get a truly adequate cup of coffee.

With Governor Christie confirming that he’s a man of his word and will honor his commitment to his fellow New Jerseyites by remaining their governor for the rest of his term, the Republican list of candidates is narrowing and sorting out.  The serious candidates are beginning to look like Mitt Romney, Herman Cain, and Rick Perry.  Other members of the field, who once had a chance, include Michelle Bachmann, Newt Gingrich, Ron Paul, and some others, but they’ve all made too many gaffes, or exposed too much ignorance in key areas, or have too much baggage, or simply haven’t been able to gain enough traction to be taken seriously.  Rick Santorum and Jon Huntsman, I hope, will be back in 2012 or 2016; they deserve a more serious look than the current season is giving them.  There’s something to like about each of those top three, though, and something to dislike.

I’ll kick off this series with a discussion of ex-Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney.

There are two key areas in Romney’s history that give me considerable disgruntlement.  His position on the environment is…uncertain.  He favors, apparently, cap and trade limits to carbon emissions, and so to economic growth—based on pseudoscience from anthropomorphic climate warming priests—until he turned against them.  He stood outside a coal-fired power plant and accused it of, if not outright murder, at least of killing people.   In an Obama-esque blame shift, Romney insists that his carbon emissions limits program was actually the work of prior administrations, but here’s what he did on his watch to block them: “These carbon emission limits will provide real and immediate progress in the battle to improve our environment,” then-Governor Romney said in a December 2005 press release, in which he also bragged that Massachusetts was then the first state to set CO2 limits.  He worked for a regional agreement among nearby states set up an area-wide carbon cap and trade régime, until he bailed on it in 2005 when he decided not to run for governor of Massachusetts anymore and instead look for the Presidency.

Health care.  Governor Romney insists that Romneycare is right for Massachusetts, but it’s not a national plan, and cannot be: each state is unique and has its own environment.  That last part is pretty good, but let’s look at the first part.  Was it right for Massachusetts?  Romney insists that he’s enrolled more citizens of Massachusetts in health insurance coverage than had been “possible” before Romneycare.  But at what cost?  He claims that every citizen of Massachusetts, while required by state government to buy health insurance, does so in a competitive market.  Set aside any argument about whether the State’s insurance markets truly are competitive—it’s irrelevant.  The problem is that we have a government requiring a free citizen of the United States to turn his property to government purposes, rather than for that citizen’s purposes.  We have a government dictating to a free citizen what he must buy, solely as a condition of his status as a citizen of Massachusetts.  This may be legal for a State to do to its citizens under the 10th Amendment, but it’s still wrong.

On the matter of Obamacare, most of the candidates have vowed to repeal it at the earliest opportunity and to work “from day one” to do so.  Romney, too, has vowed to defang Obamacare on his first day in office: via Executive Orders granting every state waivers against compliance with the state mandates organic to Obamacare.   But these  Orders will leave intact the individual mandate, taxpayer-funded exchange subsidies, a huge taxpayer-expensed Medicaid expansion, the robbery from Medicare, and Obamacare death panels.  In fact, while every other Republican candidate has vowed to push repeal from the start, Romney has not.  He’ll only implement those Executive orders (which any subsequent President can rescind), while he’ll “try real hard” to get repeal.  He won’t try at the expense of pushing a vote in the Senate, though.  Why is he avoiding a fight in the Senate?  Because a Democrat minority might remain strong enough to maintain a filibuster.  It seems that Romney will surrender control of the Senate to a Democratic Party minority, rather than fight for repeal.  Certainly it’s true that one should pick ones fights carefully, but there comes a time when you have to fight even when you know you’ll lose because the principle is that important.  If you don’t have any principles worth fighting for, what principles do you have?