Chief Executive and Unilateral Actions

President Obama, by Executive Order, is moving to ease the means by which some homeowners whose homes are underwater, can refinance their mortgages, and he is moving, also by Executive Order, to “ease the burden of student debt” for some students.  These moves come as part of an announced plan to make similar unilateral Executive Office moves on a periodic basis, and these moves come under the newly minted campaign slogan “We can’t wait.”

Of course there is a large hue and cry over this.  It must be unconstitutional, the President is bypassing Congress, and so on.  But is this accurate?  Is this executive overreach, or is this an executive officer acting like an executive officer?

Article II of our Constitution vests executive power in the President, and he is the Commander in Chief of our military forces.  The executive power authorizes the President to act unilaterally in emergencies so that a national response will not be delayed by waiting on the much slower-moving large committee that is the Congress.  The Congress’ involvement is not lost, though: when it catches up with the situation, it can overrule or condone, at its sole discretion, the President’s actions.  On the other hand, this is not license for the President to overrule the Congress.  His opportunity to do that is limited to his veto power and his authority to send his Attorney General into the courts to challenge—on Constitutional grounds, not simply any reason that might suit him—a law passed by Congress over his veto.

Yet the hoo-raw is based on the principle of the President acting unilaterally.  This smacks of being driven by party roles rather than being based on principle.  One party must support all of these actions, regardless of their legitimacy, because that is the role defined for it; the other party must vociferously object for the same mindless reason.

Certainly, the beef is given credence by those unilateral actions the President has taken in order to avoid Congressional oversight or in order to overrule the Congress altogether.  The recess appointment of Dr. Donald Berwick to be his Administrator for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services explicitly to avoid the Senate’s hearings on his suitability comes to mind.  So, too, does the creation of  the position of Assistant to the President and Special Advisor to the Secretary of the Treasury on the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau for Dr Elizabeth Warren to run the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau from his office, without recourse to the Congress.  And his decision to let stand a memo issued by Immigration and Customs Enforcement Director, John Morton, that implemented various detention paradigms of the DREAM Act which Congress had explicitly declined to enact.

This sort of thing notwithstanding, though, of course the President can act unilaterally when the situation warrants.  This is what a President is for under our social compact.  The present economic situation demands prompt action: even our Defense Chief—whose military the President’s ability promptly to deploy and employ on his own authority, at least temporarily, is quite clear—and our Secretary of State are on record as acknowledging our economic straits and our national debt to be matters of national security.

The principle of unilateral action is sound.  There is plenty about which to criticize the President over these last three years.  But integrity and justice demand that we criticize his actions—and I have objected to much of his actions and decisions—we are remiss to criticize the Executive Officer solely because he acts like one.

Government Market Intervention

I’ve written before (here and here) about the damaging risks run by governments intervening in a free market.  I want to talk about a couple of additional examples of such intervention, and then I’ll leave the subject alone for a while.

The Daily Caller wrote today about the President’s attempt, by Executive fiat, to ease the debt burden on students.  The plan, according to early information, is to allow some of the (now graduated) students to ease their debt burdens by consolidating their loans into one loan.  Further, after the original loan contracts have been solemnly entered into, the President’s plan seems to be to allow borrowers to cap their loan payments at 10% of their after-tax income (with the signed contracts capping these payments at 15%).  Finally, unpaid balances can simply be walked away from—”forgiven”—after 20 years, instead of an originally contracted-for 25.  This plan is available, though, only to students whose loans were obtained through a Federal loan guaranty program or directly from the Federal government.  (Thus, not only is a select group being singled out for preferential treatment, only an especially favored subgroup is eligible for this particular intervention.  This, though, is beside the point of this post.)

Early word is that this will be “paid for” by “savings” claimed to occur from the 2010 nationalization of the student loan business which was included in Obamacare legislation.  There are a number of problems with this; I’ll confine myself to the market intervention problem.  With one party able unilaterally to alter the terms of a loan contract, costs will be imposed on the other party absent his agreement—even his discussion.

These costs will include lost interest income and principle repayment from the smaller payments of the loan’s repayment stream, and they will include outright loss of the principle loaned through that earlier forced “forgiveness.”  That five year chop, given the way loans are amortized, means that about 25% of the principle (assuming a 7% loan; the principle loss increases as the interest rate increases) can be written off.  Look at your home mortgages for an example: most of your payments are interest, with only a little principle being paid down until the last years of the loan.  These costs, as I’ve noted, are imposed solely on the borrower’s call.

Then there is the loss to the rest of us taxpayers by using the alleged savings from that nationalization to cover these costs rather than returning those savings to the Treasury to pay down the nation’s debt.  Of course some will point out that these savings, compared to our national debt, is just chump change.  This is disingenuous.  Ask any discount store about the importance of everyone’s nickels and dimes to the millions in profit those chain discounters make in the aggregate—on a slim margin compared to the millions in costs those chains experience, but a positive margin.  And as an Illinois Senator once said, “A billion here, a billion there, pretty soon, we’re talking about real money.”

Then there’s the cost of consolidating those loans—small, generally, compared to the loans themselves, but the fees add up across the six million, or so, prospective eligibles.  This is an unnecessary cost to the taxpayer, though, as anyone who ever has gotten into credit card debt trouble knows: loan consolidation is a standard means of containing, and ultimately paying down, excessive personal debt, and the mechanisms for this are already well established in banks and credit unions.

Some (others) might point out that students might have trouble getting a loan consolidation loan from a bank or credit union; their credit ratings will be too poor.  But wait: if they’re poor risks for a bank, aren’t they poor risks for the National Bank of Taxpayer?  And wasn’t freely lending to poor risks a major contributor to our present mess?

Finally, there’s the moral hazard being created here.  Given that the borrower from, or through, the government can simply change the terms at will, or take advantage of the myriad of loopholes in our current tax system (which I’ve heard no Democrat willing to change) to hold down the dollar size of that 15%10% cap, or simply to wait a now shorter while and then legally walk away from his loan contract, where is the incentive to take his loan obligation seriously in the first place?  Where is the incentive for private lenders to involve themselves in the student loan market?  Oh, wait—what student loan market…?

Another, brief, example is  the travesty of the Chevrolet Volt, built by a car company and union that were the individual, specifically targeted, beneficiaries of an historically huge market intervention.  I suppose, in the end, though, the Volt itself isn’t much of an intervention: even after a taxpayer-funded $7,500 rebate, the $40,000 (post-rebate) Volt isn’t selling, so the taxpayer’s funds aren’t being tapped too hard here.  There’s also no reason why it would be a large intervention.  This marvel of “green” technology gets around 40 miles per charge before it needs help from an on board internal combustion engine (in fairness to the Volt, this is pretty typical of other hybrids, too).  But so does the 1896 [sic] Roberts Electric Car; although the Roberts doesn’t have an internal combustion engine at all, and it’s missing some (unrelated to “green”) comfort features.

In short, what are we getting for these government interventions into our market place?  Moral hazard, higher costs to the taxpayer—and the consumer—and loss of market participation.    This is a big price to pay for interventions that, by their nature, cannot work.

Roles

Power Line offers this quote from the Introduction to a compilation of FDR’s 1938 speeches and Presidential papers, in which Roosevelt seeks to explain the deliberate polarization of his politics.

I believe it to be my sworn duty, as President, to take all steps necessary to insure the continuance of liberalism in our government.  I believe, at the same time, that it is my duty as head of the Democratic Party to see to it that my party remains the truly liberal party in the political life of America.

…

Generally speaking, in a representative form of government, there are usually two general schools of political belief—liberal and conservative.  The system of party responsibility in America requires that one of its parties be the liberal party and the other be a conservative party.

We see this view repeated, if not necessarily with Roosevelt’s loftier motive, in the current Progressive attempt to purge conservatism from our politics and from our government with the administration’s civil discourse and its denigration, where they’re not ignoring altogether, of conservatives, Republicans, and any others who disagree with them.

But the theory, and its activation, necessarily do two things, each of them bad: 1) it drives each party further toward the extreme of the indicated position, and 2) it denies each party the ability to evolve with the society which it purports to serve—the American society.

The demand that Party satisfy the roles which FDR, and his successor Progressives, have laid out traps a self-avowed liberal party into constantly seeking change from the status quo and pursuing an ever bigger role for government, for that is the extreme of what liberalism has become, and it traps the self-avowed conservative party into constantly seeking to preserve the status quo for its own sake, for that is the extreme of what conservatism has become.  But change or preservation for its own sake is anathema to what it is that makes America exceptional.

Times change, circumstances change, but the principles underlying liberty, individual rights, and the individual obligations that underlie that liberty and those rights do not change.  This is why the Liberalism of the 18th Century is not, and cannot be, the Liberalism of the 21st Century, nor can the Conservatism of those days be today’s Conservatism.  It was 18th Century Liberalism that demanded an end, at least for us, to a monarchical world where subjects were to serve the king because they could not be trusted to take care of themselves.  It was 18th Century Liberalism that replaced monarchy with limited a government subordinate to the people explicitly because that Liberalism trusted the people.  It was 18th Century Conservatism that sought to preserve that original condition, to maintain monarchy and the supremacy of the King.  No longer can Liberalism push for that change for those conditions no longer exist in our world; Liberalism must evolve in order to represent our current world.  And that Conservatism today cannot push for a stability based those politics; it too must evolve, and for the same reasons.

To preserve our nation’s greatness, there must, of necessity, be a convergence of views, not an artificially maintained differential, on those principles that made our greatness possible.  There certainly can be divergent and diverging views on what mechanisms, appropriate to today, give concrete effect to those principles, and indeed there should be such differences, if only for the sake of debate so that we may be more sure that the better mechanisms are being selected.  The problem with being trapped in pushing one –ism or the other solely for the sake of that –ism is that the –isms themselves must push us away from those fundamental principles.

Benjamin Barber advises us (courtesy of The Nation, via Power Line, again), “We must not step away from our values before negotiation begins….”  But he destroys his thesis by founding it on this: “allowing runaway financial markets, bloviating plutocrats and anti-government hubris to dominate, while poverty, social justice and climate change slip off the legislative agenda.”  There is no logic to his argument, and his facts are absent.  Without a motivation beyond simply having to be Liberal, he is unable to mount a coherent inquiry; he is left with the sort of thing he has, instead, produced: a false dichotomy that borders on a base ad hominem attack.

We see the same problem of this trap in the inchoate character of the OWS protests and in the incoherence of the Progressive Obama administration.  They are snared in the artificial requirement of being Liberal for Liberalism’s sake.  A “Conservative” administration must not commit the same error.

Is the Group Guilty of the Misbehavior of the Few?

Or, Where is the Logic?

In 2008, JPMorgan Chase was forced by the Federal government to accept bailout funds from TARP, even though the bank had no need of these funds.  The government’s reasoning for this was that they didn’t want to embarrass the banks that actually “needed” TARP bailout by having those banks be the only ones being funded by the government.  In the end, some 700 banks received TARP funds, which sounds like a lot, until that number is compared to the total number of banks in the US: nearly 9500 having assets of at least $100 million.  Yet, despite only 7% of the banks receiving bailout funds (and not all of them needing the funds), the entire banking industry is tarred by the failures of the few.  Flowing from this is the view that all banks contributed to the Panic of 2008 by overextending themselves with foolish investments, even though only a few of them actually were so engaged.

Throughout the Tea Party’s history over the last three years, there have been instances, as there are in all large and amorphous groupings, of individuals holding signs of a racist nature.  Whenever these signs, or other behaviors, are spotted by Tea Partiers at the gatherings, these individuals are isolated and removed from the gathering by those Tea Partiers.  Despite this, though, the entire collection of Tea Partiers is branded as racist.

In the current Occupy Wall Street protests, primarily in New York, there have been instances, again as there are in all large and amorphous groupings, of individuals holding offensive signs, this time of an anti-Semitic nature.  Following the logic applied to the Tea Partiers, should the OWS crowd be branded as bigoted?  To date, the NLMSM, which has applied this logic to the Tea Party movement, has not applied it to the OWS.

There are rare, but well-publicized, incidents of police brutality—Rodney King is one such.  Others, placed on YouTube, purport to show the same, but on full investigation, the “brutality” usually turns out to be non-existent.  Yet entire police forces are branded as corrupt on the basis of these rare incidents.

There are some Americans who objected to Barack Obama being elected President because of his race.  As a result of this, all Americans who disagree with Obama are racist, say too many on the Left.

And there are examples of a related “logic:” all who objected to the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act while it was being developed were accused by Democrat Congressional leadership of being against all health care reform, even though many alternatives were proposed, both in the Congress and around the country.  Along the same lines, President Obama accuses all who object to his recently defeated Jobs Bill (defeated in the Democrat-controlled Senate, after Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid initially refused to allow it to come to a vote at all, even though Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell explicitly requested a vote in response to Obama’s demand for that vote) of wanting all teachers, police, firefighters, et al., to lose their jobs.

Where is the logic in these accusations?  Why is there such imbalance in applying this “logic?”  One answer might be in the outcome of applying such “thinking” consistently: it would contradict the predetermined outcome of those who make the logical leaps in some cases, but not others.

In the end, who benefits from this imbalance?

Update: Corrected a typo in the third paragraph: NLMSL should have been NLMSM, which it now is.

Cynicism

Fred Barnes writes in The Weekly Standard about the boneheaded economics of “liberal Democrats.  With all due respect to Mr. Barnes, who is a far better writer than I, I beg to differ with his characterization.  Here are the examples he presents of their boneheadedness.

Barbara Lee, a House member from California, is upset about computerized checkout lines at grocery stores. She avoids lines with no flesh-and-blood checker.  “I refuse to do that,” Lee said at a House Appropriations Committee hearing, “I know that’s a job or two or three that’s gone.”

Representative Jesse Jackson Jr. of Illinois is up in arms about the iPad, which he declared on the House floor recently is “now probably responsible for eliminating thousands of jobs.”  Alas, “what becomes of bookstores and librarians and all the jobs associated with paper?” Quite soon, he said, “such jobs will simply not exist.”

House minority leader Nancy Pelosi has her own remedy for the jobs dearth: Extend unemployment benefits.  “It injects demand into the economy,” she insists.  “It creates jobs faster than almost any other initiative you can name.” It has the “double benefit” of putting money in the pockets of the jobless and acting as a “job creator.”

Representative Keith Ellison of Minnesota is the champion of job creation by adding to the regulatory burden of businesses. Sounds counter-productive, right? Not so, Ellison told MSNBC. Companies will have to hire more people to comply with new regs.  “If the government says, look, we have got to reduce our carbon footprint, you will kick into gear a whole number of people that know how to do that or have ideas about that, and that will be a job engine,” Ellison said.

These are all very smart people; they know better, Mr. Barnes notwithstanding.  Rep Lee knows that technology creates more, and better, jobs than its lack.  Otherwise, she’d be pushing legislation to return us to the 19th century when roads were built with shovels and picks, there’d be no electricity to light her reading lamp, and there’d be no telephones or cars to ease her communication or travel.

Rep. Jackson had just been extolling the virtues of the iPad a few months prior to his remarks above.  I don’t think this flip-flop is an indication of any boneheadedness on his part.

Rep Pelosi didn’t get to be the Representative of the 8th District of California for 24 years and Speaker of the House of Representatives for 6 years because she’s a ditz.

Finally, Rep Ellison knows regulations don’t create jobs.  If they did, we’d have full employment, what with the number of government regulations expanding from 2600 pages in the Federal Register in 1936 to over 80,000 pages today.

It’s clear that these Progressives do think we are boneheaded, though.  It’s been their mantra for the last couple of years, for instance, that if only we understood what they were saying to us we would, perforce, agree with them and fall right in line with their government-will-take-care-of-us meme.  But since we don’t agree, they say it must be because we don’t understand; there must be something wrong with their messaging.  They need, they say, to keep adjusting their message until we do understand them.  They just need to keep dumbing down their message until we finally get it.

No, these Congressmen aren’t boneheaded.  Nor is their economics; those words aren’t intended to have any meaning.  This is just part of their messaging, and part of their cynical attitude toward us.  They’re used to having us dependent on themon government for our welfare, and they’re loathe to lose that power.  When they were swept to dominant positions by the 2008 elections, they rolled the dice on their control of our welfare.  They passed “stimulus” spending for the benefit of their unions, then they rammed through Obamacare to drastically increase our dependency on themon government, and then they rammed through Dodd-Frank to hamstring American businesses so as to increase our dependency.  Only three years on, with unemployment ranging between 9% and 10% the entire time, did they finally get around to paying lip service to a “jobs” bill.  But this is, in the event, just an attempt to push class warfare, while looking to continue paying us for (still) not working with yet more “unemployment insurance”—insurance designed to insure that we continue to not work and remain dependent on…government. Oh, and it has further spending for their unions.

After the midterm elections last year, and with the continuing disaster of their policies these last three years, they’re simply worried about losing their power.  This latest round of claims which Mr. Barnes provides just shows the Progressive cynical attitude toward us: they’ll say anything they can think of to pander to us, get our votes, and stay in power.