Justice’s View of the Law

“When the [Attorney General] does it, that means that it is not illegal.”

In the aftermath of the 11th Circuit issuing an injunction, pending fuller appeal, against Alabama’s enforcement of the (major) portions of its new immigration law that a lower court had let stand, Attorney General Eric Holder’s Justice Department is demonstrating a breathtaking—even for this administration—arrogance.

Among other things, the injunction blocks Alabama school districts from collecting immigration information from its enrolled students.  Holder’s DoJ, bypassing the districts’ legal representation, the State’s Attorney General (Luther Strange), has gone straight to the districts to demand they surrender to Justice copies of all such immigration information (information which they now are enjoined from collecting).

Yet, despite explicit and repeated requests from Strange that Holder cite the authority by which he conducts his “investigation” of an internal State matter, Holder has steadfastly refused to identify that authority.  Instead, he simply keeps repeating his bald assertion that he has it.  In a letter which his Assistant US Attorney General, Thomas Perez, wrote to Strange, this is all he had to say:

The Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department is tasked with investigating potential violations of civil rights laws that protect educational opportunities for schoolchildren.  We know that the longstanding legal tradition in this country of ensuring the right to attend school without being subject to discrimination on any impermissible ground is as critically important to you, as the Attorney General of the State of Alabama, as it is to the Civil Rights Division.

This is just a cynical obfuscation of the matter.  Asserting that an arm of Justice “is tasked” wholly evades Strange’s question of “by what authority.”

It would seem more appropriate, since Holder seems unable to identify the source of his asserted authority (else surely he would do so), that he look more to doing his job.  As Senator Jeff Sessions (R, AL) suggested in a related context,

…I would suggest that the Attorney General take a little timeout from his lawsuit against Arizona or Alabama or other states, and focus a little bit of his attention on…jurisdiction[s] that [are] willfully and deliberately acting to undermine federal law enforcement.

Sessions said this in response to Senator Dick Durbin’s (D, IL) beef that Alabama actually was trying to enforce immigration law, but the remark applies just as well to Holder in the context of his invasion of AL over its schools.

Democracy

From Spiegel Online International:

Not even a day after [German Chancellor Merkel] and French President Nicolas Sarkozy suspended aid payments to Greece pending the results of a bailout referendum called by the government in Athens, Prime Minister Giorgios Papandreou has backed away from his plan.

And this, from the Greeks’ own government:

On Thursday, Papandreou [yielded] to demands that he enter into negotiations with the opposition on the formation of a cross-party caretaker government. Shortly thereafter, plans were scrapped to hold the controversial referendum….  Papandreou’s own finance minister broke ranks.

The people will not be allowed to speak on the matter, save through continued riots.  And their own government will not hear them.

Greek democracy, RIP.

Metaphors

The current administration set up, a short while ago, a Web site intended to facilitate the efforts of those seeking Federal employment.  In doing so, the administration internalized a task that had been handled by Monster.com.

The proxy server did not receive a timely response from the upstream server.

This is an all too common complaint about that new USAJobs Facebook wall.  After a multi-million dollar, two-year to “upgrade,” Office of Personnel Management’s new site has less capability and reduced reliability compared to Monster’s original site.  Additionally, not everyone is convinced the price tag for these two years is justifiable.  “I might make some people mad if I say this, but without knowing the specifics of the contract I can’t really see something like this costing over half a million dollars,” Zach Katkin, President and CEO of Atilus, notes.

At the end of 2008 and start of 2009, the government passed TARP, a $780 billion bailout package for failing businesses.  The package was originally intended to buy all the “toxic assets” (credit default swaps, mortgage backed securities, and other even more esoteric debt instrument derivatives) from vulnerable financial institutions to facilitate their recovery.  Then it was morphed—without Congress’ involvement—into outright bailouts of financial institutions deemed to special to be allowed to fail and go through bankruptcy proceedings, and it was expanded in scope to include bailing out car companies and unions.  Thus was born the whole too big to fail thing and the moral hazard stemming from that, demonstrated by all the demands by other businesses, and even individual Americans, for similar bailouts.

Early in 2009, the government passed the Stimulus Bill, a nearly trillion dollar spending package intended, in the finest Keynesian tradition, to stimulate the economy and promote job growth.  The government even guaranteed that this package would keep national unemployment below 8.5%.  National unemployment soon peaked over 10%, and it’s been above 9% ever since.  But we got those trillion dollars successfully spent, and our national debt successfully ballooned.

In 2010, the government passed the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act on the claim that health care costs for Americans and our businesses would go down drastically and on the claim that Americans would see more transparency in our business transactions and gain protection from the nefarious machinations of our financial institutions.  The response since has been rising insurance costs, to the point the HHS has threatened to bar insurance companies from Obamacare’s insurance exchanges if they don’t straighten up and fly right.  In addition, small business employers are saying, in droves (30% of them, and rising), that costs for the insurance coverage they’re required to provide will be so high when this part of the law takes effect, they’ll be forced to stop providing insurance coverage at all.

Further, small businesses are facing nearly $3,000 per employee in incremental compliance costs due to Dodd-Frank’s reporting requirements.  And Dodd-Frank hasn’t yet had even half of its required rules written.

And we get great ideas like this one from Rep Jim Moran (D, VA):  “The banks aren’t doing it, but the federal government can borrow money at three-and-a-half percent today. They should use that money to refinance every home mortgage, and that would put $750 billion into homeowners pockets.”

We’ve been getting “The proxy server did not receive a timely response from the upstream server” messages since well before the botched USAJobs effort.

Desperation

Here come the character assassinations. The lead paragraph in a Politico article says this:

During Herman Cain’s tenure as the head of the National Restaurant Association in the 1990s, at least two female employees complained to colleagues and senior association officials about inappropriate behavior by Cain, ultimately leaving their jobs at the trade group, multiple sources confirm to POLITICO.

The rest of the article contains…carefully unnamed sources and cynically unsubstantiated “facts.”  We get those “multiple sources” from that lead paragraph.  We get a “lengthy roster of former board members, current and past staff and others,” also carefully unidentified.  We get constant repetition of the original allegation, but oddly, no corroborating facts.  We get Cain saying, in response to a interviewer’s question, that he can’t comment “until I see some facts or some concrete evidence” and being accused of being evasive for the dastardly crime of declining to speak in ignorance.  And so on.  They did bury some identified sources on the last page of their article: “Ron Magruder, Denise Marie Fugo and Joseph Fassler, the chair, vice chair and immediate past chairman of the National Restaurant Association board of directors at the time of Cain’s departure, said they hadn’t heard about any complaints regarding Cain making unwanted advances.”  How inconvenient to their thesis.

Is there anything substantive to this matter?  We’ll never know from this level of journalism.  On the other hand, was the purpose here to reveal critical facts about a man’s character, or simply to create doubt through innuendo?

Another assassination attempt is Roger Simon’s, carried out recently on CNN Live (follow the link, and have your browser allow popups—the video is in one.  Simon’s remarks occur at about the 7:10 mark, and sorry about the leading ad):

[W]hy would Perry use [the Birther “issue”] in the primaries…? Well, it’s because being extreme perhaps and a little bit racist perhaps gives you good bona fides in a Republican primary — shows him you’re on the same side as they are.

And there has been for some time, now, the misleading statements about the opposition’s performance.  For instance, we have the following from David Axelrod, as he insists that Republicans, generally, are deliberately trying to trash our economy (again, apologies for the leading commercial, and these particular remarks occur about three quarters of the way through the interview).

They don’t want to cooperate. They don’t want to help.  …so you have to ask a question, are they willing to tear down the economy in order to tear down the president or are they going to cooperate?

We also have the President and his recently begun drumbeat about do-nothing Republicans.  He blames do-nothing Republicans for blocking “jobs” bills, saying, “Over and over, they have refused to even debate the same kind of jobs proposals that Republicans have supported in the past – proposals that today are supported, not just by Democrats, but by Independents and Republicans all across America.”  He blames do-nothing Republicans for blocking his $447 billion “jobs” bill.  And so on.   Of course, he ignores the fact that the do-nothing Republicans passed a budget, in their first month in the present Congressional session, that would have produced jobs and started bringing down the national debt.  He ignores the fact that it was those oh, so active Democrats that refused Sen. Mitch McConnell’s attempt to honor Obama’s “Pass this bill now” demand and bring that expensive jobs bill to a prompt vote, choosing instead to wait until they were ready to play their political games with it.  He ignores the fact that the do-nothing Republicans have passed jobs bills and jobs-related bills that address the excessive regulations that inhibit small businesses and their hiring.  He ignores the fact that every one of these bills, including that budget bill, sit in the activist Democrat Senate being studiously ignored.  He ignores the fact that that same activist Democrat Senate has refused even to attempt a budget bill of its own for the last 900 days.

Finally, there’s the just plain silly.  We get for instance, Cokie Roberts, on ABC News’ “The Green Room,” extolling the virtues of our present overly complex, loophole-laden tax system (again, sorry for the leading ad):

I think we will see the flat tax crash and burn once again. You know, look – the reason America has used the tax code for social good is because we like the private sector. And so Western Europe has basically embraced socialism to do all of these things. What we have embraced is have business do all our health care and our universities and our arts and all of that, and our housing, with garden apartments for middle class people and all of that. And you know, you might like or dislike that, but that’s a result of the tax code and that is something Americans tend to like a whole lot better than having government do it.

We’re only in the primary season, too.  The actual campaign will be…interesting.

Chinese Danegeld

Once you pay the Danegeld, you never get rid of the Dane, goes the saying.  It’s appropriate that this European saying, originating in an ancient attempt to buy off (Danish) Vikings—which, of course, kept the Vikings coming—is being demonstrated today in Europe.

In the aftermath of the European Union’s massive bailout of the Greeks on the backs of European taxpayers and banks, EU leadership is going hat in hand to China asking for funding for the European Financial Stability Fund (EFSF).  China is insisting, though, on far more than just the usual concrete guarantees of a decent return that any investor will demand of a potential business partner who is unreliable.  China is demanding a muzzle on European speech.  If China agrees to participate, apparently, the EU must, in return, abjectly surrender its right to criticize Chinese manipulative monetary policy.

It remains to be seen whether the EU will knuckle under on this.  However, their respect for free speech never has been strong.  Just ask Geert Wilders, the Dutch Parliamentarian who was hailed into court over a four-year period for the heinous crime of criticizing Muslims, and in the height of irony, banned for several months from entry into Great Britain, his presence representing a “threat to one of the fundamental interests of [British] society.”

The Chinese are demonstrating yet another price, an unintended price, of bail outs.  And what price will they demand next?