Government Spending

Much of this originated as a comment to a Gay Patriot post.  I strongly recommend the post and then the accumulating commentary.

It’s important to note at the outset that government has no money of its own.  It only can act as intermediary in the (forced) process of transferring money from one group of private citizens to another.

Now a few remarks on government spending.  First, much of the money taken from private individuals and/or their businesses (which are just agencies of private individuals) to pay for government spending is lost to friction, including outright waste (I won’t get into losses to graft.  Could the graft be identified, it’d be rooted out.  Right?).  The waste includes money spent on government middlemen, money spent on government contractors hired to oversee the transfers and transferees, time and money spent schmoozing with lobbyists (both the good ones who are only identifying constituent needs—Congressmen generally fit this bill, for instance—and the bad ones, who are sure to take a taste of their own as the money flows, or to provide some vig in return for future consideration), and so on.

Second, money taken from private individuals to pay for government spending—whether through current taxes, current borrowing (future taxes), or printing money (future inflation)—is money that is not spent in the private sector, or husbanded against future spending in the private sector.  Thus, the multiplier effect of government spending, such as it is, is cancelled, if not exceeded, by the known, and fairly large, multiplier effect of private spending that is lost.  In many sequences of private spending, for instance, that multiplier effect runs out to 1.7x.  The best Keynesian estimate for the government spending multiplier is 1.5x.

Third, those husbanded funds generally are deposited in financial institutions as savings, and these deposits then are loaned to borrowers: these deposits are the primary source of loanable funds.  Taxes, then, reduce the amount of private money available for saving and so reduce the amount of lending that can occur.  This effect isn’t enough to cause a credit crunch like the one coming out of the Panic of 2008, but it hasn’t helped.  Further, that future inflation from printing to support excessive public borrowing devalues the funds that are saved.

There’s more.  As government debt grows, more private funds become husbanded, not against future spending goals in the private sector, but against those future taxes.  And even more borrowing is encouraged by that inflation (in the period before the recession that is the inevitable result of that high inflation)—in both the private and government sectors—since the repayment will be with inflation-devalued dollars.  Then that inevitable recession hits, and payback becomes, as they say, a bitch.

In sum, government spending isn’t zero-sum, it’s negative sum.

Update: clarified the second point.

Household Income

How are we doing in the post-recession “recovery” under the Progressive policies of the Democratic Presidential Candidate Barack Obama?  One indication comes from Sentier Research and a report produced by their Gordon Green and John Coder, Changes in Household Income During the Economic Recovery: June 2009 to June 2012. (normally, I provide links to the documents from which I quote, but the folks at Sentier charge for their reports; I’ll not defeat their purpose. The report can be found at their site, here.)

The following graph from the report shows the policies’ impact on incomes of various household types in the period since 2009.  It hasn’t been good for anyone.  Green and Coder normalized household incomes, setting per cent changes to 0.0% as of January 2000 (as in the graph) and to a Household Income Index with the income levels of January 2000 being 100.0.

Moreover, they noted that household income has remained poor and relatively static after the recession “ended.”  Having fallen from a start-of-recession HII peak of a shade over 100 to 96 at the “end,” household incomes continued to fall over the following year to roughly 92 and have remained static there for the last two years.  In other words, at the official end of the recession, incomes were roughly 96% of their pre-recession levels, and since 2010 have remained static at a lower 92% of pre-recession.

The authors pointed out a number of factors related to the drop in HII, including this one:

Another important factor contributing to the steep decline of the HII is the sharp increase in the median duration of unemployment not only during the recession but also during the economic recovery, and its tendency to remain at a very high level.  During the recession, from December 2007 to June 2009, the median duration of unemployment increased from 8.4 weeks to 17.4 weeks.  During the economic recovery, the median duration of unemployment increased from 17.4 weeks in June 2009 to 25.5 weeks in June 2010, and then fell to 19.8 weeks in June 2012.

Notice that unemployment duration after the recession “ended” remains above the in-recession rate.

Meanwhile, over 20 House-passed jobs related bills have continued to languish in the Democrat-controlled Senate in the period since 2010, when unemployment remains above in-recession levels and household income remains depressed compared even to its in- and immediately post-recession levels.

A Thought on Our Economy These Last Few Years

Both the Pew Research Center and the Congressional Budget Office have published reports in the last week that talk about the condition of our economy and the fiscal cliff that awaits us in a few short months.  Others have commented extensively on the reports themselves; I want to talk about some of the information that lies between the reports’ lines.

The Pew report focuses on the plight of the middle class, referring to “The Lost Decade of the Middle Class ” in its own headline.  The report points out, among other things, that middle class annual income has shrunk from $73k in 2001 (and 2008) to $69.5k in 2010, their most recent data.  Pew notes, also, that median middle class household net worth has fallen from $153k in 2008 to $93k in 2010.

The CBO report, on the other hand, has the following to say: if the Obama tax increases and the sequester spending cuts are allowed to go through at the start of 2013, the deficit will be cut roughly in half as a per cent of GDP, but at a cost of economic contraction of 0.5% on the year.  On the other hand, if the tax increases and spending cuts are put off for another year, the deficit will remain a damaging 6.5% of GDP, unemployment still will be at 8%, and the economy will grow an anemic 1.7%.  This is the fiscal conundrum the present administration’s Keynesian policies have created.

Plainly, the administration’s policies have been an utter failure; they have not produced economic recovery.  Indeed, the middle class, whom Progressives pretend to favor so much, have been devastated by those policies.  Still, Democratic Presidential Candidate Barack Obama wants four more years in which to do more of the same—or more so, since he’d have “more flexibility” after re-election, when he’d be beholden to no one.

After all, Obama says

The private sector is doing fine.

Hmm….

Cheap?

The Democratic National Committee has told Westport, CT, that it will not be reimbursed for the $15 thousand the city spent on security, traffic control, fire, emergency planning, and so on for Democratic Presidential Candidate Barack Obama’s fundraising trip in early August.

The candidate held two fundraisers in the small town, one at Sherwood Island State Park and the other a $36 thousand per person dinner at movie producer Harvey Weinstein’s digs.  The town’s First Selectman, Gordon Joseloff, noted that the tightwad-ness could have been softened had the candidate at least held a public event in the form of a visit to the town’s 9/11 memorial—just yards from the helipad used by the candidate to pop in and back out.  Candidate Obama had no time for such things, though.

At $36k per, it would seem half a meal—or just the table scraps—would have covered the town’s costs for the fundraisers.  I have to ask, then: is the Obama campaign that broke, or just that cheap?  And is it broke/cheap only fiscally, or morally, also?

“Not Useful”

Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Martin Dempsey insists that Americans shouldn’t be criticizing American leadership because they once were in uniform.  He seems to think that their free speech rights—appropriately curtailed (but not abrogated) along with a number of other fundamental rights while serving on active duty—become permanently lost to these men and women by dint of their military service.  He says that the political activity of Americans, once having served in uniform, is “not useful.”

Dempsey had this to say, in particular, last Wednesday about a 22 minute film released by the organization Special Ops OPSEC, a group that consists of a broad range of ex-military, ex-CIA, and others no longer affiliated with the military or any Federal agency:

If someone uses the uniform, whatever uniform, for partisan politics, I am disappointed because I think it does erode that bond of trust we have with the American people[.]

I have to wonder if Gen Dempsey actually has viewed the video (presented on the organization’s Home page, as well as here).  I saw no uniforms on any of the participants, and none of the participants were on active duty.

Indeed, as one participant put it, correctly (at about 16:20 of the video),

As a citizen, it is my civic duty to tell the President to stop leaking information to the enemy.  It will get Americans killed.

It’s dismaying that Dempsey seems not to understand that.

There’s more: Dempsey appears to disagree with a former SecDef.  Or were Robert Gates’ two years on active duty in the United States Air Force not long enough to disqualify his free speech rights in perpetuity?  Gates had this to say about the ongoing leaks:

Shut the f— up.

The men and women in uniform understand that they cannot engage in political activity while in uniform as well as the legitimacy of that ban.  Jamie Wilson (Col, Special Forces, Ret) noted this while making a larger point about the need to have a watchdog facility to make it harder for politicians to leak information for political gain.  On telling former colleagues at a military installation about this plan, their response was (roughly 18:03):

You’ve got to do this.  You’ve got to speak, because we can’t.

I have to wonder how politicized Dempsey has allowed himself to become with this blatant attempt to stifle the free speech of honorable Americans, whose only misbehavior is that they publically disagree with his boss.  Dempsey’s behavior is “not useful.”