The US Flag Is Litter?

An Alabama home owners association thinks so.  This is an image of the letter sent to residents of a condo unit (the unit is owned by one of the resident’s parents).

In case it’s hard to read in this post, the typed part of the letter reads

Resident,
It has come to our attention that you have items in plain sight that are not to be visible from the parking lot by rules and guidelines stated in the home owners association bylaws.  Please remove the following listed item(s) as soon as possible to keep the community as tidy as possible.

The hand written part reads

Your flag attached to the stairs has to be removed ASAP!

When the recipients of this clean-up letter posted it on a number of veteran advocacy Facebook pages, the resulting uproar included a flood of communications to the home owners association president and condo property manager, Carol Coffey, objecting vociferously to the demand and to the implication that the American flag is just litter to be swept away.

In fact, such association bylaws that ban the US flag from public display on (condo owners’, for instance) private property are a violation of Federal law [emphasis in the original; a copy of the law can be seen here or here]:

A condominium association, cooperative association, or residential real estate management association may not adopt or enforce any policy, or enter into any agreement, that would restrict or prevent a member of the association from displaying the flag of the United States on residential property within the association with respect to which such member has a separate ownership interest or a right to exclusive possession or use.

Coffey had this to say to justify her clean-up letter:

I served in Afghanistan, I served in Iraq, and I served in Kuwait.  I am not anti-veteran, and I am not a communist[.]

And

In order to maintain the integrity of that asset [the condominium complex], we have certain rules because people could put anything out here if we let them.

Because, she says, the association bylaws are in place to maintain property value, and naturally, the American flag is just any old thing, and it depresses property values.  Coffey also claimed that she realizes there are laws that protect the right to fly the American flag, but said those are for private property and this condo was not private property, because the condos are owned by a community of people—then she said that the “community of people” who own this particular condo consists of the parents of one of the residents, as noted above.

Coffey had this whine, also:

I think they are persecuting us without knowing all the facts.  And here’s one thing that really bothers me…this person got the letter from our management team and instead of coming to the board and expressing his concern, he went and posted something on two or three veteran’s sites without all the information and without us knowing anything about it, and now we’re being threatened—that’s not right.

That’s valid as far as it goes; she shouldn’t be getting threatened.  But.  In most (all?) other legal matters, a fundamental doctrine is that ignorance of the law is no excuse.  And she’s already said she knew the law; it wasn’t a matter of her not “knowing anything about it.”  She sent her clean-up letter anyway.

Since she already knew her letter was…invalid…it’s also hard to see what good spending time protesting to her about her letter would have done, especially since that time would have violated her ASAP demand.

The right answer is to stop “considering” waivers, but to correct her homeowners association bylaws so as both to not conflict with Federal law and separately to recognize that our flag, in its own right, is a proper item to display.

A Thought on Defined Benefits vs Defined Contributions

The Wall Street Journal described some of the problems with defined benefit plans—pensions.

When United Parcel Service Inc said last month that it was taking a noncash charge of $3 billion tied to its pension plan, the package-delivery giant blamed what might seem like an unrelated event: the downgrade last summer of several big banks by Moody’s Investors Service.

But the connection between the two incidents illustrates the complexities of calculating pension liabilities—and how little power companies have in keeping them under control.

UPS is typical, though, not at all unusual, in the problems they’re encountering with their pension plan:

Across America’s business landscape, the gap between the amount that companies expect to owe retirees and what they have on hand to pay them was an estimated $347 billion at the end of 2012.  That is better than the $386 billion gap recorded at the end of 2011, but the two years represent the worst deficits ever, according to JP Morgan Asset Management.
…
A big source of the problem: persistently low interest rates, set largely by the Federal Reserve.

I’ve written about the impact of those artificially low rates here and here.

There are additional major factors in arming this defined benefit bomb.

Putting a value on a pension liability is tricky business. Benefits for individual workers typically are based on their pay and years of service.  A company must also take into account how long retirees are likely to live.

And

Pension liabilities change over time as employees enter and leave a pension plan [including]…the fact that people are living longer.

And

For financial-reporting purposes, companies use a so-called discount rate to calculate the present value of payments they expect to make over the life of their plan.

The discount rate serves as a proxy for the hypothetical interest rate that an insurance company would expect on a bond today to fund a company’s future pension payments.  The lower the discount rate, the greater the company’s pension liabilities.

Boeing’s discount rate, for example, fell to 3.8% last year from 6.2% in 2007.  The aircraft manufacturer said in a securities filing that a 0.25-percentage-point decrease in its discount rate would add $3.1 billion to its projected pension obligations.

That discount rate falls out of those artificially depressed interest rates the Federal Reserve Bank is imposing on our economy.  And that, at the indicated drop in the discount rate works out to a nearly $30 billion increase in Boeing’s defined benefit—pension—liability over those intervening half-dozen years.

Here’s how Moody’s (entirely appropriate) bank downgrade enters into all of this:

Moody’s decision last summer to lower the credit rating of big banks hurt UPS and other companies by booting those banks out of the calculation [because those banks no longer were “safe” enough to have their rates included in the suite of rates used to estimate a discount rate].   And because bonds issued by some of those banks carried higher yields than other bonds used in the calculation, UPS’s discount rate fell 1.20 percentage points.

On the bright side, though, the WSJ article at the link suggests that

…just as falling interest rates have created a massive hole in pension funding, pension plans could quickly recover if interest rates started to climb.

This is a chimera, however.  When the Fed’s already long-term artificially suppressed interest rates are coupled with its massive money printing operation of the last few years, those interest rates will rise, but sharply, in an environment of explosive inflation.  All those dollars that will be paid out to (fixed income) retirees from their nominally recovered defined benefit plans will be worthless as prices those retirees pay with their dollars rise dramatically from that inflation.

Converting to defined contribution plans, like 401(k)s, removes all of these uncertainties from the companies’ liabilities—strengthening them, making them stronger competitors in the market, more stable employers, and so on.  In addition to this, a company’s failure to plan accurately, to fund appropriately its defined benefit plan given that planning, or just to avoid bad luck severely impacts all of its employees (its future retirees) and all of its current retirees.

In contrast, placing these retirement plans into defined contribution plans will let each employee make his own decisions about funding what is now his plan (rather than his employer’s catchall plan), how he wants to accumulate retirement savings, and all in accordance with his own goals and imperatives.  He can tailor his plan to his needs and desires, rather than being dependent on a plan that his employer must drive from a company liability perspective more than from a good for the employee perspective.

Also, should an individual employee fail to plan accurately, to fund appropriately his retirement plan given that planning, or just to avoid bad luck, he only impacts himself and a very few others.  The damage from failure of an individual’s defined contribution plan is enormously circumscribed compared to the damage from failure of a defined benefit plan.

Moreover, an American citizen isn’t as mind-numbingly stupid as our Progressive objectors to defined contribution plans make him out to be.  He’s at least as capable as a company—or a government—in making his own decisions about his future.

Progressive “Capitalism”

The Wall Street Journal describes some concerning our illustrious Treasury Secretary nominee.

The terms of Mr Lew’s original employment contract with Citi included a bonus guarantee if he left the bank for a “high level position with the United States government or regulatory body.”

Most companies include incentives for top employees not to leave, but in this case the contract was written to reward Mr Lew for treating the bank like a revolving door.

There’s more:

…former Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin, who was paid more than $115 million while encouraging the risk-taking that would have destroyed Citi if not for a taxpayer rescue.

Mr Rubin was Mr Lew’s patron at the bank.  Mr Lew’s contract suggests that Citi knew from the start that Mr Lew was headed back to a powerful job in Washington, and that it wanted him to remember the bank fondly when he left.

Hmm….

 

h/t Falkenblog

The Deficit Has A Silver Lining?

Dr Alan Blinder, Princeton University Professor of Economics and Public Affairs, had some thoughts on this.  His piece is fundamentally optimistic, but a few of his remarks jumped out at me.

Congress and the president have managed to agree on several measures that reduce the projected 10-year deficit considerably.

Reduced the 10-year deficit.  He writes of this as if it’s a good thing.  He writes of this as though that continued 10-year deficit, representing as it does an enormous expansion of an already ruinous debt, is a good thing.

Meanwhile, Republicans are talking far less menacingly about either shutting the government down or precipitating a debt crisis.

For which cynical straw man he declines to provide a single quote from a Republican—or Conservative—wherein such a one ever talked about shutting down the government or precipitating a debt crisis in recent history, other than in the context of Progressives manufacturing such things so they can decry them.

That law [the Budget Control Act of 2011] created land mines like the fiscal cliff, but it also cut spending by over $1.9 trillion once you include the associated interest savings, as you should.  (Here and elsewhere, I use the 10-year budget window 2014-2023 and recent estimates from the widely respected Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.)  That was all spending cuts, no tax increases.

Here Blinder is simply being disingenuous.  There were no spending cuts in that Act.  A reduction in the rate of spending increase is still a spending increase.  A Professor of Economics, even one at Princeton, knows that.

Then came the New Year’s Day agreement that averted the cliff. The headline number then was about $600 billion in tax increases.  But if you add in the spending cuts and the associated decrease in debt service, it came to another $850 billion or so.

See above.  And he’s exaggerating the magnitude of the spending increase reduction.

But imagine that our legislators agree instead on a smarter package of spending cuts and revenue raisers that amounts to the same amount of money [as the present sequester cuts].  After all, it’s only about 0.6% of GDP.  Then we’ll have achieved the $4 trillion target.  The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities estimates that doing so would be enough to stabilize the debt-to-GDP ratio at about 73%, which is a sensible goal for now.

There are a couple of things here.  “Cuts and revenue raisers” that achieve the same degree of…something.  Serious cuts in Federal spending would get the government out of the way of the economy, and its recovery—its enthusiastic performance—would raise plenty of revenue for the government, more so than it’s collecting now.  But Blinder and his fellow Progressives, with these demands for more taxes as the only possible revenue raisers are simply demonstrating their contempt for a free market and the wisdom of the individual Americans participating in it, preferring instead an economy centrally directed by Know Better Progressives.

The other thing is that stable debt-to-GDP at 73% nonsense.  This is an amazing thing even for a Princeton Professor to say.  There’s nothing at all stable about such a debt level.

Some of this “cost control” [in his claimed slowing rise in the cost of health care] is due to the weak economy: Hard times lead people to postpone or cancel some medical care.  But health-care inflation began to fall years before the recession began, which suggests that deeper forces are at work.  If we can somehow slow health-care costs to the rate of GDP growth, our long-run budget problem is basically solved.

On the effectiveness of President Barack Obama’s poor economy in holding down cost increases, well NSS.  “If we can somehow slow health-care costs…,” well the answer here is obvious—let a free market work its will in a competitive environment.  But, such an answer truly is not obvious to one who disdains the free market and that wisdom.

…fixation on reducing the budget deficit, to the exclusion of all other national goals, seems strangely anachronistic.  The nation has other priorities, too—such as faster growth and more jobs.

This also is an amazing thing.  The nation does have as critical economic and security imperatives faster growth and more jobs.  But these are not possible to achieve until the budget deficit is eliminated and the debt it drives reduced.