Another Judge and Free Speech

On Friday a Wisconsin judge struck a major blow for free political speech when he quashed subpoenas to conservative groups and ordered the return of property to the targets of a so-called John Doe campaign-finance probe.

Wisconsin John Doe “investigations” are secret, star chamber probes into prosecutorial targets in which even the targets are forbidden to speak publicly.  In this case, the targets were conservative organizations who had supported Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker in that state’s recently concluded recall election (which Walker won by a larger margin than his original election).  This secret fishing expedition was being conducted by special prosecutor Francis Schmitz at the behest of Milwaukee County Assistant District Attorney Bruce Landgraf.

Wisconsin Judge Gregory A. Peterson tossed most of Schmitz’ subpoenas, generally gutting the Landgraf/Schmitz job action.  Peterson was blunt in his ruling:

[The subpoenas] do not show probable cause that the moving parties committed any violations of the campaign finance laws.

And

There is no evidence of express advocacy [as required under Wisconsin law in order t oshow a violation]…the subpoenas fail to show probable cause that a crime was committed.  …the State is not claiming that any of the independent organizations expressly advocated.

Despite disgruntled Wisconsin Democrats’ best efforts (this is the party, remember, that a couple of years ago ran out of Wisconsin en masse, thereby shutting down the state’s government, when they couldn’t get their way on labor law) to continue their attempts to intimidate those of whom they disapprove and to prevent them from speaking, a judge has intercepted their plans and disrupted them, for a time.

A Short Lesson

…in employment history, presented pictorially.

Notice that: the share of working-age Americans had started to fall the year before the Panic of 2008, and it started to fall sharply a few months prior to the Panic’s official start.  Those are economic lags working through the system.

The problem is, the share of potential workers actually working has remained static at its historic low of roughly 58.5% ever since.  That’s not economic lag, that’s failed economic policies over the last several years.

Why Does America Have Poor People?

I’ll start with an old parable.  One man makes $1,000/day, and another makes $10/day.  The “high income” man then opens a factory and hires the “low income” man, and two or three others, at $100/day.  The high income man, with his factory, now makes $2,000/day.  The income disparity difference certainly has increased, markedly, from the original $990/day to $1,900/day.

But has the disparity increased, really?  The high income man, from his factory and hirings has gone from making 100 times the low income man’s earnings to only 20 times that man’s earnings.  And while the high income man’s earnings have doubled, the low income man’s earnings have gone up 10 times.

This brings me to the subject of my post.

We have poor people exactly because the US is the quintessential country where poor people have the opportunity to better themselves, and to do so a very great deal.  They come here from other countries to take advantage of just such opportunities as the parable illustrates, and other opportunities—to be the one who starts the factory, employs others, and both prospers and gives their employees increased prosperity in return for their work.  The same opportunities exist for those who start out as poor US citizens, also.  It’s economic upward mobility that lets people stop being poor and start being middle class, to continue and join the rich, and to set the conditions for their children to do the same and more.

But there’s another reason we have poor people in this country, also.  Despite having spent $20 trillion on poverty programs (I hesitate to call them poverty fighting programs) over the last 50 years, we still have the same per centage of poor people in our population as we had at the start of LBJ’s War on Poverty: 15% of Americans are classed as living in poverty.

Our anti-poverty programs—or at least our programs intended to be anti-poverty—do not encourage people to get off welfare and get a job or get a better job.  Quite the opposite, these programs engender dependence on government in these people.  Here’s how.

As recently as 2005, for instance, poor families spent about two times their income:

A four person-household is in poverty today, according to federal poverty guidelines, if they earn less than $23,550 per year, but the consumer spending of this same household is around $45,000 per year.

They do this not by being able to borrow the difference but because government welfare payments of a variety of sorts, from “assistance” transfers to (refundable) tax credits, make up the difference.  However, because the payments and credits are keyed to household income and not to efforts to work or improve their training and/or education or otherwise to become more self-sufficient and independent, a family whose wage earner(s) get better jobs that increase their income to $40,000 per year—a 70% increase in income—will lose those welfare payments and credits, and will see a net income drop of $5,000 per year to those $40,000—an 11% decrease in actual family income/spending power.

America’s poor aren’t lazy (indeed, the only ones who say so are political hacks trying to make political points by accusing others of saying so); they’re making entirely rational economic decisions, and maximizing (as they see it) their household income.  They’re staying dependent on government rather than coming to rely on their own devices, and opportunities, by logical choice.

And that’s the dead end of our welfare programs.  As structured, these poverty programs do nothing to help our poor, but they do keep our poor poor—and short circuit their opportunity for economic upward mobility.

Security of Personal Information is an Administrative Burden on Government

That’s what the Obama administration claims, and they’re actually serious.

The House of Representatives last Friday passed and sent to the Senate the Health Exchange Security and Transparency Act, HR 3811, by 291-122, with 67 (!) Democrats voting in the affirmative, also.

The one-sentence bill says that no later than two business days after any security breach on an ObamaCare site is discovered, “the Secretary of Health and Human Services shall provide notice of such breach to each individual.”

In response to that one sentence bill (who says we need 2,000 pages to write a bill?), the Obama administration, through its OMB, issued a one-page statement decrying the bill, saying, in part,

The Administration opposes House passage of HR3811 because it would create unrealistic and costly paperwork requirements that do not improve the safety or security of personally-identifiable information in the Health Insurance Marketplaces.

After all, the administration said, the Web site is fine, and Americans’ information is secure.  We said so.  So why should we have to tell anyone their information has been stolen or leaked?  They don’t need to know, and telling them would work a hardship on us.

Never mind that this “hardship” is answered by private enterprise as a matter of unfortunate routine.  Is the administration terrified that Obamacare security breaches might surpass the recent Target breach?  Or are they just worried about the political hardship news of such a breach might work on them in the ballot box?

Oh, and half the OMB statement was wholly irrelevant to the issue at hand, being devoted to Obama’s campaign speech of how wonderful Obamacare is.

The statement can be seen here.

Friday’s Unemployment Numbers

The unemployment rate declined from 7.0% to 6.7% in December, while total nonfarm payroll employment edged up (+74,000)….

However, 347,000 Americans gave up and stopped trying to find work in this December of the fifth year of President Barack Obama’s failed recovery.  Had they kept looking, December’s unemployment would have remained at 7%.  Had the labor force participation rate—which includes those looking for work and still unemployed, mind you—matched December 2012’s rate of 63.6% instead of last December’s 62.8%, December’s unemployment figure would have been 7.7%.

Instead, nearly 2 million Americans have been pushed out of our labor force by Obama’s failed economics.

That’s the last year.  The graph below, from The Federalist, illustrates the failure over the last five years:

The red line in this graph starts in June 2009, the month in which the Panic of 2008 officially ended, and the present “recovery” began.