Political Correctness and Jim Crow

I was taking my daily exercise walk through the neighborhood this morning and had an interesting conversation with a passing motorist.  Since it’s a residential area, I was moseying along in the street, and the motorist stopped and asked why I didn’t like the sidewalk (no snark; he was just curious).  The salient part of the conversation went like this:

Me: “Just habit.  Usually my wife and I walk together, and when we talk, there’s much hand-waving and elbow-flying.  The sidewalk isn’t wide enough for us.”

He: “Oh, you’re Italian.”

Me: “Nah.  We’re American.”  (OK, some leg pulling here.)

He: “No, I meant your heritage is Italian.”

Me: “Nope.  American.”

He: “I get that.  I was asking about your ethnicity.  All that hand stuff, and all.”

Me: “Yeah—like I said, American.”

This completely innocent conversation—the motorist really was just curiously asking about something that seemed entirely natural for him to ask about—illustrates how far we’ve slipped into the mess that is the Politically Correct.  We no longer think of ourselves as Americans.  We think of ourselves, instead, as part of this or that group first, and we just happen to be American, second.  We’re African-Americans. We’re Asian-Americans.  We’re Hispanic-Americans.  We’re XYZ-Americans.  We insist on these group break outs of our American-ness, as though all there is to being an American is the legal citizenship of the country to which we belong, and every difference, however minor, needs anxiously to be preserved.

But we don’t just separate ourselves on ethnicity or skin color.  We segregate along other equally useless lines.  We’re Catholics, first, and Americans second.  Or Protestant.  Or Baptist.  Or Muslim.  Or Jewish.  Or Atheist.  We’re rich, or poor, and American second; union or non-union, and American second.  In a sort of reverse artificial segregation, we can’t hold back a student who isn’t progressing in his studies because keeping him back might “stigmatize” him.  So he’s passed forward, anyway, in a reverse segregation.

This is nothing more than the preservation of the Jim Crow era’s segregation and separate but equal…claptrap.  Today’s segregation, though, is far more insidious than that era’s openly separate water fountains, restrooms, schools for which those Jim Crow Democrats of 50 years ago fought so desperately.  Today, we have “affirmative action” that seeks to give preferential treatment to government-selected groups, not on the basis of merit, but solely on the basis of belonging to the right group.  We have outright quotas, where selection is based solely on belonging to the right group: the process doesn’t even pay lip service to merit.

In the end, this PC-driven segregation accomplishes nothing but the soft bigotry of low expectations about which Bush the Younger spoke some years ago.  Although he was referring specifically to education, this low expectations nonsense is far broader than that.  This soft bigotry justifies government welfare for those “special” groups: government believes the members of these groups cannot—ever—help themselves, an individual in one of these groups cannot—ever—make the right choices, without government handouts and “guidance”  In the end, this PC-segregation serves no other purpose—intended or not—than to keep these government “favored” groups trapped in the Liberal company town, paying for their government welfare with their votes—there being no other product in the company store than dependency, and no other currency for that store’s white goods than the scrip of those votes.

We aren’t Americans who have differing beliefs—which diversity contributes to our greatness as a nation and makes our culture what people of other nations want to immigrate to join.  We aren’t Americans with differing skin tones—which differences gives us a breathtaking range of beauty.   Instead, we are those differences, first and foremost.  That’s the argument, anyway, for Political Correctness.

On second thought, PC is far worse than Jim Crow.

Update: For an additional take on the racist nature of Affirmative Action, see this article from The Wall Street Journal by Ward Connerly, president of the American Civil Rights Coalition and author of “Lessons from My Uncle James: Beyond Skin Color to the Content of our Character” (Encounter Books, 2008).

Another Reason to Privatize Social Security

You can’t have your disability benefits whenever it’s inconvenient to the Federal bureaucrats who control SSA in your name to act promptly.

Social Security bureaucrats—and this includes the Social Security judges who must rule on the legitimacy of a disability application—in at least seven states are slow-walking social security disability applications.  The reason offered is that, in the Federal calendar, which is used for promotion and bonus assessment, the last week of September of this year is a 53rd week due to leap year effects.  Work done in the 53rd week doesn’t count toward meeting the numbers necessary for promotion or “thousands of dollars” of bonuses: they’ve been instructed to hold off on the work for a week so the work will count toward those numbers.  Of course it’s a simple programming task to include 53rd weeks….

Apparently, the Federal bureaucrats’ perks are more important than the disability payments for thousands of Americans.  Of course the SSA spokesman “regrets this occurrence.”  No word on whether Ms Jo Anne B Barnhart herself, the head of the Social Security Administration, “regrets this occurrence.”

Read the whole thing.

Bank Fees on the Rise

Bank of America has announced that it’s going to raise, drastically, the monthly fees for debit card swipes made by its customers.  Why is this bad, though?  It’s certainly true that banking—and shopping—is going to get more expensive for all of us (Wells Fargo and JP Morgan Chase are expected to follow suit, and then the rest of the major banks, and the little banks, will do the same), but is this the real reason?

Big Government, via Dodd-Frank, is dictating limits on what banks can charge for debit card swipes and for a host of other fees.  Dodd-Frank uses the Federal Reserve Bank to cap debit card swipe fees, and the Fed has set this cap at a level that’s 50% of what the banks originally charged, at a cost to those banks of some $16 billion (based on 2009 revenues).  Those additional fee limits will cost still more revenue.  Yet these limits are set in the name of protecting the consumer—us.

Let’s look at the debit card fee limit for a bit.  We use our debit cards 16 times a month on average, for a $10 purchase each time, again on average, according to the Washington Post article at the link.  The merchants used to pay the banks some 4%-6% per debit swipe (depending on the merchant’s size and the size of the actual purchase—that’s the original 44 cent cap on the swipe fee).  Just doing some back of the envelope calculating, we’re buying $160 of goodies each month with our debit cards, and if Bank of America proves typical, we’re going to pay a $5 debit card use fee for that month.  That fee works out to a bit over 3% of our average monthly purchase.  The merchant is still paying 24 cents per transaction: 2.4% of the buy.  Debit card swipe costs now total, then, something like 5.4%.  There’s real change.

Here are some of the unintended consequences of Big Government looking out for the little folks.  In addition to the card swipe problem, for instance, Dodd-Frank makes it difficult for banks to charge for bounced checks—the customer has to agree to be charged beforehand (and there are those other fee caps).  The fees we pay generally will rise because, instead of banks charging those riskier customers higher fees, the Dodd-Frank limits force them to cover those high-risk costs by spreading them across all their customers—low-risk customers are now subsidizing those high-risk ones.

Small checking accounts, the kind held by consumers who aren’t so well off (and that’s a lot of us in this Obama economy) face higher fees to maintain those small balances.  How many of these consumers will be forced to turn to check cashing enterprises, or to prepaid credit cards (with their higher interest rates) and the like, because they cannot—or do not want to—pay the $60/year debit card “convenience” fee?

We’ll also pay more for our credit cards as the banks look to make up for their lost banking fee revenue where they can.  This means higher annual fees, higher interest rates on unpaid balances, and so on, on our credit cards.

Watch out for the results of this latest round of government price controls.  We saw their effectiveness when applied during the Nixon years: gasoline price caps, for instance, intended to fight inflation led to more inflation, gasoline shortages, and long lines at the pump.  We’re already seeing reduced availability of banking services: higher cost for our debit cards, reduced access to low cost checking accounts, harsher credit cards, and so on.

But there’s an additional problem to this government intervention, and it’s a moral one.  One of the most fundamental tenets of our social compact is that each of us is both free to transact our property—our labor, our goods, our money—with others for their property in any way we might mutually agree, and each of us is solely responsible for the outcomes of those transactions.  Government’s sole role under our social compact is to protect that freedom and responsibility.  Yet here we have government’s intervention utterly violating that tenet.  Big Government has determined that it cannot allow two men seeking to do business with each other in a free market to conduct that business unless Big Government is in the middle managing the relationship.  Banks (for instance) no longer can charge high risk customers higher fees: instead, they must, in order to make enough money to stay in business in this regulatory regime, spread those high risk costs across all of their customers.  On what basis should the rest of us be required to subsidize the riskiest?  On what basis does government transfer responsibility from parties to a transaction to others of us who are not involved?

“Bank of America is trying to find new ways to pad their profits by sticking it to their customers,” Senator Dick Durbin, Dem, IL claimed about that debit card fee adjustment.  This, though, is just a paraphrase of what our President has said: “I do think at a certain point you’ve made enough money.”  On what basis does government transfer responsibility from parties to a transaction to itself?

Finally, it’s a bit cheeky for Big Government to dictate to businessmen in the private economy how to handle their accounts, when Big Government has no understanding of the matter whatsoever when it comes to its own accounts.

Bad Moon Rising

The Blessings of Government

Candidate for Senate from Massachusetts, and late of the Consumer Financial Protection BureauAssistant to the President and Special Advisor to Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner, Elizabeth Warren, recently had this to say about our need for big government:

There is nobody in this country who got rich on his own. Nobody. You built a factory out there—good for you. But I want to be clear. You moved your goods to market on the roads the rest of us paid for. You hired workers the rest of us paid to educate. You were safe in your factory because of police forces and fire forces that the rest of us paid for….  You built a factory and it turned into something terrific or a great idea—God bless, keep a big hunk of it. But part of the underlying social contract is you take a hunk of that and pay it forward for the next kid who comes along.

There are some thoughts on this statement.  I paid for those roads, too, not just “the rest of you.”  And that’s a legitimate tax: fostering the free exchange of goods, as well as fostering their easy production, by free citizens is part of the government’s job: under our social contract—the one actually in existence via our Declaration of Independence and our Constitution—the government’s sole job is to protect those individual liberties.  And nothing more.

On the other hand, “the rest of you” didn’t pay for the education of the workers I hired.  My fellow members of my local community and I paid for that education.  As did, individually, all the local communities surrounding all the other factories pay for the education of those factories’ workers.  Your Federal government had little to do with that, Arne Duncan and his Office for Civil Rights’ “Dear Colleague” letter’s attack on the rights of our students notwithstanding.

Further, “the rest of you” didn’t pay for the police and fire protections of my workers—again, the local community around my factory did, and does, that.  “The rest of you,” and I, do pay for the federal police function that keeps our borders secure, and our citizens along the border area safe.  We’re well aware of how that’s working out.

And if my workers and I were able to keep more of our money, instead of having it confiscated by an overreaching government for current spending (note that: not “paying it forward for the next kid”), I’d be able to improve my factory, develop better products, and hire even more workers (educated by local communities, not “the rest of you,” and kept safe by locally funded and manned police forces, not paid forces for by “the rest of you”).  On top of that, if my workers and I were able to keep more of our money, we would be able to put “a hunk of that” by to “pay forward” to our own kids.  But your kind of government won’t even let us do that.  You’re going to increase the death taxes you seize to 55%—at direct cost to those kids.

Progressives and Democracy

The ProgressivesDemocrats have long insisted that they Know Better than mere Americans, and so we should just sit down, shut up, and follow their guidance.  “Throughout the nation men and women, forgotten in the political philosophy of the Government, look to us here for guidance,” said Franklin Roosevelt in his 1932 nomination acceptance speech.  “I think at a certain point, you’ve made enough money,” said Candidate Obama.  Even your estate is better off in the hands of the government—and furthermore, as ex-Congressman Anthony Weiner insists, we shouldn’t even care: “You’ll be dead,” he insisted in a national television interview.

We have, now a governor, Bev Perdue (Dem, NC), saying with a straight face,

I think we ought to suspend, perhaps, elections for Congress for two years and just tell them we won’t hold it against them, whatever decisions they make, to just let them help this country recover. I really hope that someone can agree with me on that….  You want people who don’t worry about the next election.

Of course her aides quickly spoke up and said this was just a joke, just hyperbole to make a point.  And perhaps she was only making a point, but what point?

Here’s the larger backdrop in which the Progressives (dang—I keep confusing them) Democrats are operating and against which Gov. Perdue’s statement was made.  The Democrats in the Wisconsin and Indiana State Houses both openly attacked our democratic foundation by going AWOL in mid-session, preventing their respective State governments from doing the job they’d been elected to do—from functioning at all—on the premise that if they couldn’t have their way, the good citizens of these States couldn’t have democracy.  A critical part of Obamacare is the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB)—the death panel—consisting of “experts” who will dictate cuts to Medicare payments to doctors and hospitals, rationing health care in accordance with their own criteria, not the doctor’s or hospital’s decisions in conjunction with the patient in question.  These Democrats’ death panels are almost without oversight: the panel’s decisions must be positively overruled by Congress, our representatives, rather than be positively accepted.  The Obama Congress created an entity known as the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau which is totally outside the oversight of Congress, getting its funding from Treasury essentially on demand.  This unaccountable entity has powers to dictate to banks, and to the mom and pop grocery store, the terms under which, for instance, they might offer credit to a customer.  The Democrats in the present United States Senate threatened us all with a Federal government shutdown and proximately with denial of funds to FEMA so thousands of Americans suffering ongoing emergencies from natural disasters like Hurricane Irene and flooding along the Mississippi River would go unaided solely because these Democrats weren’t going to be allowed to continue their profligate spending to which they’re so addicted.  The list goes on, but the backdrop for Gov. Perdue’s “suggestion” is plain.

Perdue’s rationale for this?  It’s in her statement:  “…tell them we won’t hold it against them….  You want people who don’t worry about the next election.”  Umm, Governor, that’s sort of the point of democracy, including—especially—the republican democracy that we have.  These folks work for us; we’re not hanging around just to give them something to do.  They do need to be worrying about the next election; they do need to be worrying about their jobs.  We sent them to Washington (and your constituents sent their representatives—and you—to the NC state house) with specific instructions.  If they don’t, or won’t, do what we told them to do, they need to get gone at the next election.  But a Progressive (dang!) governor doesn’t seem to get this.

Just whose side are these…Democrats…on?  Besides their own?

Update: Here’s Gov Perdue in all her glory, courtesy of The Daily Caller via PowerLine: Gov Perdue  You decide whether she was joking, or hyperbolizing….