The Caliphate

Is it being established after all, and with the present administration’s acquiescence through ignorance?

There’s this from the Pittsburgh post-gazette (h/t to BLACKFIVE):

The war in Afghanistan may end this year in thinly disguised surrender.

“The Taliban per se is not our enemy,” Vice President Joe Biden said in an interview with Newsweek magazine Dec. 15.

We went to war in Afghanistan to oust the Taliban regime because it had sheltered al-Qaida. Perhaps Mr. Biden forgot.

and [link added]

A story in an Indian newspaper Dec. 29 suggests the reason for the vice president’s memory lapse.  The Obama administration apparently is conducting secret negotiations with the Taliban and has recruited Yusuf al-Qaradawi, the Muslim Brotherhood’s leading jurist, to mediate them.  “Earlier this month, Mr. al-Qaradawi helped draw a road map for a deal between the Taliban and the United States aimed at giving the superpower a face-saving political settlement ahead of its planned withdrawal from Afghanistan, which is due to begin in 2014,” wrote reporter Praveen Swami, citing “Indian diplomatic sources.”

Mr. al-Qaradawi seeks the establishment of a worldwide caliphate ruled by Islamic law.

(Mr Swami also goes on at some length about al-Qaradawi and the threat he poses to India as well as to the West.)

BLACKFIVE points out this:

The bottom line is we have been severely weakened by Obama….  We can start w/ losing one war and one peace [respectively, Afghanistan and Iraq],…the Arab Spring installing Islamists in Egypt, Libya and much of the rest of the Middle East….

Spain surrendered to the Islamists some years ago when it was driven from Afghanistan with its tail between its legs after a series of train bombings followed by instructions from the bombers’ handlers to depart forthwith.

Withal, we have the Umayyad Caliphate being rebuilt from the Middle East west across north Africa and back onto the Iberian Peninsula to the Pyrenees, and east through Pakistan and back into Afghanistan.  The lone holdouts seem to be Portugal and the Sarkozy French in and above Iberia, and a seemingly abandoned Israel in the heart of the redeveloping Caliphate.  It’s true enough that the present reconstruction is no more monolithic than were the Umayyads, but that doesn’t reduce the present threat any more than it did with the Umayyads.  Especially given the current Islamist goals.

National Defense Cuts vs National Defense Purpose

Yochi J. Dreazen  of the National Journal describes the announced US military reduction as follows.  He characterizes the reduction as “a decisive shift away from manpower-heavy counterinsurgencies like Afghanistan,”  and this isn’t inaccurate.  Our military leadership, in fact, insists

that ground wars like Afghanistan are a thing of the past while air and naval conflicts with nations like Iran or China represent the most important threats of the future. The document explicitly said the Pentagon will shift military and financial resources away from Europe and toward the Middle East and Asia-Pacific regions.

and consequently,

potentially significant cuts to the size of the Army and Marine Corps[.]

However,

Both men [Panetta and Obama] have previously indicated that the purchases of costly armaments like the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter, the most expensive warplane ever built, and several next-generation types of warships may be slowed or reduced to save money, though they offered no new details on Thursday.

There are some problems with this thinking, though.  In the first place, if the primary upcoming threats are Iran and the PRC, then what do they call the terrorist organizations like the ones actively at war with us now?  These are just competitors, then?

Secondly, if we’re to rely on our Navy in the Asia-Pacific region, and PRC is building up its navy, its long-range counter-ship capability, and its air force, how will we deter and defeat that threat without modernized—and more—ships?

Thirdly, do we no longer care about the safety of our only reliable ally in the Middle East, Israel?  Are there no important threats there to our interests or to our ally?  Or, for how long do the Pentagon and the White House expect that Israel can hold out while we’re “spoiling” an attack there, perhaps one by a nuclear Iran, while we are fully engaged elsewhere?

Additionally, air and naval forces can’t seize and hold territory—which is what terrorist organizations and their supporting nations, as well as directly threatening nations occupy.  To defeat these enemies, we need to take their territory away from them and hold it ourselves until a more peaceable government can be installed.  That requires ground forces not merely equipped and trained to the task, but numerous enough for it, as well.

Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta says

The U.S. joint force will be smaller and it will be leaner.   The Army and Marine Corps will no longer need to be sized to support the kind of large-scale, long-term stability operations that dominated military priorities…over the past decade.

He’s partly correct.  The Marines are an expeditionary force, best used for power projection and for breaking down the barriers to entry into enemy territory, and it’s the Army’s job to complete that entry and then to effect the subsequent destruction of the enemy’s ability to prosecute his war against us.  Reversion of the Marines to its primary role—if that’s what’s actually intended, and not simply a “cost-saving” across the board slashing of manpower for its own sake—is a useful move.  However, also stripping the Army of the numbers it needs to do its job—and there is a threshold number required, regardless of skill and equipage—simply strips us of our ability to protect ourselves.

Dreazen adds

Canceling or curtailing planned weapons buys is always difficult politically because lawmakers typically work to shield armaments built in their states as a way of saving jobs. It is likely to be even harder now because of election-year partisanship and legitimate concerns about the Pentagon taking steps that would almost certainly mean job losses at a time of deep economic weakness throughout the U.S.

To a large extent, though, as with the “smaller and leaner” bit above, this is only partially true.  Where weapons systems cuts are legitimate—the F-22 is a prime example of a boon-doggle, and the F-35, within the new defense concept, is of questionable value, unless it can deliver the goods in the secondary “spoiling” engagements elsewhere in the world that is a part of this new “fight one and hope for the best everywhere elsedenying and deterring aggression elsewhere” strategy—the systems should be eliminated and the funds put to better use in the DoD.

On the other hand, systems that are necessary for this new strategy (vis., modernized and enlarged naval forces, longer-ranged air forces with larger payloads and better protection systems, and additional forward basing systems in places like, oh say, the Republic of China, the Republic of the Philippines, the Socialist Republic of Vietnam, the Republic of India) will need to be increased, not cut.  Congressmen of all parties and independencies will have to decide whether they’re going to be partisan hacks for favored private companies or Representatives of their constituents come together with their fellows at the Federal level, and look to doing what’s best for the nation as a whole: making the requisite cuts here and increases there, regardless of personal political profit.

Finally, I have to ask:  Is Panetta now suggesting we have no more need of dealing with terrorists?  The GWOT is over?  As I mentioned above, neither insurgency and its associated terrorism, nor terrorism directed against us or our friends and allies, are destroyed unless someone is prepared, in the aftermath of the fighting, to occupy the territory and engage in “stability operations.”  In the end, assuming we’ve won the proximate fight, who else will conduct the stability operations?  The just defeated nation?  With what resources, and to what motivated end?  Europe?  With what resources?  They ran out of bombs five minutes into the Libyan No Fly campaign and had to drop American ordnance for the duration.  Given that failure, from where will Europe get the manpower and equipment—including civil engineering manpower and equipment—to conduct stability operations?  Or is Panetta’s plan to simply to shoot up the area, crush the enemy forces in the field, for today, and then just walk away?  This seems somehow…incomplete.

In the end, the Pentagon and the White House seem to have lost sight of a fundamental tenet: quantity has a quality of its own.  What’s the value of the best trained, best equipped, most courageous and dedicated force in the world if it can be overwhelmed by sheer numbers from an attacker that cares not a whit about his own casualty rate, so long as he kills and wins the battle?  The terrorists in the World Trade Center attacks achieved ~110:1 kill ratio, and at Mumbai the terrorists achieved a kill ratio of nearly 20:1.  Across both attacks, one attacker survived.  The enemy simply didn’t care; he achieved his goals.

In the Korean War, the PRC forces kept coming against the American and Republic of Korean forces, absorbing enormous casualties to achieve their victories.  Over the course of the Chosin Reservoir battle, for instance, the Chinese absorbed nearly 50% casualties in their attempt to pen up and destroy an Allied force half their size at the start of the battle.  Even though the allied force escaped, the Chinese carried the battlefield, and so they counted the outcome as worth its cost.

Our enemies don’t think like us; it’s foolish—and fatal—to base our planning, strategy, and tactics on the assumption that they do.

It appears the present “draw-down” is based more on political rationale than on the evolving threat environment.  Our new national defense concept seems based on a muddled, ill-thought out view of the purpose of our national defense, and of who the threats against us really are.

There are nation-states that remain our enemies and would like nothing more than to see our destruction.  War is not out of the question with these.  There are non-national organizations that already are at war with us, intending to destroy us.  The force structures and capability sets necessary to engage and destroy these threats are as different from each other as are the threats themselves.

Does any rational person really think the proposed rump military that will result from the present reduction will be capable of being fully engaged simultaneously against both types of threats and defeat them—rather than itself being destroyed in those battles leaving us disarmed and helpless?  Or that it’ll be able to function at all without control of the high ground—space—which went completely unmentioned?

They Don’t Get It

Jim Tankersley of the National Journal is talking about the just concluded Iowa Caucus.

…what Republicans have on their hands now, and will likely have until the party rallies around a nominee to face President Obama, is another chapter in a longstanding struggle among ideological factions within their party—factions including social conservatives, libertarians, business leaders, and the GOP political establishment.

Perhaps the starkest divide came on the question of what caucus-goers were looking for most in a presidential candidate.

This is a typical misunderstanding of the dynamic.  Rather than the Democratic Party’s demand that its members strictly accept the party line handed down by its leadership, conflicts among Republicans in their primaries constitute a microcosm of democracy in action.  This is simply the open debate through which the party arrives at its position, for good or ill, with no fear of the public listening in.  In fact, the eavesdropping is encouraged; it helps the public understand the positions developed.  This is in sharp contrast to the Democrats’ philosophy of monolithic positions, against which disagreement is not allowed.

Of course it could be argued, without being too far wrong, that the Republicans depend too much on the publicness of their debates as their means of messaging, rather than, having arrived at a position, going to that same public and speaking to us directly and plainly.

The Progressives’ misunderstanding goes far further, though.

There’s no unifying characteristic of the economic proposals offered by Iowa’s top-finishing trio of Romney, Santorum and Rep. Ron Paul, other than their general conservatism; the three plans differ sharply on core economic issues, including how much to cut taxes, how deeply to slash the federal budget, and how to spur new investment in America.

And yet these plainly are “unifying characteristics:” cut corporate taxes, slash government spending, spur new investment.  The differences among the candidates on these, as monolithic Democrats do not understand, are not yawning chasms, but  minor quibbles around the edges.  Moreover, this unifying message stands in sharp contrast to the Progressives’ unifying characteristics: raise taxes, spend even more, use subsidies to favored businesses for spurring “investment.”

Further, the Republicans have succeeded in changing the dynamic of the public discourse.  There’s no more argument over the specific size of tax increases, or of spending increases (or fictitious reductions in future spending increases), or how large government should be.  It’s about how much lower to reduce tax rates, how much to cut from actual spending, how small government should be.

What the Democrats Stand for in the Coming Campaign

Straight from the horse’s mouth.  As President Obama says,

Part of what 2012 is about is…framing this larger debate about what kind of country are we going to leave for our children and our grandchildren….

He’s right about that.

Then he says that Republican policies amount to

…a different theory that says, we’re going to cut taxes for the wealthiest among us, and roll back regulations on things like clean air and health care reform and Wall Street reform, and that somehow, automatically, that assures that everybody is able to succeed.

This is his demonization of his opposition’s desire, and the American people’s need, to get government out of the way of our economy so that it can begin to recover, and to get government out of our lives so that we can go about our business free of government interference.

Further, the Progressives of the Obama party insist that government Knows Better.  Government should be populated with university-trained Patrons who will run our economic and social lives, because we can’t be trusted to manage our own: more government management of competition, for instance (the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau), and Obamacare, under which Big Government presumes to be to dictate to us what we will buy or not buy.

And the Democrats stand for government by fiat, and the Constitution be damned.  On Wednesday, Obama simply ignored Constitutional requirements and appointed Richard Cordray as CFPB director, despite the fact that the Senate has not advised and consented to Cordray’s appointment.  Obama claims this is a recess appointment; however, the Senate is not in recess.  Doesn’t matter.  “I refuse to take ‘no’ for an answer,” says he.  He followed this with another unconstitutional set of appointments, this time of three new members that must be Senate-approved–but without that approval, and while the Senate is in session–to flesh out the blatantly pro-union NLRB.

We can look forward to bigger government, more governmental interference in our affairs, and the removal of the Constitution from its status as the supreme Law of the Land if the Progressives are reelected this year.

Another thing for which the Progressives stand in the coming campaign: ad hominem attacks on their opponents, since the Dems can’t run on their record of accomplishment—or on their ideology.

Gridlock Works

Lost in the hoo-raw over the payroll tax reduction extension at the end of the year was Congressional inaction on a couple of other weighty matters—and this inaction redounds to our benefit.

Congress failed to continue a 45 cent per gallon tax credit for corn-based ethanol and a 54 cent per gallon tariff on imported ethanol (mostly from Brazil—Obama wants us to be one of their best customers).  Since these two items were among the few things Congress even constructed reasonably—they actually had sunset clauses—they expired Dec. 31.  Of course we can expect the Progressives to attempt to redress this egregious failure or to score the evil Republicans for stopping a resumption—that is, if the Republicans find their courage, lost in the debt ceiling fiasco and which loss was underscored by their screw-up on the payroll tax reduction, and block a resumption.

Another useless “green” subsidy expired through Congress’ inaction, also: the thousand dollar tax credit for installing an electric car charging station in a residential garage expired, as did the related tax credit (up to $30 thousand) for installing a commercial charging station.

Unfortunately, the gridlock didn’t achieve a sweep: fuel refiners still are required to add 36 billion gallons of ethanol to their fuel mixes by 2022, and the (maximum) $7,500 tax credit for buying an electric car remains in place.

Of course, as with all subsidies, these had just made the subsidized items more expensive.  The 45 cent credit for the ethanol-in-gasoline just followed the fuel right into your cost at the pump, for instance.  The $6 billion per year we taxpayers were being hit for this credit bought everyone else’s ethanol gasoline.  And we paid those $6 billion even when we bought an electric car, instead.  Those of us that have bought one; sales are steady, but far from outstanding.

That credit for buying the electric car is interesting in its own right.  Just to take an anecdote for an illustration, a Ford Fusion (ignoring the usual haggling, and only looking at MSRP) runs around $20 thousand.  The correspondingly ungussied-up Fusion Hybrid is a bit under $29 thousand.  With the subsidytax credit, that drops the Hybrid to a shade over $21 thousand.

In some cases, the credit doesn’t do the buyer as much good, though.  The Tesla’s Model S is a $50 thousand electric car, and their Roadster seems, from Tesla‘s Web site, to be of a price that if you have to ask, you can’t afford it.  The tax credit doesn’t have so much practical effect here.  As to the Fisker Karma, well, that electric car isn’t available at any price, at least for a while: its batteries are…defective.  The credit is useless for it.

Maybe instead of renewing the ethanol subsidies, we can get Congress to eliminate the electric car subsidy and the requirement to dump ethanol into our gasoline, too.  Keep in mind that ethanol is hard on your car‘s engine.

Or am I hoping for too much change this year?