Greek Bailout, More

I wrote last fall on this subject.  Even though a new round of bailout funding is being discussed, my argument hasn’t changed.  Now, though, Spiegel Online International reports that it appears that European leaders are beginning to recognize the folly, as well: it’s best to cut the Greeks loose to find their own way, and to find their freedom from the fiscal bondage that ever-increasing debt and continued Greek resistance to making serious spending cuts are creating.  Yet the majority continue to cling to their asserted need for bailouts.

Everyone knows that Greece cannot repay its massive pile of debts, now at more than €350 billion ($459 billion).  But instead of effectively reducing the financial burden, European politicians intend to approve new loans for the government in Athens and go on fighting debt with new debt.  “If the country wants to remain in the euro zone, we should support it,” says Austrian Chancellor Werner Faymann.

And

If there are no other options, says Luxembourg Finance Minister Luc Frieden, “the public sector may have to provide more money.”

And

The representatives of the so-called troika, consisting of the European Commission, the European Central Bank (ECB) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF), estimate the shortfall [for the second round of bailout payouts] to be about €15 billion, meaning that Greece needs €145 billion instead of €130 billion.

The only other option is to redistribute the burden. Under the current program, the IMF is responsible for about one-third, and the Europeans for two-thirds of the costs.

But these illustrate the depth of the Greek problem, and the inability of additional borrowing, of additional bailouts to solve the problem.

 

 

With the Greek debt exploding and its economic output shrinking, if not actually collapsing, there is no hope of repayment—or of growth at all.  Furthermore, this leadership school assumes, erroneously, that the “burden” should exist in the first place.  And it demonstrates their confusion of who it is that bears this burden.  It’s not the EU piggy bank owners from whom the bailout funds are intended to be collected.  It’s the Greeks, who are being burdened with even greater debt that they cannot repay, and so with even greater servitude, onto whom this burden is being loaded.  It has even been proposed that an external “budget commissioner,” with authority to veto Greek tax and spending decisions, be imposed on Athens.

But others of the political class are beginning to object to continuing the bailout.

[I]n Germany, the main donor country, leading politicians within the two coalition parties, the CDU and the business-friendly Free Democratic Party (FDP), do not believe that a majority of parliamentarians will vote for additional aid to Greece.

More generally,

The German government feels that the financial sector should bear much of the additional burden. If additional funds were needed, the banks would simply have to contribute more, the Germans argue.

This attitude is spreading beyond Germany, too; although without the economic powerhouse of Europe, the future of any more bailing out is highly questionable.

Moreover, the reasons for the growing reluctance, beyond a growing understanding of the folly of bailing out a debt crisis by increasing debt, are becoming more apparent.

The Greek economy is not productive enough to generate growth. Aside from olive oil, textiles and a few chemicals, there are hardly any Greek products suitable for export. On the contrary, Greece is dependent on food imports to feed its population.

“Greece has been living beyond its means for years,” an unpublished study by the German Institute for Economic Research (DIW) concludes. “The consumption of goods has exceeded economic output by far.”

And this [emphasis added]:

…lack of progress on austerity measures long-since passed.  Attempts to privatize state-owned enterprises, for example, have met with limited success at best.  The Greek government initially announced it intended to raise €50 billion in four years by selling state-owned companies and property—a sum that was calculated into the country’s financing needs.

But lack of interest has crippled the program.  In 2011, the government’s privatization program brought in just €1.7 billion instead of the €5 billion planned.  In 2012, expectations have been reduced from €11 billion to just €4.7 billion. Government-owned enterprises in Greece are simply not competitive enough to attract investors.

A solution is being offered.

Instead, economists recommend finally doing what is already unavoidable: sending the country into an orderly insolvency. Greece’s government creditors, which include the ECB and, most of all, the partner countries that have lent the country money until now, would have to abandon about half of their claims so that the country’s mountain of debt could be reduced to a tolerable level.  Then the measures that can return the Greek economy to growth on its own can become more effective: reforms in the labor market, more competition in the service industries and foreign investment.

I’ve insisted all along that Greek bankruptcy is necessary to free the Greeks and give them a new start.  If the Europeans think an “orderly bankruptcy” can be arranged, more power to them.  However, the success of this, with its continued Greek membership of Greece in the EU and in the euro zone, depends on those follow-on reforms actually be implemented—particularly labor reforms, and one not mentioned: getting all Greeks to pay all of their taxes.  I’m not sanguine about either, but especially about the reforms.  Nevertheless, bankruptcy is the only way out for Greece, the only way back to freedom and solvency.

Success Criteria

President Obama is actually bragging about this.

President Barack Obama wears his decision to rescue General Motors and Chrysler three years ago as a badge of honor, a move to save jobs in an industry that helped create the backbone of the middle class more than a half-century ago.

…pointing to GM’s reemergence as the world’s largest automaker and job growth and profitability in the U.S. auto industry.

But Obama disingenuously argues from a false premise.  The American auto industry was—and is—in sound health.  Two auto companies, GM and Chrysler, were in trouble.  One of those, courtesy of the Obama “bailout,” now is no longer an American car company.  Chrysler is owned by the Italian company, Fiat.  And both companies still owe significant amounts of money to the government.

The American auto industry, though, consisted—and consists—of GM, Chrysler, Ford, Toyota, Honda, Kia, Nissan, and a number of other companies, all of whom assemble cars at plants in the US, and none of whom build cars from the ground up in the US.  All but two of these never were in serious trouble, and all but two are very sound companies today.  Without bailouts.

Furthermore, if GM is so profitable, why is this administration reluctant to sell the shares of government ownership—oh, wait, that would result in an enormous loss.  GM stock currently sells for $24; it needs to reach $53 to recoup the bailout money poured in.  This highly “profitable” company began 2011 selling at $36, and it’s been downhill all year.  We taxpayers have $23 billion in the wind as GM stock falls away from that break-even point.  On the other hand, why won’t Obama’s administration issue the government’s shares to its rightful owners—us, whose tax money funded the bailouts and paid for those shares—and let us retain or sell our shares according to our own decision criteria?

Chrysler is privately owned, so its valuation is harder to determine, but we Americans, through the Obama administration, own a significant fraction of this private company.  The same questions apply here.

Governor Mitt Romney pointed out at the time, and he repeats it today,

[C]apital markets and bankruptcy—it works in the U.S.  The idea of billions of dollars being wasted initially, then finally they adopted the managed bankruptcy.

Indeed, Obama’s “bailout” abused the bankruptcy system already in place, and it abused the companies’ creditors: GM’s senior creditors got a tiny fraction of what they were owed—and were denounced by Obama as “greedy speculators,” and threatened with getting nothing at all if they didn’t shut up—while the union was handed a 17.5% ownership.

Today, Obama, Vice President Joe Biden, et al., claim the decision saved an estimated 1 million jobs throughout the Midwest.  Former Governor Ted Strickland (D, OH) even says,

I don’t know how any reasonable person can fail to acknowledge that this rescue plan worked and the country has benefited.

However, they cynically refuse to offer any concrete, objective evidence to substantiate these claims.

They provide, instead, only anecdotes of union assertions and claims by those beholden to the Obama administration for having received government paymentshandouts from it.]

Notice that.  It doesn’t get any plainer.  This administration ignored bankruptcy law, ignored bankruptcy courts, pushed senior creditors to the back and gave the companies to the unions and to the government.  We’re still owed $30 billion on the “bailout” that we’ll never get back, and the fiasco resulted in two companies being owned by the US government, the Canadian government, the auto unions, and the foreign car company, Fiat.  The unions and Fiat remain the primary owners, the US government still owns significant portions.

Think about this administration’s definition of success and its view of the law as it implements its definition as you go to the polls this fall.

The President’s Republican Plans

President Obama, in his State of the Union address, spoke passionately of bringing manufacturing back to the US, of bringing in particular high-tech manufacturing back.

An America that attracts a new generation of high-tech manufacturing and high-paying jobs. … So we have a huge opportunity, at this moment, to bring manufacturing back. But we have to seize it….  It’s not fair when foreign manufacturers have a leg up on ours only because they’re heavily subsidized. … And this Congress should make sure that no foreign company has an advantage over American manufacturing when it comes to accessing finance or new markets like Russia. Our workers are the most productive on Earth, and if the playing field is level, I promise you—America will always win.

Republicans have been pushing for this—both manufacturing and dealing with economic cheaters—for quite some time.

And

…if you’re an American manufacturer, you should get a bigger tax cut. If you’re a high-tech manufacturer, we should double the tax deduction you get for making products here.

This has been a campaign theme of Senator Rick Santorum, in particular, for some time (although, let’s not forget that Obama’s tax plans aren’t entirely beneficial—he still demands to raise taxes on those groups of which he disapproves).

He also wants to boost domestic energy production.

Nowhere is the promise of innovation greater than in American-made energy. Over the last three years, we’ve opened millions of new acres for oil and gas exploration, and tonight, I’m directing my Administration to open more than 75 percent of our potential offshore oil and gas resources. Right now, American oil production is the highest that it’s been in eight years. That’s right—eight years. Not only that—last year, we relied less on foreign oil than in any of the past sixteen years.
But with only 2 percent of the world’s oil reserves, oil isn’t enough.

This has been the push of Republicans for years.  The complaint has been about the Obama administration actively interfering with domestic energy production, from slow-walking offshore drilling permits (after an outright ban following the BP spill) to nixing the Keystone XL pipeline that would have brought Canadian oil into the US—North American, if not domestic.

I won’t go (far) into fact checking Obama’s claims in that segment (like that 2% claim, which actually refers to the amount of oil that is recoverable at current prices and under lands currently available by Federal fiat for development.  In fact, according to the Institute for Energy Research, the US has more than 1.4 trillion barrels of recoverable oil, more than the rest of the world (excluding North America) combined).  It’s enough that Obama is, apparently, embracing another Republican policy.

All this comes against the backdrop of Obama’s failed economic policies.  He chose not to address the budget disaster in his SOTUS, and he’s chosen to ignore it in his re-election campaign these last several months.  Beyond this, Obama’s Progressive Congress approved $4 trillion worth of economic stimulus via deficit spending, spending which has supported historically high unemployment rates for historically long periods, and which spending has suppressed the cyclical economic recovery that’s been struggling since spring 2009 when the present recession “ended.”  Further, in these last three years the national debt has exploded to more than $15 trillion, equal to the nation’s whole GDP.

Hmm….

Outcome Inequality

The Daily Caller is writing about “The Inequality Trap,” in the context of income inequality.  Indeed, TheDC points out the hypocrisy generally inherent in the plaints:

At the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, last week, heads of state and billionaires from around the globe lamented the fact that some people are not as well off as they are, and called for government to do something about it. Then they went skiing.

And our favorite uncle Warren Buffet decries the premise that he pays less (income) tax than his secretary and wants government to raise his taxes—all the while declining to make donations to the Treasury and while doing everything legally within his and his accountants’ skill to reduce his own total tax bite.

Income or tax inequality, though, is just a small part of a larger item—inequality of outcomes generally.  The fact is, we can have equality of opportunity, as the principles statement of our social contract, or Declaration of Independence, promises us; or we can have equality of outcomes, as the Progressives today want us to have.  We can’t have both.

Not every individual has the same degree of talent, or capability, or work ethic of every other individual.  John Adams understood this:

Although, among men, all are subject by nature to equal laws of morality, and in society have a right to equal laws for their government, yet no two men are perfectly equal in person, property, understanding, activity, and virtue, or ever can be made so by any power less than that which created them.

Forcing equal outcomes, then, is nothing more than denial of a more successful man’s right to the fullness of his Liberty and Life by denying him the right to the fruits of his success, his right to achieve his fullest potential, and it holds him back for no other reason than that others have not kept up.  This also subsidizes the less successful so they have the same outcomes as the more successful independently of their own labors.  This government subsidy, then, usurps that individual’s right to make his own decisions and makes the government responsible for each individual’s welfare, eliminating that individual’s own responsibilities and obligations.

But restraining the more successful, or subsidizing the less successful, are the same thing: the more successful are denied full value for their work, their talent, and their skills.  In the first instance, the more successful are held back directly, with the full measure of their success denied them.  In the second, the more successful are denied the same extra return to their performance that is awarded the less successful through subsidy.  Here, for instance, is every child receiving a prize, independent of the outcome from his effort or skill or talent, and so both the self-esteem of the child who did not do well and that of the child who won the competition are damaged by not being able to reap a reward consistent with actual effort or reap the consequences of failure and the opportunity to learn from that—with its own concomitant return to self-esteem.  Each child functionally receives only a participation award.  Here, too, is the high school orchestra, having won a state-wide competition in one year denied by rule the opportunity to compete at all in the following year.  This punishment for success denies the successful orchestra the opportunity for further success, and it denies the newly “winning” orchestra the opportunity to show that it is truly the best by outperforming last year’s winner.  Here, too, is the man who worked hard, both at the particular endeavor and at acquiring the skills necessary for success in the endeavor, and who was able to bring his talent to bear, being forced to give up some portion of the results of his more successful effort to another who did not do as well.  This concept of equal outcomes punishes the successful for their success, and it denies the unsuccessful the opportunity to do better and to become successful in their own right.

Instead, under our social compact, each American has an equal opportunity to achieve his version of the American dream, to achieve the full potential of his own capabilities.  This necessarily produces unequal outcomes when measured merely by fiscal wealth or material possession.  However, this equal opportunity is a grand implementation of American rights and liberties, as it provides the greatest equality for the protections of each one’s existence, rights, freedoms, and social well-being.  This also produces the greatest moral strength.

Thomas Jefferson understood this, too:

To take from one, because it is thought his own industry and that of his fathers has acquired too much, in order to spare others, who, or whose fathers have not, exercised equal industry and skill, is to violate arbitrarily the first principle of association, the guarantee to everyone the free exercise of his industry and the fruits acquired by it.

The Republican Primaries

I haven’t posted on the Republican race for a presidential candidate in a while.  I’ve been wrong every time before; what’s one more?

Gingrich’s ads and campaign are beginning to have the air of a desperate man.  They’re getting increasingly shrill and personal, and they do not contrast (favorably) his own ideas and policies either with those of his fellow Republican candidates or those of President Obama.  His presence does, though, have a positive effect on the primary campaign in general.

For one thing, the longer the Republicans go without a clear front runner, the longer the question of who the Republican nominee will be remains unanswered, and the longer the campaigns run, the debates, whether on a stage or via dueling ads and speeches, will force the candidates to clarify their positions, their policies, their ideas, and their solutions in their own minds and in the minds of Americans before this fall.  This can only work to the good of the eventual nominee as he faces a Progressive candidate whose record of governing failure is as clear as is his skill at obfuscation, changing the subject, and raising straw men for his own opponent to defend.

For another thing, Gingrich’s continued survival as a viable candidate is forcing all of the other candidates to sharpen their own debating and communications skills, which also can only work to the benefit of the eventual nominee when he faces that Progressive in the fall.  This improvement in skill and clarity of communication is palpable.

Congressman Ron Paul has gone from frequent mumbling incoherence, from reliance on the inside oral shorthand that he and his coterie have evolved over their 30 years in relative isolation in the House, to a much clearer enunciation of his principles and a much sharper expression of his ideas and solutions.  And once we can understand him, his domestic ideas and solutions are very much worth taking seriously.

Senator Rick Santorum has become a much less a one-dimensional, only anti-abortion candidate.  He’s been forced to talk more about his economic ideas—and he has good ones—and to talk more about solutions to entitlements, the role of self-confidence and self-reliance, and the place of education in facilitating these.  And the Federal government’s (lack of) place in that education.  And in Thursday’s debate, he had the clearest comment of the night, when on the subject of government-provided health care, he pointed out (for the first time by anybody, with this degree of clarity) that it didn’t matter whether it was the Federal government or a state government that forced an individual to buy health insurance as a condition of existence: it was still government run health care, it was still top-down control and not individual choice.

Governor Mitt Romney was, in the beginning, a pure technocrat, who could only speak in the details and weeds, without clarity, and with too much mildness—often perceived as timidity.  The debates—with Gingrich’s sharp participation—have forced him to develop a sharper approach, and he, too, has gotten much clearer as he explains his policies and solutions.  He needs to improve his explanation of the role and benefits of capitalism, particularly against the background of the Bain rap (unfounded, but still there), but he’s improved on this a great deal.  Likewise, he needs to improve his explanation of his position on health care, but he’s gotten better there, as well.  He’s finally said in so many words that he’ll work to repeal in toto Obamacare; although as Santorum pointed out Thursday, he still needs to work on his explanation for Romneycare.

Speaker Newt Gingrich, though, isn’t getting any better.  Certainly one reason is that he’s already very good, and his opponents have been unable until recently to challenge him as he’s been able to challenge them.  However, one of the raps on him is that, for all his debating skills, when he meets someone who can match him, he folds.  This was clearly demonstrated in last Thursday’s debate when he began to remonstrate with the moderator Wolf Blitzer.  When Blitzer pushed back, Gingrich backed down.  Later, Gingrich admitted he was flat generally in that debate: he doesn’t know how to debate effectively when the other debater is manufacturing “facts,” distorting issues, and so on.

You cannot debate somebody who is dishonest.  You just can’t….  I can’t debate somebody who won’t tell the truth….  I know what he’s saying is untrue. And I also know that, in that particular audience, it would not have worked to take him head on, so I backed out.

Given this admission, and given the audience stacking we can expect the Progressives to do, what should we expect from Gingrich in any debate with Obama, who will do exactly that on steroids?

Gingrich needs to pick two or three ideas and push those to the exclusion of all else; he needs to show how they’re better ideas than Obama’s and more so than are the ideas of his Republican competitors.  But he’s never been able to stay this focused.  He’s an outstanding idea man, but his inability to stay centered also works against his capacity to be President.

So….  These are desperate times, but that means we cannot afford a desperate man for our President.  Additionally, Paul’s foreign policy plans demonstrate his dangerous naiveté concerning the ways of the outside world.  I’m beginning to lean toward a Romney/Santorum ticket.  I don’t see Santorum on the top spot because I don’t think he has the temperament for President, but he does have the temperament to ride herd on the Senate, and he can certainly be an effective bad cop to the President’s good cop.