European Finance Crisis

I’ve written before about this subject.

The chart below is from Spiegel Online International, which has a related story, but I want to visit another aspect of this.  The chart’s breakout indicates German governmental exposure to Greek debt and that exposure’s cost to the German economy were Greece finally to default altogether on its debts.

 

The 50%, or so, haircut currently being sort of negotiated with Greece’s commercial financial institution creditors is a real default, albeit much lipstick has been applied to this PIIG’s lips, and much makeup is being added to its face.  The breakout elides those private banks and the cost to the German economy through the private sector generally; however, the governmental institution cost breakout has its uses.

The German economy is the EU’s and the euro zone’s largest, so the figures in the chart can be taken as an outer bound, within which the other European creditor nations’ costs can be assessed.  Alternatively, and perhaps more effectively, the German cost can be proportionally bounced against the other nations’ GDPs to get an idea of the costs to them, along with an idea of how expensive those costs really are.  Since I don’t have 2011 GDP figures, yet, my greasy spoon diner napkin analysis uses 2010 GDP estimates.

Germany’s 2010 GDP was in the neighborhood of €2.7 trillion.  The chart’s seemingly enormous €72 billion bite, presented without context, shrinks when compared to German economic strength: it’s about 2 2/3% of the German GDP.  The French GDP was €2.1 trillion; its proportional “share” then works out to a bit under €56 billion.  The Netherlands’ GDP was €641 billion; its “share” would be roughly €17 billion.  And so on.  It’s true enough that stronger economies will have an easier time than weaker economies, but in the end, these are sums that are easily absorbed.

To be sure, the private sector also will take hits from a Greek default.  Taking the private sector as a whole, not just the commercial bank interests mentioned above, but including insurance company, pension firm, and mutual fund holdings of Greek debt, the total private exposure works out to around €142 billion.  That’s about half the total Greek debt; it doesn’t add much at all to the GDP-based cost.  For individual economies, the ripple effects of private sector dislocations and occasional bank bankruptcies could seem sharp, but they would be short-lived.  The economies of the non-Mediterranean EU nations (yes, including France) are simply too large and too strong to suffer permanent, or long-lasting, damage.  And the private sector is the only place the hits should occur, anyway.  There’s no reason a French, German, Dutch, and so on, taxpayer—private citizen—should pay for the profligacy of a Greek government, or for that of any government other than their own.

Certainly, it would be suboptimal for Greek’s national creditors to walk away from the deals already made for a Greek bailout: even a bad contract must be honored.  But there should be—and there need be—no more public monies committed to this effort.

The Greeks will be better off, too, for having been released from their indenture to their creditors and allowed to default and to start over.

Contraception Regulation

Others have some thoughts on this, along with matters carefully ignoredmissed by President Obama.

Ruth Ann Daily of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette points out a principle that was well understood in our early days, but that our former University of Chicago Senior Lecturer in Constitutional Law seems to have…forgotten.

She describes an 1801 exchange of letters between Thomas Jefferson and a coalition of Baptist ministers from Connecticut, where the Congregationalist Church was supported by all citizens’ state taxes [emphasis added].

The “Danbury Baptists” and other minorities…could seek an exemption certificate that would route their taxes to their own church, but in practice, many municipalities made that difficult to do, and in principle, the Baptists argued, it was wrong:

“What religious privileges we enjoy (as a minor part of the State) we enjoy as favors granted, and not as inalienable rights,” they wrote to Jefferson, “and these favors we receive at the expense of such degrading acknowledgements, as are inconsistent with the rights of freemen.”

Jefferson’s response extolled the “wall of separation between church and state,” a metaphor borrowed from Rhode Island founder Roger Williams. The Baptists and the deist skeptic are still right, 210 years later: An exemption, by definition, establishes one worldview over another and relegates dissenters to second-class status. Therefore the government must abstain from any such sphere where its presence is not absolutely necessary — as in forcing employers or insurance companies to dispense free contraceptives.

Caroline May of The Daily Caller describes another aspect of this problem that Obama…missed: some insurance providers are “religious organizations whose beliefs preclude them from offering birth control.”

She quotes Richard Land, president of the Southern Baptist Convention’s Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission:

Let’s just take Southern Baptists, there are 16 million of us, almost all of us are covered by a self-funded insurance program called GuideStone.  So when he says “well you don’t have to pay for it, your insurance company will,” our insurance company is a Southern Baptist insurance company, it is self-funded through the denomination, so it is totally unconscionable for them to provide abortifacients.

As Land put it

My initial reaction is: How dumb does he think we are?  Does he think when he puts lip stick on a pig, that we don’t understand that it is still a pig?

Hmm….

Is College for Everyone?

Michelle Singletary of The Washington Post asks whether higher education is a right or a privilege.  She doesn’t, though, answer the prior question of the purpose of going to college, and who should benefit from that.  Nor does she address the related question of why college is so expensive in the first place.

She cites some student debt statistics as part of the foundation of her question:

Among borrowers, the average debt for recipients of bachelor’s degrees increased 36 percent, from $17,075 in 1996 to $23,287 in 2008. But that average borrowing figure masks the pain felt by many students and graduates. We know many are strapped with an oppressive amount of debt that requires them to stretch payments out for 20 to 30 years.

She misses the context, though.  That debt is the debt on a new car, with the duration of a home mortgage.  Moreover, that home mortgage is an order of magnitude larger.  She asserts the pain of the student debt, but she offers no substantiation of it.  Certainly, money spent on the student debt is money not available to spend on other things—that new car, or the mortgage, perhaps.  But then, for those who understand the finite nature of the supply of money in an individual’s pocketbook, such tradeoffs are commonplace, and well planned for.  There is that cost of college driving those loans, though….

In the general-public poll, 75 percent of respondents said college is just too expensive. Among respondents 18 to 34 who did not have a bachelor’s degree and aren’t enrolled in school, 48 percent said they couldn’t afford a college education.

Then she turns to her confused purpose of college, buried in her question of who should foot the bill.

So if it’s in the best interest of the country to educate people so they can qualify for better-paying jobs, who should foot the college bill?

Is that, in fact, the purpose of the education—to make money, and not more broadly to learn to be more effective in a competitive, modern world?  If it is to increase one’s personal income (no mean goal in itself), then Ms Singletary has answered her own question: the one who will obtain that better-paying job is the one who should pay for the education that leads to it.  Indeed, if the purpose is that other one, still it’s the one being educated that benefits (albeit society also gains—but then so does society gain from the higher paying job), and so it is that one who should pay.

But there is that high cost….

Then she sets up her conflation:

If going to college is a right and vital to our nation’s economic standing, then government will have to do more to make it affordable for all.

The premise of a right is entirely separate to the premise of being vital to national economic standing.  But where is this right supported in our founding documents?  Our several States have laws mandating presence in schools until a certain age, generally 16 years old.  Our Declaration of Independence acknowledges the inalienable rights of Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.  John Adams explained that Happiness:

All men are born free and independent, and have certain natural, essential, and unalienable rights, among which may be reckoned the right of enjoying and defending their lives and liberties; that of acquiring, possessing, and protecting property; in fine, that of seeking and obtaining their safety and happiness.

Nothing in any of that about a right to a “higher education” in particular.  Certainly, in a modern world, such an education can prove highly useful, but utility does not define, or create, “right.”

Ms Singletary constructs a straw man alternative to this “right:”

If it’s a privilege, only the nation’s wealthiest families will one day be able to send their children to college.

But this straw man compounds its irrelevance by proceeding from the false premise that college must be as expensive as it is today.

What drives expense, though is not the demand for seats in college classrooms so much as it is two other things.  One is the rampant federal subsidies for students to go to college—all those student loan guarantees, all those grants and grants-in-aid, and so on—and all those financial incentives from the federal government to the colleges themselves to boost enrollment.

The other thing that drives demand is itself two-fold.  One of these is all those rampant federal subsidies for the students.  The other is the stigma that lack of a college degree means the person who doesn’t have one is somehow lacking, somehow less than his high school classmate who graduated from college.  It’s the pressure applied to everyone that they must go to college, whether it’s useful or not to a particular individual.

This brings me to a third question that must be answered before we can begin a discussion of right vs privilege for getting that higher education: who, in fact, should go to college?

Consider, for just one example, the trades—everything from a highly-skilled machinist, to an auto mechanic, to a plumber or electrician to—on and on.  Are the people who work in the trades not as valuable in our work force as the folks who work in the financial industry, or for the defense contractor, or  in IT—not in terms of money, but in terms of the health of our economy?  If you question the actual value of their work, try to repair your own car, or wire your own house.

What’s the value of a college education to these folks?  Must they incur the cost of those student loans, or the cost of four years of tuition and books out of their own pockets, to learn their trades and then go to work?  Plainly not.

Misleading Campaign for the Contraceptive Mandate

Senators Jeanne Shaheen, Barbara Boxer, and Patty Murray (D; NH, CA, and WA, respectively) have an Op-Ed piece in The Wall Street Journal that contributes to the disinformation being spread about concerning this diktat.

They begin with their opening premise:

…the Obama administration changed the law to require private health plans to provide preventive services including breast exams, HIV screening and contraception for free.

They actually think no one is paying for this mandate?  They actually think no tax increases, no insurance premium increases, no reductions in services or policy option flexibility will result from this?  No, they don’t think that: these are grown, adult human beings, of far above average intelligence.  Of course they know better.

They go on:

…the real forces behind [an alleged campaign to deny this “benefit” to women]…are trying to force their politics on women’s personal health-care decisions.

Of course, this mandate in no way seeks to impose government’s politics to override the fundamental teachings of a broad reach of religions and religious institutions.  Nosirreebob.

And

Contraception was included as a required preventive service on the recommendation of the independent, nonprofit Institute of Medicine and other medical experts because it is essential to the health of women and families.

Aside from the fact that, as feminists used to protest—correctly—pregnancy isn’t a disease, pregnancy prevention (and cancelation) mechanisms are widely available already.  Not overriding religious teachings, not canceling religious tenets, in no way impacts this.

And

Those now attacking the new health-coverage requirement claim it is an assault on religious liberty, but the opposite is true.  Religious freedom means that Catholic women who want to follow their church’s doctrine can do so, avoiding the use of contraception in any form.

It also means that religious institutions—including “institutions that have historic religious ties but also have a broader mission, such as hospitals and universities”—do not have to cast aside their fundamental beliefs, do not have to submit to a government order to ignore those teachings.  Catholic—and other—women still can exercise their religious freedom.  And they still have access to contraception and abortions absent this government intrusion.

The good Senators’ disingenuous claim to the contrary, this mandate has nothing to do with women’s health, except in the most peripheral, side effect way.  It is exactly an assault on religious liberty, it is a deliberate reach for political power and an assertion of government’s authority over what will be permitted to be taught by religious institutions and what teachings will be permitted to be obeyed by related institutions.  This is an attempt to bring down Jefferson’s wall of separation between Church & State, and nothing else.

Congresswoman Gwen Moore (D, WI) makes this plain.  She has said that the church

…can’t impose its religious views on people and whether they can have health care.

However, it’s the government that’s imposing its religious view: religions must act contrary to their fundamental tenets because Government requires it.  Moreover, “the church” certainly can impose its religious views.  It’s what a church is.  It’s God’s Word—regardless of the religion at hand—that’s being taught.  The question of individual conscience, as the Catholic Church (for instance) teaches, is still a matter among the individual, the church, and God—government is, in no way, permitted to interfere here.

Yet government is doing everything it can to interfere.

Taxes, Again

Once again, a tax cut for Americans is being held hostage against a demand to offset that cut by a commensurate tax increase imposed on a government-disfavored group.  Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D, NV) has announced, at this late date,

We know there’s gonna have to be mandatory cuts, we understand that but also going to have to be something done with tax incentives, enhancements, revenues[.]

Unfortunately, this also is the wrong fight.  Both Democrats and Republicans are agreed that a two per centage point reduction in individuals’ taxes (or a three per centage point reduction both for individuals and businesses, if President Obama can be believed) is good for Americans.  Economists are agreed that temporary tax cuts, such as the proposed payrolls cuts, are not at all stimulative for the economy as a whole—a stimulus effect requires the cuts to be permanent.

The discussion, then, shouldn’t be a debate at all, nor should it concern payroll tax reductions, which serve only to further gut, and so to hasten the demise of, the Social Security system.

This discussion should be about a permanent income tax reduction for both individuals and businesses of two to three per centage points.  This much seems doable within the month since the idea of a tax cut and its present size already are agreed by all.  And who can understand the logic of “paying for” a tax cut with a tax increase (leaving aside the fact that there’s no need to pay for a reduction in the government’s receipt of something—our money—which doesn’t belong to it in the first place)?

This cut then should be followed by further discussion with a view to deeper income tax cuts.