Did Lois Lerner Waive Her 5th Amendment Right?

At the start of her testimony before the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, Lois Lerner, the head of the IRS facility that ran the targeting of government-disfavored Americans and groups of Americans, made a brief statement, asserted her 5th Amendment right not to testify against herself, and then refused to testify further.  Lerner said, in her statement,

On May 14th, the Treasury inspector general released a report finding that the Exempt Organizations field office in Cincinnati, Ohio used inappropriate criteria to identify for further review applications from organizations that planned to engage in political activity, which may mean that they did not qualify for tax exemption.

On that same day, the Department of Justice launched an investigation into the matters described in the inspector general’s report.  In addition, members of this committee have accused me of providing false information when I responded to questions about the IRS processing of applications for tax exemption.

I have not done anything wrong. I have not broken any laws. I have not violated any IRS rules or regulations, and I have not provided false information to this or any other congressional committee.

The bulk of the rest of her testimony was a statement that her counsel had advised her to plead the fifth, and she was doing so.

The Volokh Conspiracy (the above link) polled a number of professors with criminal procedure expertise on the question, including a bunch who were experts on the 5th Amendment in particular; their collected response was summarized thusly:

Opinions were somewhat mixed, but I think it’s fair to say that the bulk of responders thought that Lerner had not actually testified because she gave no statements about the facts of what happened.  If that view is right, Lerner successfully invoked her 5th Amendment rights and cannot be called again.  But this was not a unanimous view, it was not based on the full transcript, and there are no cases that seem to be directly on point.  So it’s at least a somewhat open question.

I’m not a lawyer, nor do I play one on the radio.  However, I disagree with these guys.  One of the things on which Lerner stands accused, as she acknowledged in her statement, is giving false testimony.  Her statement that she did not provide false information is an explicit statement about a fact of what happened under that accusation; it seems to me that she waived her 5th Amendment right in this area.

Furthermore, her broader statement of having “not done anything wrong…” in the context of her prior statements, which tie this claim explicitly and exclusively to the subject of that hearing, strikes me also as a statement about the facts of what happened under the implied accusations, and so again she seems to have waived her right—this time broadly so, concerning all of the subjects of the hearing.  This statement isn’t even akin to a plea of “not guilty;” it’s a statement of “I didn’t do the things related to this case about which you intend to question me.”  A “not guilty” plea is only a statement that the accuser cannot prove his case—which is all a not guilty verdict means: the state did not prove its case.

An Outcome of Big Government

The proper lessons of the unfolding IRS scandal are twofold.  First, any effort to have the IRS police advocacy activities of social-welfare organizations is bound to be clumsy and prone to degenerate into either selective or broad witch hunts.  Second, the remedy is not to further limit political speech by nonprofit entities—which would certainly raise significant constitutional issues—but to encourage such speech by imposing fewer restrictions.

That combines with this:

There are two valid takeaways from the IRS scandal [and the other scandals: AP; Benghazi; Sebelius’ HHS “fund-raising” for Federal government’s health exchanges, just exposed this year].  First, it confirms that big government, whose power Obama is bent on expanding, cannot be trusted to behave properly.  Second, it calls for further investigation to determine how high up the chain the wrongdoing extends and whether the administration acted promptly to stop the targeting once it learned of that activity.

The need for an investigation and the firing of miscreants and subsequent jailing of those miscreants whose behavior was criminal certainly is warranted.  However, the IRS’ unconscionable behavior, and the Obama administration’s behavior vis-à-vis the other…scandals…, aren’t unique to the Obama administration.  These are the inevitable outcomes of Big Government, even when that government acts with the best of intentions.

Our Federal government needs to be drastically shrunk in size and scope, returning it to the small, limited, and so controllable, entity that it was designed to be.

A first step in this, in the present context, would be to do away with the distinction between 501(c)(3) and 501(c)(4) organizations—the legal distinction is wholly artificial and without meaning, anyway.  All entities engaged in otherwise tax exempt activities must be able to engage in some political activity.  That’s at the core of the speech clauses of the 1st Amendment:

Congress shall make no law…abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

There’s nothing in there about “except for when individual Americans or groups of them peaceably assembled are doing certain government-identified things.”

Subsequently, reform the tax code altogether to a single low, flat tax and thereby eliminate the need for tax exempt status for any organization.

Yet Another Thought on Taxes

The Wall Street Journal has reported that

Apple, Inc paid no corporate income tax to any national government on tens of billions of dollars in overseas income over the past four years, Senate investigators found, a revelation that fuels the debate over whether the US tax code needs an overhaul.

The Senate thinks this is a bad thing, even as they acknowledge that Apple actually paid all the taxes it legally owed.  Senator John McCain (R, AZ), ranking Republican on the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations that hectored Apple’s CEO, Tim Cook, on that dastardly legal behavior earlier this week, gripes that

What they often leave out is the second part of the story, that Apple is one of the largest tax avoiders…Apple [is] the most egregious offender [among US corporations trying to avoid tax bills].

This despite the Subcommittee’s already completed investigations finding that Apple has, indeed, behaved entirely legally.  (Which makes me wonder, as an aside, whether McCain has outlived his usefulness and become just another RINO who needs to be terminated in his next primary.)  Regardless of any findings, though, in the finest Federal government tradition (can you say, “IRS,” boys and girls?), we’re going to hector and harass, anyway.  That was the point of haling Cook before the subcommittee to answer their inquisition.

This comes as part of a debate that the

US is undergoing…about the earnings that US companies are keeping overseas.  The profit at foreign subsidiaries are out of the reach of the IRS, and largely unusable to their US operations.

The sums amount to an estimated $1.9 trillion, according to an analysis by Audit Analytics….

However, instead of thinking about how to get their grubby mitts on all that money—which they then can dole out to select groups in return for votes and political power—these politicians should think about how much good that money would do in terms of jobs and innovation (and so more jobs) and lower product costs (and so more demand and so more jobs) were that money allowed to come home by an intelligent tax régime that would contain rates that encouraged rather than prevented repatriation of the money.

But thinking about that would require these politicians to “ask not what they can do for themselves, ask what they can do for their country.”

Is it Time?

Fox News is asking the question, “Is it time to overhaul the IRS?”

I say, no, but not for any of the reasons offered by Fox.  It’s time to overhaul our tax code to simplify it to a single flat tax at, say, 10% with no deductions, credits, subsidies, exceptions, differences depending on source of income, or what-have-you, and that everyone pays.

How much money did you make from all sources (wages, cash payments, interest, capital gains, dividends, gambling, etc)?  Pay 10% of that total.  Based on 2007 numbers (i.e., pre-Panic), that actually would increase revenue to Uncle Sugar by a substantial amount.  That’s only a static analysis.  Considering the ripple effects on our pocketbooks and so on our economy—which would take off—that would yield an even more substantial amount of revenue for the government.

Then we can restructure the IRS (as opposed to merely reform it) to vastly shrink it and limit it to the tax bookkeeping function that’s all it would need to be.  At those low tax rates and with no…deductions…there’s no need for an IRS division for special exemptions for this or that organization, no need for an IRS division to gather data and enforce the Obamacare suite of taxes (which would be included in the tax overhaul), no need for eight of the nine IRS divisions in Services and Enforcement.  The rest of the major sections—all overhead—could then be reduced or eliminated.

But first things first.

Obamacare Fail

…again.

Employers are increasingly recognizing they may be able to avoid certain penalties under the federal health law by offering very limited plans that can lack key benefits such as hospital coverage.

Benefits advisers and insurance brokers—bucking a commonly held expectation that the law would broadly enrich benefits—are pitching these low-benefit plans around the country.

This, of course, is backwards.  The coverages here should be paid out of pocket.  The better policy would cover only catastrophic events—like hospitalization.

Then there’s this:

[E]mployers and benefits experts have understood the rules to require robust insurance, covering a list of “essential” benefits such as mental-health services and a high percentage of workers’ overall costs….

But a close reading of the rules makes it clear that those mandates affect only plans sponsored by insurers that are sold to small businesses and individuals, federal officials confirm.

The money-saving bare bones policies are only available to large companies.  The jobs producers remain stuck with the expensive, overwrought mandated policies that they cannot afford.  Nor can they afford the penalties Obamacare exacts for not affording them.

And this from Kansas Insurance Department Special Counsel Linda Sheppard:

The whole idea is to get healthy people in and not-so-healthy people in.

Never mind that healthy people don’t need to be in, since they don’t need the coverage, and so they shouldn’t be being forced in.