Recess Appointments and Trust

President Obama has, in the past, criticized President Bush’s alleged tendency to push Constitutional limits in seeking to expand Executive Branch power.

Now we come to some “recess” appointments, made because Republicans allegedly were blocking Senate confirmation.  Michael McConnell, writing for Advancing a Free Society, offers some insight.

First, the present set of appointments (to the CFPB and to the NLRB) were made while the Senate was in session through a series of pro forma, short sessions, ostensibly for the purpose of blocking recess appointments.  The use of pro forma sessions for this purpose was a tactic devised in 2007 by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D, NV) and then-Senator Barack Obama (D, IL) specifically to prevent Bush from making recess appointments.

Second, ex-University of Chicago Constitutional Law Professor Barack Obama appears to have acted without legal advice other than his own: even his own Office of Legal Counsel, the body intended to advise presidents ahead of time on the legality of an action (and note that this is advice; OLC opinions are not law and are not binding), didn’t issue their opinion justifying Obama’s appointments until two days after the appointments had been made.  McConnell is more generous than I, suggesting that “presumably it reflects the advice given to the President in advance.”  I have my doubts.

Third, there are a number of legal arguments that suggest that Obama’s appointments are, in fact, unconstitutional, all centering on the fact that, as Reid and Senator Obama understood in 2007, the Senate actually has to be in recess before recess appointments can be made.  McConnell offers the following.

Obama and his pet OLC insist that since the Senate had announced an intention of conducting no business during its pro forma sessions, it was, in fact in recess.  Never mind that Obama signed into law at least two pieces of legislation that had been passed during those sessions, including the infamous payroll tax reduction extension.  This is old news.  McConnell offers new insight, though:

It is hard to see why the Senate’s stated intention not to do business takes legal and constitutional precedence over its manifest ability to do so.

McConnell goes on:

[T]he Opinion creates an implausible distinction between the legal efficacy of pro forma sessions for various constitutional purposes. According to the Opinion, a pro forma session is not sufficient to interrupt a recess for purposes of the Recess Appointments Clause, but it is sufficient to satisfy the constitutional command that neither branch adjourn for more than three days without the consent of the other  and that Congress convene on January 3 unless a law has provided for a different day…. Why a pro forma session would count for some purposes and not others is a mystery.

And there are other, longer-standing demonstrations of the illegitimacy of these appointments.  For one thing, the NLRB “nominees” hadn’t even been proposed to the Senate until two days prior to their previously announced, well publicized, ordinary holiday break, which the Senate then voluntarily gave up in order to remain in (pro forma) session.  The only one who was blocking Senate confirmation here was the President.

Also, we get the strange concept that the President can decide for himself when the Senate (or, by extension, the Congress) is in session, the Senate (or the Congress) not being competent to make that determination for itself.  Certainly, the President can adjourn both houses when they cannot agree between themselves on adjournment and ask him for help.  Certainly, the President can call the Congress into session to deal with emergencies.  Deciding that they actually have convened—or not—seems a bit of an expansion of Executive Branch power.

Where’s the love?  Where’s the trust?  Hmm….

The New Bipartisanship

Here it is, in black and white.  First we have Senate Majority Leader harry Reid (D, NV) advising his Republican opposition that they must “leave Tea Party ‘extremism’ behind and ‘learn what legislation is all about.’ ”  Reid goes on to insist that

Legislation is an art of working together, building consensus, compromise. And I hope that the Tea Party doesn’t have the influence in this next year that they had in the previous year[.]

and

I don’t think…anyone can question or they should question our having reached out to Republicans[.]

Of course, he’s silent on the House-passed budget that he’s refused to let see the Senate floor for debate for more than a year.  And he has nothing to say about any of the 20-something jobs-related House-passed bills that he’s similarly actively blocking.  Who’s refusing to talk?

Then we have this from President Obama:

…recess appointments last week of Richard Cordray at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and three new members of the National Labor Relations Board—even though the Senate was not in recess….

Obama’s own Assistant Attorney General Virginia Seitz knows these are unconstitutional:

The question is a novel one, and the substantial arguments on each side create some litigation risk for such appointments[.]

Obama made the appointments were made, anyway.

Finally, there’s this from one of the Progressives’ party organs:

‘Why Are Obama’s Critics So Dumb?’

together with this image from Newsweek‘s own proud tweet:

Clearly, the American people are extremists who don’t know they’re supposed to compromise and accept the Progressives’ every wish, and if one side can’t get its way, they’ll just ignore the law and go ahead, anyway.  Oh, and we’re all just dumb, so our views don’t matter, anyway.  Which sort of renders unimportant all us extremists: we don’t know what we’re doing.

Government Intervention Gone Awry

Peter Suderman, writing for Reason, suggests that Obamacare, far from being the cost saver the Progressives insist it to be, actually is a cost increaser.  It seems that Obamacare is inflating health benefit costs at a sharply more rapid pace than was the rate of increase before Obamacare’s ram-through.  According to a series of Kaiser Foundation annual surveys of employee health benefits, in 2008, the cost increase for employer-provided family health benefits was 5%.  In 2009, the cost increase was 5% again, and in 2010—the year Obamacare was passed before anyone was allowed to know what was in it—the cost increase was only 3%.  But in 2011, that cost increase was 9%.  And it’s going to get worse.

This is reminiscent of another government intervention into our health care system: the creation of Medicare.  Under the Johnson administration, Medicare (and Medicaid) were established as interventions in the market for medical services because government Knew Better then, too, how markets should work.  Far from reducing costs, though, these programs also made the situation worse.  In the year before Medicare was passed, the cost of a hospital bed was rising at 5% per year—three percentage points above the overall rate of inflation for that year.  By the fifth year following Medicare’s enactment, the cost of that same hospital bed was rising at 8% per year, a 60% increase in the rate of inflation for that bed, against a baseline, still, of just 4% overall inflation—the relative cost of a bed had doubled.  Further, the combined “advantage” of Medicare and Medicaid, through 2001, accounted for fully 25% of the inflation in the overall cost of medical care.  The tax exempt status of employer-provided medical coverage (another “boon” for the individual), accounted for another 33% of the inflation in total medical services cost: these two government interventions were responsible for nearly 60% of the inflation in the cost of medical care.

Medicare premiums themselves have risen rapidly since the inception of the program.  1965’s $3 per month premium had risen to $94.60 in 2011.  If the premiums had only risen with general inflation, they would be in the $14-$15 per month range today.  Additionally, the doctor and hospital reimbursement rates—those Medicare-approved amounts—are too low to allow the doctors and hospitals involved to recover their costs.  As a result, these health service providers are driven increasingly to refuse Medicare patients altogether.  Despite this, Medicare participation is mandatory: Americans must purchase Medicare, whether they want it or not, even in the face of this dwindling service, and this artificially elevated demand for a decreasing supply also contributes heavily to cost increases.

Mandatory participation in Medicare has not achieved the goal claimed for it: an overall reduction in the cost of health services.  It is, though, succeeding in reducing the availability of medical services generally.

And so it is with Obamacare.  New mandates—the Individual Mandate, requirements that insurance companies cover people’s health condition, regardless of risk and at government mandated price ranges—increase demand.  Although there are those price controls, the regulations will drive insurers increasingly out of an increasingly unprofitable market, and this will drive costs upward in the form of inaccessibility of health services and long waits.  Further, Obamacare’s tax hikes will be passed on to consumers.  There are those price controls, but as we saw with the Nixon price controls, ways will be found around them.

Rest assured, also, the quality of care will fall through the floor, too.  There’s another Obamacare regulation: medical loss ratios, whose values are mandated under Obamacare, require insurers to spend a high percentage of their premium revenue on federally defined clinical services (Government-mandated, not market-driven, and so not necessarily wanted by us), and this is at the direct expense of R&D.  And of course health insurers are interested in research—not only in how to better provide insurance products to customers (there are profits to be made in offering better products and doing so more efficiently, and without those profits, the search for more and better won’t occur), but also in medicine itself.  Medical research is part of that search for profit: more, and more efficiently provided, medical services also are profitable, as is a long-lived, healthy customer base.  Only now there’ll be less money available for that research.

Once again, we’re stuck with an artificially elevated demand for dwindling supplies, and this time supplies of decreasing quality as well as quantity.

Made in Germany

The EU is at it again, still trying to manage economies, and this time they’re taking on the German powerhouse whose piggy bank they want to raid directly to bail out the rest of Continental Europe.

Spiegel International Online reports

Whether it’s attached to a car, a dish washer or a pepper grinder, the “Made in Germany” label is key to selling products made in the country. But if the European Union has its way, goods carrying the tag will soon have to comply with higher standards….

EU Commissioner Algirdas Semeta plans to restrict the sought-after “Made in Germany” label to products where at least 45 percent of the value content comes from Germany. Until now, EU rules defined the country of origin as the place where “the last substantial, economically justified processing” took place.

Spiegel reports further that a part of the beef is that, under the current regulatory régime,  products could be produced almost entirely outside of Germany (for instance), and only the finishing touches applied in the domestic factory.  This is an exaggeration, or it would be in a truly open, information-flowing free market—something that’s been anathema to the Europeans for decades, and which lack underlies the current European economic malaise.

In the modern globally integrated economy, “Made in Germany/France/United States/etc” has been a bit of a misnomer for a long time: “Assembled in…” would be more accurate.  German—and American—automobiles, for instance, are built up from parts made in a number of foreign locations where labor is cheaper and necessary supplies, especially commodity supplies (iron, plastics, and so on), are nearer by and so cheaper to obtain.  Then the parts are shipped for final assembly in Germany or the US.  To do the whole thing overseas, only applying the last coat of paint in the domestic factory, and claiming that to be domestically made would, at best, irritate an informed market’s public, and it would eliminate the value of any “Made in” claim.  Businessmen aren’t smarter than their customers, nor need they be better informed.

Moreover, in the near term, and in perpetuity, bureaucratic imperatives involved in the record keeping needed at all “production stages to establish where most of the value of the product was created,” assuming “most of the value” could be defined adequately, will only increase production costs—and so costs to the consumer who’s being “protected” by this foolishness.

EU leadership is both exposing its jealousy of German success and demonstrating once again how the euro zone is too fractionated to support a common currency and how the EU itself is too fractionated to support the tighter integration that many want and that the Brits have correctly eschewed.  And the European political class is demonstrating once again its contempt for the intelligence and wisdom of the common man whom it purports to represent.

On Shrinking Government

This should be, in principle, an Obama move that we can support.  Of course, the devil will be in the details, and this “shrinkage” is pretty trivial—only a reduction of 2,000, or so, civil servants out of a total Federal work force of nearly 4.5 million, and a cost reduction of walking around money—$3 billion over 10 years.  But it’s a start, and if we wait until the last step has been mapped out to a gnat’s patootie, the journey will never start.

What the President wants to do in the present case is consolidate some unnamed Commerce “core business functions” with the Small Business Administration, the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative, the Export-Import Bank, the Overseas Private Investment Corporation and the Trade and Development Agency.

His idea has been under consideration for some time, but one objection to it is one that this poor, dumb Texas boy doesn’t understand.  Those earlier thoughts had also included moving the NOAA from Commerce to Interior, but there was “resistance internally to moving it to the Interior Department.”  The boss said to move, so off they go.  Where’s the problem?

Maybe, while we’re at it, we could also eliminate the EPA and the President’s Office of Legal Counsel.  Oh, wait….

The mechanics proposed are interesting, too, and are the real reason for my initial support (subject to satisfaction with the details, as always).  With this initial consolidation permission, the bill if passed, would let the President propose other reorganizations of his Executive Branch and require the Congress to give it an un-amended, up or down vote within 90 days.  Thus, the President gets more flexibility over the structure of his Branch, and the Congress retains its present power over the structure of the Federal government, including the Executive Branch.

However, the ability for either party to stall and to posture for political gain would become much more difficult.  And the members of Congress would have to be on the public record, in front of their constituents, for their individual decisions on the reorgs.  Moreover, amendments remain eminently possible: the pre-proposal dickerings that should be occurring anyway would get objections worked out, and the necessary modifications to satisfy the reasons for a down vote would constitute such amendments as well.

This wants a close look, devoid of political imperatives on both sides.