Attacking the Institution of the United States Senate

Senator Jeff Sessions (R, AL) had some thoughts on the matter last Thursday in a Senate floor speech.

Our late colleague Senator Robert Byrd liked to say that there have been two great Senates in history: the Roman Senate and the US Senate.  He understood the special and crucial role the Senate fulfills in our Constitutional Republic.

And

Yet, in the last few years, we have witnessed the dramatic erosion of Senators’ rights and the dismantling of the open legislative process.

We fund the government through massive omnibus bills that no one has had the time to read or analyze.  Senators are stripped of their right to offer amendments.  Bills are rushed through under threat of panic, crisis, or shutdown.  Secret deals rule the day, and millions of Americans are essentially robbed of their ability to participate in the legislative process.

And

One of the tactics by which Majority Leader [D, NV, Harry] Reid has suppressed Senators’ rights and blocked open debate has been a technique called “filling the tree.”  What this means, basically, is that when a bill comes to the floor, the Leader will use his right of first recognition to fill all of the available amendment slots on a bill and block any other Senator from offering amendments.  One man stands in the way of his 99 colleagues.  But, not alone really.  His power exists only as long as his majority concurs and supports his actions. This…prevents Senators from being held accountable by their votes on the great issues of the day.
…
In so doing, the Leader denies the citizens of each state their equal representation in the Senate.  Majority Leader Reid, in his effort to protect his conference from casting difficult votes—in order to shield his Majority from accountability—has essentially closed the amendment process.  He has shut down one of the most important functions that Senators exercise to represent the interests of their constituents.

And

Recently, this tactic manifested itself in a dramatic way.  To the surprise and shock of many, the December spending agreement contained a provision that cut the lifetime pension payments of current and future military retirees—including wounded warriors—by as much as $120,000.  I and other Senators had many ideas for how to fix this problem, but we were blocked from offering them by the Majority Leader.
…

So I would ask my colleagues: … Do you believe the Senate should operate according to the power of just one man?

There are other avenues of attack, also.

The erosion of the Senate has also been front and center in the budgeting process.  We are now in our fifth year without adopting a congressional budget resolution.  Instead, taxpayer dollars are spent through a series of backroom deals and last-minute negotiations.  Then we face a massive omnibus that is rushed to passage without amendment or meaningful review.  The American people have no real ability to know what’s in it or hold us, their elected representatives, accountable.

And

[U]nder the tenure of Majority Leader Reid, the budgeting process has been totally mismanaged.  We have ceased consideration of appropriations bills altogether, relying more and more on autopilot resolutions and catch-all behemoth spending packages.  In fiscal year 2006, for example, every single appropriations bill was debated, amended, and passed in the Senate.  In 2013, none were.

And

A more ominous development, however, is how the breakdown of the appropriations process in the Senate is now infecting the House of Representatives, and spreading like the plague.  In the first year of their majority, the Republican-led House marked up six appropriation bills and sent them to the Senate.  The Senate didn’t consider a single one.  Last year, the House passed eight appropriation bills and sent them to the Senate.  Again the Senate didn’t act.  This year, the futility of the House efforts began to show as the House passed only four bills.  But why should they?  Why should the House expose their members to politically tough votes when they know the Senate won’t?

Finally [emphasis added],

All of us owe our constituents an open, deliberative process where the great issues of the day are debated in full and open public view.  Each Senator must stand and be counted—not hide under the table.

Remember all of this, as you consider for whom to vote for your Senator in the upcoming primaries and mid-term elections.

Bigotry at the UN

What a surprise.

A UN exhibit created as a joint venture between the United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization—UNESCO—and the Simon Wiesenthal Center, the People, Book, Land – The 3,500 Year Relationship of the Jewish People and the Land of Israel, and scheduled to open Monday, has been canceled, and cynically so: it was done at the last minute, leaving little time for the Center to respond.

Why?  The Arab League claimed the exhibit “could create potential obstacles related to the peace process in the Middle East.”   Never mind that the obstacle to peace there has been Palestinian terrorist refusal to take peace negotiations seriously (and President Barack Obama’s insistence on acquiescing to Palestinian demands while not supporting our ally in the slightest, but that’s another story).  Never mind that the PLO (under the rubric “Palestine”) is a member in good standing of UNESCO and in that capacity had review and input into this exhibit as it was being developed and scheduled.

Never mind the extortionate threat the Arab League’s…objection…represents.  Chairperson of Group V(b) (Arab States), Abdulla al Neaimi of the UAE, proclaimed in a letter to the UNESCO MFWIC, Irina Bokova,

The subject of this exhibition is highly political though the appearance of the title seems to be trivial.  Most serious is the defense of this theme which is one of the reasons used by the opponents of peace within Israel.  The publicity that will accompany…the exhibit can only cause damage to the peace negotiations presently occurring, and the constant effort of Secretary of State John Kerry, and the neutrality and objectivity of UNESCO.

For all these reasons, for the major worry not to damage UNESCO in its…mission of support for peace, the Arab group within UNESCO is asking you to make the decision to cancel this exhibition.

This is nothing more—or less—than anti-Israeli, anti-Jewish bigotry by the Arab League and the timid acquiescence to it by UNESCO (and by the Obama administration, which meekly accepted Neami’s charges and Bokova’s agreement with them).

It’s time we cut off funding to the UN until the UN goes back to its founding principles.  We have other uses for our money in an era of enormous deficits and runaway national debt.

Obamacare Runaround, State Level

A Maryland woman is getting the Obamacare runaround treatment in Maryland’s state “exchange” (exchange of what, exactly?).  The woman, after months of trying, finally got signed up—she thought—through one of Obamacare’s Navigators and was given a confirmation number and a printout of her selected plan.

Her Democrat Representative, Barbara Mikulski, has declined to help (help with what?  The woman is signed up, isn’t she?  See below); Mikulski would only commit to empty words of…commiseration:

I am just as frustrated as you are about the launch of health reform.  I am particularly disappointed that the exchange websites did not operate smoothly for Marylanders.

Yeah, that’s helpful.  And Mikulski plainly still thinks the problem is just with the software of a Web site, and not in the law itself.  Hmm….

Again, signed up for what?

the selected insurance company has no record of her

the state navigation system has no record of her

Never mind the printout and confirmation number.  Especially never mind the confirmation number.

both the Maryland Health Connection and the troubleshooting site assured the woman “that somebody would get back to me within two to three days;” nobody has.

The governor’s office—not the Governor or his head of the Maryland Office of Health Care Reform apparently, just a staffer—called the woman and assured her that they would send a manual application “next week.”

However.  The Catch-22 gotcha:

she would have to pay two months of premiums this week

the provider doesn’t have any record of her (see above)

and so the provider is  unable to tell her the premium

It just doesn’t get any better than this with government-directed (I hesitate to say “-managed”) health coverage and health care programming.

The VA Strikes Again

Used to be, veterans could apply for disability via letter, even a hand written note.  Further, when that note arrived, coverage began for the applicant, should his application be accepted, including backdated payments to cover the period between receipt of the application and its acceptance.  Not anymore.

The Department of Veterans Affairs says the many ways that requests for disability compensation arrive actually hamper its ability to administer benefits, and they contribute to a claims backlog that has about 400,000 veterans waiting more than 125 days for a decision.  At times, workers spend so much time trying to figuring out what’s being claimed and trading letters with applicants that it’s slowing down decisions for everyone.

Never mind that the Godfather of the VA, General Omar Bradley, its first MFWIC, told VA staff that they were there to serve the veterans, not themselves.

According to the VA’s bright idea,

the first communication from a veteran may not trigger anything.  Those veterans who put their claims in writing would have to completely fill out a standard form [generally on line], and the clock that determines how far back the government will pay, won’t begin ticking until the VA receives the successfully completed form.

And that form better be filled out correctly.  If it’s not, there’ll be delays, including the possibility the form will be returned “for resubmittal in 90 days for further disapproval.”  Oh, and never mind that critics of this move point out that

veterans who are the most vulnerable—the homeless, those with traumatic brain injury, and those with a limited education—would have the most trouble meeting the new standard.

The VA emphasizes its online form, which is more convenient for the VA bureaucrats.  After all,

The VA said that veterans who don’t have a computer can go to the closest VA facility to get help.

Never mind that lots of veterans, especially those in rural areas and the elderly, either don’t have access to the Internet, or they don’t have a computer at all.

The Administrative State and the United States

The accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary, in the same hands, whether of one, a few, or many, and whether hereditary, self-appointed, or elective, may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny.  Were the federal Constitution, therefore, really chargeable with the accumulation of power, or with a mixture of powers, having a dangerous tendency to such an accumulation, no further arguments would be necessary to inspire a universal reprobation of the system.

James Madison wrote those words in Federalist No 47.  And yet we have exactly this threat clear and present in the Regulatory State that’s been a-building since FDR’s time in power.  Chief Justice William Howard Taft, in his eulogy to Chief Justice Edward White, said without a trace of irony,

[T]he inevitable progress in exigencies of government and the utter inability of Congress to give the time and attention indispensable to the exercise of powers in detail forced the modification of the rule [held from our birth for the succeeding 140 years that no legislative powers can be delegated].  Similar necessity caused Congress to create other bodies with analogous relations to the existing legislative, executive, and judicial machinery of the Federal Government, and these in due course came under the examination of this court.  Here was a new field of administrative law which needed a knowledge of government and an experienced understanding of our institutions safely to define and declare.

We have, indeed, that whole branch of our judiciary—Administrative Law Judges—created specifically to specialize in interpreting and applying (their interpretation of) the regulations created by our Executive Branch’s Cabinets and Independent Agencies.  The foundation of the belief that they are necessary is illustrated by the explosion of the Federal Register, the government’s primary listing of these regulations, from 2,600 pages in 1936, as FDR was just getting started with his New Deal, to over 80,000 pages by 2010, and with an additional 6,300 regulations (not pages of regulations) finalized by the end of 2012.

The current, wholly out of control state of lawmaking masquerading as rulemaking is illustrated by the byzantine (and at times wholly hidden) rules and rules-in-the-making that enact the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and by the Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, of which the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is described by Todd Zywicki this way:

A centerpiece of the Dodd-Frank financial reform legislation was the creation of a new Federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“CFPB”) within the Federal Reserve.  Few bureaucratic agencies in American history, if any, have combined the vast power and lack of public accountability of the CFPB.  It is an independent agency inside another independent agency, presided over by a single director who is insulated from presidential removal.  Additionally, the Board is outside of the congressional appropriations process.  Finally, its actions are unreviewable by the Federal Reserve….

Proponents of the CFPB argue that extreme independence is justified to insulate it from political pressures.

The plethora of laws that a Progressive government thinks is necessary to guide and direct men’s lives and businesses drives the imperative to generate regulations in order to give flesh and “clarity” to those laws.  But these regulations, these rules, are enacted [sic] by men in sections of government whose placement wholly isolates them from effective oversight by government’s employers—us.  This unaccountability and lack of control over functional lawmaking in which these men engage is an even greater threat to the very freedoms which we hire this government to protect and to facilitate than are that plethora of laws itself.

Keep in mind that lawmaking is properly and wholly a political matter; it must be subject to what those CFPB proponents fear: “political pressures.”  Making law is the task of We the People through our elected representatives in the Congress.  Regulations and rules are a subset of law, and so these must be dealt with by us and our representatives, not by the Executive Branch, whose sole function in this context is to enforce the law, not make new ones or modify or “clarify” existing ones.

Neither can the judiciary have any role in lawmaking; its sole function in this context has exactly two parts: first to decide whether the law before a judge is legitimate, that is, Constitutional (and if not to strike it down), and second if it is legitimate, to apply it as it is written, and not as that judge thinks it ought to have been written or as that judge creatively “interprets” it in order to “update” it for his (understanding of the) times.

Even could the argument be made that regulations are a separate class of lawmaking, wholly different from the statutory lawmaking that We make through our representatives, We have identified lawmaking, in the Constitution which We ratified, as the sole province of us and our Congress.

To solve this, aside from withdrawing the vast majority of regulations currently on the books (an entirely necessary endeavor) we must, which Taft failed to understand, rescind that excess of laws, and we must sharply curtail, if not withdraw entirely, Congress’ delegation of rule-making authority to the Executive Branch.

Full Stop.