Democracy My Way—Not Yours

The lede lays it out.

Voters in two Democratic strongholds approved restrictions on transgender participation in girls’ sports last week, delivering rare Republican victories amid a blue wave. But Democratic officials are already discussing ways to change the measures, drawing accusations of hypocrisy from Republicans who point to their support for the “No Kings” movement.

The citizens of Washington voted down, by a clear majority, an initiative to ban biological males from girls’ sports. In addition, the citizens of Colorado voted, also by a clear majority, an initiative to restrict gender-related surgeries that would otherwise be inflicted on children.

Colorado’s Progressive-Democrat Governor-elect Philip Weiser and Progressive-Democrat Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal of Washington have come out not just decrying those outcomes, but objecting to them and promising steps to cancel those citizens’ decisions. Weiser (as cited by Fox News):

suggested Colorado’s Democratic-controlled legislature could revisit the voter-approved measures, saying that it is “statutory…and a natural and I believe appropriate role for the legislature [to adjust.]

Jayapal has pledged to “take our state back” after voters approved the initiative.

“Our State.” Washington belongs to her Progressive-Democratic Party, not to the citizens of Washington.

Washington’s Progressive-Democratic Party Chair Shasti Conrad was even more direct. She

call[ed] the ballot measure “unconstitutional on its face” and indicating the party would “support [for] organizations planning to challenge it in court.”

The voice of the people is unconstitutional. Imagine that.

This is Progressive-Democrats shouting “King’s X” over American citizens’ democratically stated—that is to say, stated clearly at the ballot box—decisions and saying loudly that petty decisions of mere citizens do not count and are without effect.

Referenda Weren’t Part of the Blue Tsunami

In all of the voting that produced the collapse of the Republican Party in the last week, there were some bright spots where the people spoke directly for themselves rather than indirectly by electing politicians to speak for them. The people passed a number of conservative-oriented referenda.

  • Iowa…voters approved a constitutional amendment to require a two-thirds legislative majority for raising income taxes on residents or businesses.
  • Ohio…voted to shore up the state’s voter ID requirement by putting it in the constitution.
  • North Carolina…approved a constitutional amendment to cut the maximum income-tax rate to 3.5%, from 7%.
  • North Carolina also approved an amendment on voter ID.
  • Washington state approved a measure.
  • Colorado is on a path to Colorado’s barring biological males from competing in girls’ sports and a separate measure banning gender surgeries on minors also is ahead.
  • Arizona is on a similar path to protecting female athletes.
  • Kentucky voters amended their constitution to prevent lame-duck pardons.

However, even that silver lining is deeply buried in dark clouds; there’s still this:

  • Colorado voters repealed the state’s groundbreaking Taxpayer Bill of Rights and may saddle themselves with a progressive income tax.
  • Washington looks to have rubber-stamped a millionaire’s tax.
  • Arizona and California said no to voter ID.
  • Montanans and Michiganders voted for new restrictions on free speech under the guise of “campaign-finance reform.”

Go Vote

I said this a bit ago, and it bears repeating. It’s important that all of you—each of us—go vote regardless of which candidates or party you favor.

It’s not only our individual civic duty. Keep in mind that not voting at all leaves a vote for the other side unanswered.

Go vote.

Vote

Voting season is upon us. It’s important that all of you—each of us—go vote regardless of which candidates or party you favor.

It’s not only our individual civic duty. Keep in mind that not voting at all leaves a vote for the other side unanswered.

AI and Polling

A letter-writer in Tuesday’s WSJ Letters section thinks he sees a use for AI in improving the quality of political polls, which for the last several years have been badly off the mark both in prediction election winners and in predicting the margins of victory when they did get the winner right.

He’s sort of right, and he’s wrong.

It [AI] can help researchers reach a more representative mix of people, examine results faster and track changes in opinion more often.

AI can certainly speed up “examinations” of results if it’s properly trained on truly balanced techniques. That, though, requires humans being diligent about scrubbing as much as possible their own biases, with those humans involved in the training coming from a variety of political bents so as to counterbalance remaining biases. This is a requirement too often honored in the lack.

Additionally, researchers already know how to reach a more representative sample. However, they’ve been, instead, deliberately oversampling one party over others in order to reach a predetermined outcome. AI will not address that; it cannot correct it if it could address it.

Finally, there’s not much need to track opinion changes more frequently than is already done; most of us already have polling fatigue and are not interested in being confronted by even more polls, even if we just decline to participate.

In the end, all AI is likely to do, at least until we get better trained human oversight, is speed up the rate at which the polls get the politics wrong.