A Problem with Censorship

[Ukraine’s] Parliament voted Thursday to ban Soviet as well as Nazi symbols here….

Lawmakers voted 254-0 in favor of the bill, which outlawed any “public rejection of the criminal nature” of the Soviet or Nazi regimes in Ukraine, a former Soviet republic that was overrun by the Germans in World War II.

Their heart is in the right place.

Yuriy Lutsenko, a senior Member of Parliament with the Petro Poroshenko Bloc, added this about the legislation:

Symbols including five-pointed stars and hammers and sickles will disappear from the streets of Ukrainian cities[.]

But the USSR’s flag isn’t the only thing that uses the symbology of a five-pointed star. So do the United States flag and the European Union flag—the latter which Ukraine would like to join.

This illustrates a problem with government censorship. Leaving aside the fundamental inappropriateness of censorship by governments, it’s tough for government to censor narrowly enough to block the target without also blocking the friends.

Roll Call Votes

Senator Bob Corker (R, TN) has a bill in his Foreign Relations Committee that would require President Barack Obama to submit the deal he’s “negotiating” with Iran concerning the latter’s nuclear weapons program to Congress for approval or disapproval. His bill is was cosponsored by a large number of Democrats, so large that a week ago, he had 64 Senate votes for its passage.

Those Democrats are disappearing faster than fog in the West Texas sun as Obama begins turning up the heat on them. In their finest Saul Alinsky fashion, though, they’re covering their fade with a move to amend and gut the bill. As Kimberly Strassel put it in her op-ed at the link,

The goal of these amendments is to render the Corker legislation useless. Yet if Republicans balk, watch for Senate Democrats to howl that the GOP is acting in a partisan fashion, or refusing to be flexible. And watch for those same Senate Democrats to then use those complaints as their pretext for voting against the legislation.

And

[I]t appears that Mr Corker’s only path to 67—if that is even possible—is to so water-down his own bill as to make it useless. Does he want a meaningless 67-vote victory? The better route is to shoot for 60, send a principled bill to the president’s desk, and force the commander in chief and his defenders to solely face the consequences of a bad Iran deal.

Indeed. And Corker should demand a roll call vote in his committee, and Republicans should demand a roll call votes on the Senate floor, both on passage and on the veto override vote.

And that information should be bruited about in the 2016 campaign season—including in the Democrat primaries.

Media Self-Importance

Much is being made of Rand Paul’s (R, KY) friction with NLMSM interviewers, his disagreements with NBC‘s Savannah Guthrie being the latest.

Even Fox News‘ Howard Kurtz is in on the act:

What Paul bought himself by indulging the desire to lecture the “Today” show co-host [Guthrie] was days of media attention focused almost entirely on his temperament, and not on the issues he wants to talk about.

Kurtz went on at some length about Paul’s disagreements with Guthrie and with other NLMSM interviewers.

Therein lies the problem. These folks would rather talk about the supposed abuse of their own by impertinent candidates than talk about what those candidates are saying in the interviews. Of course, Kurtz cast this media behavior as a test of candidates’ ability to handle the stress of high office, but that’s just an Obama-esque effort to obfuscate the matter.

The “media attention focused almost entirely on [Paul’s] temperament” is entirely the media’s choice, a conscious decision to ignore the issues a candidate talks about and instead to obsess over their own.

And some accuse President Barack Obama of narcissism. Jeez.

A Stay on Illegal Immigration

Federal Judge Andrew Hanen has refused to stay his temporary injunction blocking President Barack Obama’s refusal to deport some 4 million illegal immigrants in Federal custody or whose whereabouts otherwise is known to the Feds. Hanen’s injunction will remain in force while Obama’s men appeal the stay to the 5th Circuit.

Refusing to stay his injunction has the effect, among others, of blocking Obama from pursuing (pending that appeal’s outcome) his Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents program and his planned expansion of the 2012 program called Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals.

OF course, enforcing that block is problematic. Aside from the obvious reasons for suspicion, there’s this about that 2012 program from Hanen’s order and ruling:

The Court finds that the Government’s multiple statements on this subject were indeed misleading, as detailed in the Order filed simultaneously with this Order. It also finds that the remedial measure taken by counsel for the Government through the filing of an “advisory” on March 3, 2015, was neither prompt nor fully candid.

Since this administration, once again, has shown it cannot be trusted, there’s no reason to suppose Obama won’t move ahead apace with both programs.

Hanen wasn’t done, though. In a separate order, on the matter of that 2012 program and the President’s men lying about it, Hanen

also issued a separate ruling Tuesday night allowing the states to conduct discovery into their separate claim that the administration, beginning late last year, improperly implemented part of its immigration program, even though it had allegedly represented to Judge Hanen that it wouldn’t do so until February.

Deal, or No Deal?

It seems there are two published versions of the nuclear arms agreement framework just “negotiated” with Iran: the Obama administration’s and Iran’s. Here’s a summary, via Fox News at the link, of the highlights of the two versions:

Regarding sanctions:

US: The US fact sheet says: “US and EU [and UN] nuclear-related sanctions will be suspended after the IAEA has verified that Iran has taken all of its key nuclear-related steps. If at any time Iran fails to fulfill its commitments, these sanctions will snap back into place.”

Iran: The (translated) Iran fact sheet says: “According to the reached solutions, after the implementation of the Comprehensive Plan of Joint Action, all of the UN resolutions will be revoked and all of the multilateral economic and financial sanctions by the EU and the unilateral ones by the US will be annulled.”

The weasel-wording cynic in me, though, can see a serious misunderstanding rather than an entirely differing version in this disconnect. “After implementation” could be seen as “upon agreement and placement into force,” and it could be seen as “fully complied.”

Regarding centrifuges:

US: The US fact sheet says: “Iran will not use its IR-2, IR-4, IR-5, IR-6, or IR-8 models to produce enriched uranium for at least ten years. Iran will engage in limited research and development with its advanced centrifuges, according to a schedule and parameters which have been agreed to by the P5+1.”

Iran: The Iran (translated) Iran fact sheet says: “Iran will continue its research and development on advanced machines and will continue the initiation and completion phases of the research and development process of IR-4, IR-5, IR-6, and IR-8 centrifuges during the 10 year period of the Comprehensive Plan for Joint Action.”

Of course this means Iran will use those carefully specified centrifuge models—as well as others—to enrich. At the least, “limited R&D” and all phases of “R&D” involving those models—and others—require testing in the enriching process for which they’re built. This is no mere misunderstanding; these statements represent two entirely different agreements.

Regarding their uranium stockpile: 

US: The US fact sheet says: “Iran has agreed to not enrich uranium over 3.67% for at least 15 years,” and Iran will “reduce its current stockpile of about 10,000 kg of low-enriched uranium (LEU) to 300 kg of 3.67% LEU for 15 years.”

Iran: Iran’s (translated) Iran fact sheet says: “The timeframe of the Comprehensive Plan of Joint Action regarding Iran’s enrichment program will be 10 years.” It then refers to the enrichment at Natanz occurring during this period.

Ten years? Some nebulous 10-15 years? This is no misunderstanding, either.

Regardless of the time frame, the only way to verify this is with inspections. The inspections, though, are entirely on prior notice and only to specified locations (yes, including those that might be newly discovered (or become suspicious). Iran is allowed to litigate in an international court those locations, too. On top of that, neither statement contains any remarks about how violations will be corrected.

Just what exactly was it that our guys were “negotiating” with Iran’s guys? Were they even in the same building in Lausanne?