Much Ado about Nothing

Many traders reported difficulty buying and selling exchange-traded funds, a popular investment in which baskets of stocks and other assets are packaged to facilitate easy trading. Dozens of ETFs traded at sharp discounts to their net asset value—or their components’ worth—leading to outsize losses for investors who entered sell orders at the depth of the panic.

Products built to provide insurance for investors came up short. As a result of trading halts in futures tied to the S&P 500 index, it was difficult for investors to get consistent prices on contracts linked to them that offer insurance against S&P 500 declines.

That’s how Bradley Hope, Saumya Vaishampayan, and Corrie Driebusch opened their Wall Street Journal piece about Monday’s stock market performance, a piece interestingly titled Stock-Market Tumult Exposes Flaws in Modern Markets.

They also had this:

The giant swings in the market and problems with ETFs pointed to a need to rethink rules governing stock trading, analysts said.

“There needs to be a deeper examination of how the stock-market circuit breakers behaved on Monday,” said Joel Dickson, a senior investment strategist at Vanguard Group of Valley Forge, PA. “There was a major market-structure component to what happened.”

Illustrative of the bleating is this, too:

“Pricing options is almost impossible on the kind of move you had that day,” said Wayne Wu, who trades SPDR S&P 500 ETF options on the NYSE floor for Integral Derivatives.

Yeah, and? If an investor can’t get/doesn’t like the data related to an investment plan, it’s on him to take the risk, or not. It’s not on government to protect him from the outcomes of his decisions.

More government rules, or more layers on existing ones? No. Fewer government rules, and simpler. Tumult is the necessary noise of a free market. The PRC’s failure is illustrative of the outcomes of government “management” of markets and of underlying economies. We’re not where the PRC is, yet, and we don’t need to approach that, either.

But, but–what about guys who already had staked out positions when this happened, when the information breakdown occurred?  Second Rule of Investing (the First Rule is “Never invest anything you can’t afford to lose all of”): “Know where the back door is before you go in through the front door.”

Personal responsibility. Government needs to butt out. Caveat emptor.

EPA’s Orwellian Transparency

Congressman Lamar Smith (R, TX), Chairman of the House Science, Space, and Technology Committee, is unhappy with the EPA’s decision to be unresponsive to Committee requests for information regarding the EPA-caused disaster in and downriver from a Colorado mine.

It is disappointing, but not surprising, that the EPA failed to meet the House Science Committee’s reasonable deadline in turning over documents pertaining to the Gold King Mine spill. These documents are essential to the Committee’s ongoing investigation and our upcoming hearing on Sept 9. But more importantly, this information matters to the many Americans directly affected in western states, who are still waiting for answers from the EPA.

But that’s just transparency in the manner of this administration.

Border Walls

There are lots of reasons for objecting to a wall running the length of our southern border (and I’ll elide the reasons for supporting one for the purposes of this post), but the reasons posited by the National Journal aren’t on that list.

[T]he more difficult it becomes to cross the border, the more likely undocumented migrants are to turn to smugglers for help getting across….

It’s not a perfect solution so we shouldn’t bother trying it at all? Aside from that bit of foolishness, the question of coyotes is a wholly unrelated question that needs to be addressed regardless of the measures we take to tighten security at our borders.

[N]o barrier will ever be high enough or secure enough to completely halt attempts to cross the border illegally.

It’s not a perfect solution so we shouldn’t bother trying it at all?

Research shows an uptick in migrant deaths at the border in the years following efforts by the US to tighten security and construct fences to keep undocumented immigrants out.

It’s not a perfect solution so we shouldn’t bother trying it at all? The source of immigration is a wholly unrelated question that needs to be addressed regardless of the measures we take to tighten security at our borders. We should be working with the source countries to get them to/force them to improve their domestic situation so as to reduce the incentives their citizens have to leave in the first place.

In the long run, that’s cheaper than efforts to control—in isolation—illegal immigration at our border, and it’s more prosperous by making those citizens freer in their home countries and making them better markets for our goods and services.

Market Timing

Gerald Driscoll, Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute and former vice president at the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, thinks the Fed should engage in market timing regarding its planned short-term interest rate hike in September—a planned move that he actually calls a course change.

The world markets are in turmoil, he worries, and the Fed should delay its planned hike. Why raise rates now, he asks.

Why not now? Well, the inflation rate doesn’t justify a monetary tightening, he says.

Well, raising interest rates now—or in September as the Fed has said it’s ready to do—from their current suppressed-to-artificially-low rates, and bringing them closer to rates more consistent with the Fed’s price stability goal of 2% inflation isn’t monetary tightening. On the contrary, that would be controls loosening. Letting the market determine interest rates will spur economic growth and national—and individual citizen—prosperity.

Low interest rates were thought to be stimulative. But we have learned that financial intermediaries struggle with spreads in a low-interest-rate environment.

Indeed. Many of us have learned also—and the Fed should have learned this, too—that we all struggle with artificially low interest rates: they’re inconsistent with a robust economy.

The Fed isn’t any better at market timing—at predicting the actions of animal spirits—than any other institution or collection of skilled investors. The key to prosperity is discipline, sticking to a plan even when things seem momentarily uncomfortable.

The Fed should be disciplined and stick to its plan. It shouldn’t try timing the animal spirits.

There’s a Hint Here

Boeing Co is scrambling to renegotiate an about $85 million satellite contract that became the first big casualty of the US Export-Import Bank’s loss of its operating charter due to congressional opposition.

Asia Broadcast Satellite last month terminated its order for a Boeing 702SP satellite, although the two say they are continuing to discuss the deal.

On the other hand,

SpaceX played down the threat, and said only two of the 50 launches in its current manifest were due to be backed by the bank.

And

Orbital ATK has recently relied on the bank for about one satellite deal a year, though doesn’t currently have any Ex-Im backed space business.

Hmm….