New York City has a program, Expanded Success Initiative, that was intended to improve the city’s K-12 “black and Latino males'” (apparently, the girls just don’t matter in New York City) performance. It’s failing; although, the piece at the link is more optimistic than that.
Students…reported better school relationships and more fair treatment than peers in comparable schools outside the program.
Socialization does matter in a child’s development; however….
[A]cademic outcomes and suspension rates remained roughly similar to those in the comparison schools.
Academics are the primary purpose of schools. ESI improved nothing important.
But here’s the kicker, completely missed by the WSJ piece:
Among the first cohort of black and Latino males in the initiative, about 71% graduated high school, 17% hit state benchmarks signifying college-readiness….
In what universe do these numbers make sense? Leaving aside the poor graduation rate, how does a student graduate from high school without being prepared for higher education? I’ve long disputed that college is a necessary next step for high school graduates, but a student not academically prepared for that step isn’t prepared for community college or trade school, nor is he (or she!) prepared to go straight into the work place in any job other than ditch digging or burger flipping.